Skip to content

CA Intermediate · Advanced Accounting

AS 14 Accounting for Amalgamations: Merger vs Purchase Method

AS 14 sets how companies record amalgamations. First test whether it is a merger or a purchase using five conditions. Mergers use pooling of interests at book values. Purchases use the purchase method: fix purchase consideration, record net assets, and show goodwill or capital reserve. Then pass entries and adjust for inter-company items.

What this chapter covers

AS 14 deals with two companies combining. The company that loses its identity is the transferor. The company that takes over is the transferee. The standard first classifies the amalgamation into two types: in the nature of merger and in the nature of purchase. The type decides the accounting method.

A merger uses the pooling of interests method. Assets, liabilities and reserves come across at existing book values. A purchase uses the purchase method. Here you must first compute purchase consideration, then compare it with the net assets taken over. The gap is goodwill or capital reserve. In questions you usually pass entries in the books of the transferor, the transferee, or both.

This chapter ties into the rest of the paper. It uses share capital and reserves from company accounts, and the Schedule III balance sheet format for the final presentation. It also needs AS 4 for events after the balance sheet date. Numerical questions on this chapter are long, so the chapter rewards a clean, step-by-step layout.

Amalgamation is a regular source of long numerical questions, and these questions give many step marks even if one figure goes wrong. The chapter is also highly rule-driven. Once you know the five merger conditions, the two methods and the purchase consideration formulas, most questions follow a fixed pattern. That makes it one of the more scoreable chapters if you practise. Theory points such as the conditions for a merger and the treatment of reserves also appear in MCQs, where a clear rule gets you full marks quickly.

AS 14 Accounting for Amalgamations: topics in the order to study them

  1. 1AS 14 Scope and Types of AmalgamationStart here because every question begins by classifying the amalgamation as merger or purchase.
  2. 2Pooling of Interests MethodIt is the simpler method, with book values and reserves carried over, so it builds your confidence first.
  3. 3Purchase Method and Purchase ConsiderationThis is the core numerical part; learn it after pooling so you can see how the two methods differ.
  4. 4Journal Entries and Ledger Accounts in Books of TransferorOnce you know the consideration, you can close the transferor's books with Realisation Account and related accounts.
  5. 5Inter-company Holdings, Dividends and Other AdjustmentsThese adjustments change the consideration and the net assets, so they come after the basic method is firm.
  6. 6Disclosures and Amalgamation after Balance Sheet DateStudy this last as a short theory block that completes the picture.

How to prepare AS 14 Accounting for Amalgamations

Treat this chapter as a process you repeat for every question. Build the process first, then add the twists.

  1. Learn the five conditions for a merger by heart. If any one fails, the amalgamation is in the nature of purchase.
  2. Write a one-page comparison of pooling and purchase: treatment of assets, reserves, goodwill or capital reserve, and statutory reserves.
  3. Practise the four ways of computing purchase consideration: lump sum, net assets, net payment and intrinsic value. These are a textbook classification, not AS 14 text. Do the same sum by two ways to check yourself.
  4. Solve questions in a fixed layout: classify, compute consideration, list net assets taken over, find goodwill or capital reserve, then pass entries.
  5. Practise the transferor's books separately: Realisation Account, Transferee Company Account, Shareholders' Account and the closing entries.
  6. Add the twists one by one: mutual owings, inter-company holdings, unrealised profit in stock, dividends and liabilities taken over or not taken over.
  7. Finish with a mixed test. Attempt MCQs on conditions and treatment, then one full written question under time.

Common mistakes in AS 14 Accounting for Amalgamations

  • Calling an amalgamation a merger without testing all five conditions

    Fix: Tick each of the five conditions in the answer. Pay special attention to cash payment beyond fractional shares and any change in book values.

  • Including liabilities paid directly by the transferee in the purchase consideration

    Fix: Count only what goes to the transferor's shareholders. Debentures or creditors settled by the transferee are liabilities taken over, not consideration.

  • Carrying over all reserves under the purchase method

    Fix: Under the purchase method, only statutory reserves are recorded in the transferee's books, with an equal debit to Amalgamation Adjustment Account. Other reserves are not recorded.

  • Mixing up goodwill and capital reserve

    Fix: Always write: consideration minus net assets taken over. A positive answer is goodwill. A negative answer is capital reserve.

  • Ignoring inter-company holdings, mutual owings and unrealised profit

    Fix: Underline every fact about transactions between the two companies before you start. Adjust consideration, assets and liabilities, and stock profit as required.

  • Passing entries without a clear working note

    Fix: Show workings for consideration, net assets and goodwill or capital reserve first. Step marks are given for each working even if the final entry is wrong.

Last-day revision: AS 14 Accounting for Amalgamations

  • Transferor is the company absorbed; transferee is the company that takes over.
  • Merger needs all five conditions; failing even one makes it a purchase.
  • For a merger, shareholders holding at least 90% of the face value of the transferor's equity shares (other than those held by the transferee, its subsidiaries or their nominees) must become equity shareholders of the transferee.
  • In a merger, consideration to equity shareholders is wholly in equity shares; cash is allowed only for fractional shares.
  • Pooling of interests: assets and liabilities at existing carrying amounts, and reserves preserved in the same form.
  • Under pooling, the difference between the share capital issued (plus other consideration) and the transferor's share capital is adjusted in reserves.
  • Purchase consideration is shares and securities issued plus cash or other assets paid by the transferee to the transferor's shareholders.
  • Purchase consideration excludes liabilities that the transferee pays directly to outsiders.
  • Net assets method (a textbook method, not AS 14 text): purchase consideration equals the agreed value of the assets actually taken over less the liabilities actually taken over. Count only assets and liabilities taken over, at agreed values.
  • Under the purchase method, consideration above the net assets taken over is goodwill; consideration below is capital reserve.
  • Under the purchase method, the transferor's reserves are not carried over, except statutory reserves. These are recorded in the transferee's books with an equal debit to Amalgamation Adjustment Account, which is reversed when the reserve is later reversed.
  • Cancel mutual owings and shares held by one company in the other, and remove unrealised profit on stock in the transferee's books.
  • An amalgamation after the balance sheet date but before approval of the financial statements is disclosed as a non-adjusting event under AS 4.

AS 14 Accounting for Amalgamations practice questions

AS 14 Accounting for Amalgamations in other exams

The same ground in other exams, if you are preparing for more than one or want another angle on it.

AS 14 Accounting for Amalgamations: frequently asked questions

What is the difference between merger and purchase under AS 14?

A merger meets all five conditions of AS 14, including issue of equity shares as consideration and no change in book values. Any other amalgamation is in the nature of purchase. The merger uses the pooling of interests method and the purchase uses the purchase method.

How do I calculate purchase consideration quickly?

Identify what the transferor's shareholders receive: shares, securities and cash. Add only those items. If the question gives agreed asset values, you can cross-check with the net assets method, which is the assets actually taken over less the liabilities actually taken over, at agreed values.

Is goodwill always written off in the transferee's books?

Goodwill is not written off immediately. AS 14 requires goodwill arising on amalgamation in the nature of purchase to be amortised systematically over its useful life, presumed not to exceed five years unless a longer period is justified. Read the question for the period it states.

Do I need entries in both companies' books?

It depends on the question. Some ask for the transferor's books only, with Realisation Account and related closing entries. Others ask for the transferee's entries or the balance sheet after amalgamation. Read the requirement first, then plan your layout.