CS Professional · Insolvency and Bankruptcy - Law and Practice · Group Insolvency
Three companies of a promoter group owe money to the same bank, and each has its own board and balance sheet. The bank files separate Section 7 applications against each of them. In which manner does the Indian IBC framework, as applied in judicial decisions, generally treat these companies for insolvency purposes?
Group companies are treated as separate legal entities, each facing its own CIRP. Judicial decisions do not automatically consolidate them on the basis of common promoters or financial linkages, because the IBC contains no statutory provision for automatic substantive consolidation of group entities.
- AAs separate legal entities, each undergoing its own CIRP, with no automatic substantive consolidationCorrect
- BAs a single debtor, with one CIRP covering all group companies automatically
- CAs one entity, with the group holding company's resolution professional controlling all the others
- DAs a single estate, whose assets are pooled once the first company is admitted
Explanation
The IBC treats each corporate debtor as a distinct legal person. Courts have held that group companies are not automatically merged merely because they share a promoter or financial dealings. Options suggesting a single CIRP or automatic pooling of assets ignore this separate-entity principle.
Did you get it right without looking?
One question tells you little. A timed set on Group Insolvency shows your real accuracy, how long you take and where you lose marks.
More Group Insolvency questions
- A promoter's group has four companies, each admitted into CIRP by the NCLT on separate dates. A single IRP is proposed for all four on the g…
- Alpha Ltd and Beta Ltd are group companies in separate CIRPs. The same insolvency professional is proposed as resolution professional for bo…
- Alpha Steel Ltd, Alpha Power Ltd and Alpha Logistics Ltd are group companies of the Alpha Group. All three have defaulted to lenders, and a …
- The CoC of Alpha Ltd. is also the CoC of its sister company Beta Ltd., and both are in CIRP with a common resolution applicant. The NCLT is …
- The Insolvency Law Committee examined group insolvency and proposed a framework limited to a particular kind of coordination. Which approach…
- Meera, an insolvency professional, is advising on a group where Parent Ltd and its two subsidiaries are all in CIRP. She says that group ins…