FRM Part II · FRM Exam Part II · Estimating Market Risk Measures: An Introduction and Overview
Which is the main advantage of using a QQ plot rather than a histogram overlaid with a fitted density to assess whether returns follow a given distribution for risk measurement purposes?
A QQ plot makes tail departures easier to see. Histograms are dominated by the central mass of observations, whereas QQ plots compare quantiles directly and highlight differences in the extreme tails, which are what drive VaR and expected shortfall.
- AIt gives a formal p-value for rejecting the distribution
- BIt makes departures in the tails easier to see, where VaR and expected shortfall are determinedCorrect
- CIt automatically estimates the distribution's parameters without any fitting
- DIt removes the effect of outliers from the sample
Explanation
Histograms emphasize the center of the distribution, where most observations lie, so tail discrepancies are hard to see. A QQ plot compares quantiles directly and magnifies tail differences relevant to VaR and ES. It is a graphical tool, provides no p-value, does not estimate parameters by itself, and does not remove outliers.
Did you get it right without looking?
One question tells you little. A timed set on Estimating Market Risk Measures: An Introduction and Overview shows your real accuracy, how long you take and where you lose marks.
More Estimating Market Risk Measures: An Introduction and Overview questions
- An analyst plots the ordered sample of 200 returns against a reference distribution. The sample mean is 0% and standard deviation is 2%. A Q…
- A risk team applies the BRW (age-weighted) approach to historical simulation with decay factor λ = 0.98 and a very long window. The weight o…
- A risk manager reviews four candidate risk measures for a trading desk. Under the axioms of coherence (monotonicity, subadditivity, positive…
- A bank's risk committee compares VaR with expected shortfall (ES) for a portfolio containing short option positions with a highly skewed, fa…
- A bank has two independent bonds, each with a 4% chance of default within the horizon, and a loss of USD 100 if default occurs (otherwise ze…
- A portfolio's daily returns are normally distributed with mean zero and standard deviation 1.5% of a USD 80 million portfolio. Using z-value…