IAI Actuarial Core Principles · Economic Modelling
Single and multifactor models for investment returns: formula sheet
Key formulas
- Market model
- R_i = α_i + β_i R_M + e_i
- E(e_i) = 0, Cov(e_i, R_M) = 0, Cov(e_i, e_j) = 0 for i ≠ j.
- Expected return
- E(R_i) = α_i + β_i E(R_M)
- Take expectations of the model; the residual has mean zero.
- Beta
- β_i = Cov(R_i, R_M) ÷ Var(R_M) = ρ_iM σ_i ÷ σ_M
- This is also the slope of the regression of R_i on R_M.
- Alpha
- α_i = E(R_i) − β_i E(R_M)
- The intercept of the regression line.
- Variance of a security
- σ_i² = β_i² σ_M² + σ_ei²
- Systematic part plus specific part.
- Covariance between two securities
- Cov(R_i, R_j) = β_i β_j σ_M²
- Holds for i ≠ j because residuals are uncorrelated.
- Portfolio beta
- β_P = Σ w_i β_i
- Weights w_i sum to 1.
- Portfolio variance
- σ_P² = β_P² σ_M² + Σ w_i² σ_ei²
- Specific risk falls as the portfolio is diversified.
- Multifactor return model
- R_i = a_i + b_i1 F_1 + b_i2 F_2 + ... + b_iK F_K + e_i
- F_k are factors, b_ik sensitivities, e_i specific return with E(e_i) = 0, uncorrelated with the factors and with other securities' specific terms.
- APT expected return
- E(R_i) = r_f + b_i1 λ_1 + b_i2 λ_2 + ... + b_iK λ_K
- λ_k is the risk premium per unit of sensitivity to factor k. Here r_f is the return on a risk-free asset (sensitivity zero to all factors).
- Factor premium as excess return
- λ_k = E(R_P,k) − r_f
- R_P,k is a portfolio with sensitivity 1 to factor k and 0 to all others. This is the usual way to read premiums from data.
- Portfolio sensitivity
- b_Pk = Σ w_i b_ik
- Weights w_i sum to 1. Sensitivities are weighted averages, so portfolio factor exposure is linear in the weights.
- Variance of a return (uncorrelated factors)
- Var(R_i) = Σ b_ik² Var(F_k) + Var(e_i)
- Valid only if factors are mutually uncorrelated. With correlated factors, add 2 b_ij b_ik Cov(F_j, F_k) terms.
- Covariance between two securities
- Cov(R_i, R_j) = Σ_k Σ_l b_ik b_jl Cov(F_k, F_l)
- Assumes specific returns are uncorrelated. With uncorrelated factors it reduces to Σ b_ik b_jk Var(F_k).
- CAPM as a one-factor case
- E(R_i) = r_f + β_i [E(R_M) − r_f]
- Here the single factor is the market and λ_1 = E(R_M) − r_f.
- General multifactor model
- R_i = a_i + b_i1 F_1 + b_i2 F_2 + ... + b_ik F_k + e_i
- F_j are common factors, b_ij are sensitivities, e_i is specific return with zero mean, uncorrelated with the factors and with other securities' e.
- Expected return
- E(R_i) = a_i + b_i1 E(F_1) + ... + b_ik E(F_k)
- Follows because E(e_i) = 0. If factors are defined with zero mean, E(R_i) = a_i.
- Variance of return
- Var(R_i) = Σ_j Σ_l b_ij b_il Cov(F_j, F_l) + Var(e_i)
- If factors are uncorrelated this reduces to Σ_j b_ij² Var(F_j) + Var(e_i).
- Covariance between two securities
- Cov(R_i, R_m) = Σ_j Σ_l b_ij b_ml Cov(F_j, F_l)
- The specific returns add nothing because they are uncorrelated across securities. This is the parameter saving.
- Fama-French three-factor model
- R_i − R_f = α_i + β_i (R_M − R_f) + s_i SMB + h_i HML + e_i
- SMB = return on small-cap minus large-cap portfolio. HML = return on high minus low book-to-market portfolio. R_f is the risk-free rate.
- Portfolio sensitivity
- b_pj = Σ_i w_i b_ij
- Portfolio loadings are the weighted average of the security loadings, with weights w_i summing to 1.
- Single index model
- R_i = α_i + β_i R_M + ε_i
- E(ε_i) = 0, Cov(ε_i, R_M) = 0, Cov(ε_i, ε_j) = 0 for i ≠ j.
- Variance of a security (single factor)
- σ_i² = β_i² σ_M² + σ_εi²
- Systematic plus specific variance.
- Covariance of two securities (single factor)
- Cov(R_i, R_j) = β_i β_j σ_M² (i ≠ j)
- Holds only if residuals are uncorrelated.
- Portfolio beta
- β_P = Σ w_i β_i
- Weights w_i sum to 1. Same rule applies to each factor loading.
- Portfolio variance (single factor)
- σ_P² = β_P² σ_M² + Σ w_i² σ_εi²
- The specific term shrinks as the portfolio becomes diversified.
- Multifactor expected return (APT form)
- E(R_i) = r_f + b_i1 λ_1 + b_i2 λ_2 + ... + b_ik λ_k
- λ_j is the risk premium for factor j.
- Attribution of return
- R_P − R_B = Σ (b_Pj − b_Bj) F_j + (α_P − α_B)
- Active return = factor-tilt effects plus selection effect (benchmark B).
Quick revision
- Single factor model: Rᵢ = aᵢ + bᵢ·I + cᵢ, with cᵢ having zero mean.
- The market model uses a market index return as the factor.
- bᵢ measures sensitivity to the factor; it is the slope in a regression on the factor.
- Total variance of a security = bᵢ²·Var(I) + Var(cᵢ), as the error is uncorrelated with the factor.
- Covariance between two securities i and j = bᵢ·bⱼ·Var(I) when errors are uncorrelated.
- Systematic risk comes from the factors and cannot be diversified away; specific risk can be.
- A portfolio's sensitivity is the weighted average of its securities' sensitivities.
- Multifactor model adds further factors, each with its own sensitivity.
- APT is based on no-arbitrage, not on investor preferences.
- Three types: macroeconomic, fundamental and statistical factor models.
- Limitations: factors may be wrongly chosen, sensitivities may change over time, and past data may not predict the future.
- Always state your assumptions before computing.
Common mistakes
- Saying deterministic models are wrong or useless. Fix: State that deterministic models suit simple projections, sensitivity tests and communication. Choose by purpose.
- Confusing stochastic with statistical. Fix: Stochastic vs deterministic is about randomness in the model. Statistical vs economic is about how the model is built.
- Dividing covariance by the standard deviation of the market instead of its variance. Fix: Beta = Cov(R_i, R_M) ÷ σ_M². Square the standard deviation first.
- Forgetting to square beta in the systematic variance. Fix: Variance scales with the square of the multiplier: systematic variance = β²σ_M².
- Using total factor returns instead of risk premiums in the APT formula. Fix: Check that each λ_k is an excess return. If given a factor portfolio's total return, subtract r_f first.
- Saying APT needs the market portfolio or mean-variance investors. Fix: State that APT rests on a factor structure, well-diversified portfolios and no arbitrage. It does not need an equilibrium or a market portfolio.
- Calling Fama-French a macroeconomic model because it has a market factor. Fix: Classify by the extra factors. SMB and HML come from company characteristics (size, book-to-market), so it is fundamental-type.
- Saying statistical factors always have a clear economic meaning. Fix: State that statistical factors are extracted from data and may be hard to interpret. This is their main limitation.
- Adding specific variances without squaring weights. Fix: Specific variance of a portfolio is Σ w_i² σ_εi², not Σ w_i σ_εi².
- Using Cov(R_i, R_j) = β_iβ_jσ_M² when residuals are correlated. Fix: State that residuals are uncorrelated. If not, add the residual covariance term.
Exam tips
- Define each term in one line before comparing. Many marks go for clear definitions.
- Always tie your answer to the stated purpose. Generic lists score less.
- For comparison questions, give both advantages and disadvantages of each side.
- In MCQs, check whether the option talks about randomness (stochastic) or construction (statistical or economic).
- Mention calibration and parameter uncertainty when asked to evaluate a model.
- Write the model and its assumptions first. Examiners give marks for stating that residuals are uncorrelated with the market and with each other.
- Always check whether the question gives a standard deviation or a variance before you compute beta.
- In written answers, explain what the result means: systematic risk cannot be diversified away, specific risk can.