CA Final · Integrated Business Solutions (Multidisciplinary Case Study with Strategic Management)
Strategic Cost & Performance Management: formula sheet
Key formulas
- Target cost
- Target cost = Target selling price − Target profit
- Target profit may be given as a percentage of selling price or of cost. Read which one it is.
- Cost reduction gap
- Cost gap = Current (estimated) cost − Target cost
- This is the amount the team must remove through design and process changes.
- Cost driver rate (ABC)
- Rate per unit of driver = Cost of activity cost pool ÷ Total quantity of cost driver
- Compute one rate per cost pool.
- Overhead assigned to a product (ABC)
- Overhead = Σ (Driver quantity used by product × Rate per unit of driver)
- Add the charge from every pool, then divide by units to get overhead per unit.
- Kaizen cost target
- Target cost for period = Previous period cost × (1 − Kaizen reduction %)
- Applied to cost already in production.
- Life cycle cost per unit
- Life cycle cost per unit = Total life cycle cost ÷ Total units produced over the life
- Total includes design, development, production, marketing, distribution, service and disposal costs as given.
- Cost-plus price
- Price = Cost base + Mark-up % × Cost base
- State the cost base used. Mark-up is on cost; margin is on selling price.
- Mark-up and margin link
- Margin % = Mark-up % ÷ (100 + Mark-up %)
- A 25% mark-up on cost equals a 20% margin on price.
- Target cost
- Target cost = Target selling price − Target profit
- Used in market-led pricing. The gap to current cost is the cost reduction needed.
- Minimum transfer price (general rule)
- Minimum TP = Variable cost per unit + Contribution lost per unit on external sales forgone
- With spare capacity at the seller, the lost contribution is nil, so the minimum is variable cost.
- Maximum transfer price
- Maximum TP = Lower of (external purchase price net of savings, buyer's net realisable value per unit)
- The buyer will not pay more than this.
- Special order test
- Accept if Order revenue > Incremental cost + Opportunity cost
- Ignore sunk and unchanged fixed costs.
- Limiting factor ranking
- Contribution per unit of scarce resource = Contribution per unit ÷ Scarce resource per unit
- Use when capacity is short and several uses compete.
- Contribution
- Contribution = Sales − Variable cost
- Use this as the base for most short-term decisions. Fixed costs come in only if they change.
- Relevant cost of material
- Material to be bought: current purchase price. Held and regularly used (will be replaced): replacement cost. Held with an alternative use and not replaced: contribution from the alternative use. Held with no other use: higher of resale/scrap value and value in the job
- Historic cost is never relevant. For material with no other use, the relevant cost is the opportunity cost: the higher of its resale or scrap value and its value in the job.
- Relevant cost of labour
- Spare capacity: nil extra cost (if paid anyway). Fully used: wage paid + contribution lost per hour
- Idle time paid in any case is not a relevant cost.
- Make-or-buy rule
- Make if avoidable cost of making < purchase price. Buy if purchase price < avoidable cost of making
- Avoidable cost = variable cost + fixed costs that would be saved. Add any benefit from using freed capacity.
- Shutdown rule (short run)
- Continue if Contribution > Avoidable fixed costs. Shut if Contribution < Avoidable fixed costs
- Allocated fixed costs that continue after closure are ignored.
- Limiting factor ranking
- Contribution per unit of limiting factor = Contribution per unit ÷ Units of scarce resource per unit
- Rank products by this figure and allocate the scarce resource in that order, up to the demand limit.
- Special order rule
- Accept if Incremental revenue > Incremental cost
- Include extra fixed costs and lost sales from existing customers if any.
- Material cost variance
- MCV = (SQ × SP) − (AQ × AP)
- SQ is standard quantity for actual output. MCV = price variance + usage variance.
- Material price and usage
- MPV = AQ × (SP − AP); MUV = SP × (SQ − AQ)
- Positive is favourable, negative is adverse. Calculate price on quantity purchased if the question says price is isolated at purchase.
- Material mix and yield
- Mix = SP × (RSQ − AQ); Yield = SP × (SQ − RSQ); MUV = Mix + Yield
- RSQ is total actual input quantity split in the standard mix ratio. Apply per material and add.
- Labour variances
- LCV = (SH × SR) − (AH paid × AR); LRV = AH paid × (SR − AR); Idle time = idle hours × SR (adverse); LEV = SR × (SH − AH worked)
- SH is standard hours for actual output. Labour rate variance uses hours paid. Efficiency uses hours worked.
- Variable overhead variances
- Expenditure = (AH × SR) − Actual VOH; Efficiency = SR × (SH − AH)
- SR is the standard variable overhead rate per hour.
- Fixed overhead variances
- Expenditure = Budgeted FO − Actual FO; Volume = Absorbed FO − Budgeted FO; Absorbed FO = Standard rate × Actual output (in the same unit)
- Volume splits into capacity, efficiency and, if given, calendar variances. Expenditure plus volume gives the total fixed overhead variance.
- Sales price and volume (profit method)
- Price = AQ × (AP − SP); Volume = Standard profit per unit × (AQ − BQ)
- BQ is budgeted quantity. Price plus volume gives the sales profit variance.
- Sales mix and quantity
- Mix = Std profit per unit × (AQ − RAQ); Quantity = Std profit per unit × (RAQ − BQ)
- RAQ is total actual quantity split in the budgeted mix. Mix plus quantity equals volume.
- Flexible budget
- Flexed cost = Variable cost per unit × Actual activity + Fixed cost
- Use for semi-variable costs after splitting them into fixed and variable parts.
- Return on Investment (ROI)
- ROI = Divisional profit ÷ Capital employed (investment) × 100
- Use the profit and capital basis stated in the question. A manager may reject a project whose return is above the cost of capital but below the current ROI.
- Residual Income (RI)
- RI = Divisional profit − (Capital employed × Required rate of return)
- Gives a money figure. Accept projects with positive RI.
- Economic Value Added (EVA)
- EVA = NOPAT − (Capital employed × WACC)
- NOPAT = operating profit after tax, with adjustments if the question asks (for example R&D treated as investment). Positive EVA means value is created.
- NOPAT
- NOPAT = EBIT × (1 − tax rate)
- Use operating profit before interest, as the capital charge already covers financing cost.
- Weighted Average Cost of Capital
- WACC = (E ÷ V × Ke) + (D ÷ V × Kd × (1 − t))
- Use market or given weights. Cost of debt is taken after tax.
- Four Balanced Scorecard perspectives
- Financial, Customer, Internal Business Process, Learning and Growth
- Each has objectives, measures, targets and initiatives.
- Throughput
- Throughput = Sales revenue − Totally variable cost (usually direct material)
- Direct labour is normally treated as an operating expense in throughput accounting unless the question says it is variable with output.
- Throughput per unit
- Throughput per unit = Selling price per unit − Direct material cost per unit
- Use the same basis for every product when ranking.
- Throughput per bottleneck hour
- Throughput per bottleneck hour = Throughput per unit ÷ Bottleneck hours per unit
- Rank products on this figure, highest first, to use the scarce resource best.
- Total Factory Cost (TA)
- Total factory cost = Direct labour + Factory overheads (operating expenses)
- Used in the cost per factory hour calculation.
- Cost per factory hour
- Cost per factory hour = Total factory cost ÷ Total hours available on the bottleneck resource
- Use bottleneck hours as the denominator.
- Throughput accounting ratio (TAR)
- TAR = Throughput per bottleneck hour ÷ Cost per factory hour
- TAR > 1 means the product earns more than the cost of the factory time it uses. TAR < 1 means it does not cover factory cost. A higher TAR is better.
- Net profit under TA
- Net profit = Total throughput − Total operating expenses
- Operating expenses are treated as fixed in the short run.
- Target cost
- Target cost = Target selling price − Target profit margin
- The market sets the price. The firm must design cost down to the target cost.
Quick revision
- Relevant cost is a future, incremental cash flow that differs between alternatives.
- Sunk costs and committed costs are not relevant to the decision.
- Opportunity cost counts as relevant when a resource is scarce or has an alternative use.
- Target cost = target selling price − target profit margin.
- Life cycle costing looks at costs from design through to disposal, not only production.
- ABC assigns overheads through cost drivers to activities, then to products.
- Variance = actual − standard, read as favourable or adverse by its effect on profit.
- With a limiting factor, rank products by contribution per unit of that factor.
- Penetration pricing starts low to win share; skimming starts high and reduces over time.
- The balanced scorecard has financial, customer, internal process, and learning and growth perspectives.
- Always add qualitative factors such as quality, capacity, supplier reliability and morale to a make-or-buy recommendation.
- Reconcile your numbers: totals of variances must match the difference between standard and actual.
Common mistakes
- Treating target profit as a percentage of cost when it is given on selling price. Fix: Underline the base in the question. If profit is 20% of selling price, target cost is 80% of price.
- Confusing target costing with Kaizen costing. Fix: Remember: target costing is at design stage and market-driven; Kaizen is at production stage and compares with last period's actual cost.
- Using full cost for a special order when spare capacity exists. Fix: Use incremental cost. Ignore fixed costs that do not change.
- Forgetting the opportunity cost when capacity is full. Fix: Ask what is displaced. Add its lost contribution to the variable cost.
- Including apportioned fixed overheads in a make-or-buy or shutdown comparison. Fix: Split fixed costs into avoidable and unavoidable. Include only the avoidable ones.
- Using the historic purchase cost of material already in stock. Fix: Use replacement cost, resale value or the contribution lost from the next best use, whichever the facts support.
- Calculating usage or efficiency variance on budgeted output instead of actual output. Fix: Always compute SQ or SH for the actual output first. Only fixed overhead volume uses a comparison with budget.
- Using the wrong sign convention so favourable and adverse are swapped. Fix: For costs, standard minus actual is favourable when positive. For sales and profit, actual minus standard is favourable when positive. State F or A next to each answer.
- Using profit after interest in EVA instead of NOPAT. Fix: Start from operating profit (EBIT), apply tax, then charge capital at WACC. Financing cost is covered by the capital charge.
- Using pre-tax cost of debt in WACC. Fix: Always write Kd × (1 − t) unless the question gives the after-tax cost.
Exam tips
- In case studies, name the technique first and then link it to facts from the case. Generic theory earns fewer marks.
- For ABC numericals, show the rate for each pool and a check total. Marks are given for method even if one figure slips.
- Expect questions asking you to distinguish between two techniques, such as target and Kaizen costing. Prepare a short comparison on stage, focus and benchmark.
- Since Paper 6 is open book, keep a one-page summary of formulas and definitions in your file, but practise enough that you do not need to search for them.
- End every descriptive answer with a recommendation that fits the case, in provision-facts-conclusion style: concept, case fact, advice.
- Read the capacity line first. It decides whether opportunity cost enters the answer.
- In case studies, quote the facts from the scenario when naming a strategy, such as inelastic demand for skimming.
- Show the minimum and maximum transfer prices separately, then the negotiated range.