CFA Level I · CFA Level I Exam
Fiscal Policy: formula sheet
Key formulas
- Government budget balance
- Balance = Tax revenue − Government spending
- Positive means surplus, negative means deficit. Spending here includes transfers and interest.
- Expansionary fiscal stance
- Higher spending and/or lower taxes → higher aggregate demand
- Used to fight recession. Usually widens the deficit.
- Contractionary fiscal stance
- Lower spending and/or higher taxes → lower aggregate demand
- Used to cool an overheating economy or reduce inflation pressure.
- Tool classification
- Spending: transfers, current, capital. Revenue: direct (income, wealth), indirect (VAT, excise, tariffs)
- Most exam items test which bucket a given measure falls in.
- Budget balance
- Budget balance = Government revenue (taxes) − Government spending
- Negative means a deficit, positive means a surplus.
- Aggregate demand components
- AD = C + I + G + (X − M)
- Fiscal policy acts directly on G and, through taxes and transfers, on C and I.
- Expansionary stance
- Higher G and/or lower taxes → AD shifts right
- Typical effect: higher output and employment, upward pressure on prices, larger deficit.
- Contractionary stance
- Lower G and/or higher taxes → AD shifts left
- Typical effect: lower output and inflation pressure, smaller deficit.
- Budget balance
- Deficit = Government spending − Tax revenue
- A positive result is a deficit. Spending includes interest on existing debt.
- Primary balance
- Primary balance = Revenue − (Spending excluding interest)
- Shows the budget position before the cost of past debt.
- Debt-to-GDP ratio
- Debt ratio = Public debt ÷ GDP
- Main measure of debt burden. Use nominal values for both.
- Debt ratio stability condition
- Ratio rises if (r − g) × (D/Y) + (primary deficit/Y) > 0
- r = interest rate on debt, g = nominal GDP growth, D/Y = debt-to-GDP. Ratio is stable when this sum equals zero, and falls when it is negative. This is a first-order approximation.
- Rule of thumb
- If g > r, a country can run a primary deficit of up to (g − r) × D/Y and keep the ratio stable
- A larger primary deficit still raises the ratio. If r > g, a primary surplus is needed to hold the ratio steady when debt is positive.
- Total lag of discretionary policy
- Total delay = recognition lag + action lag + impact lag
- Recognition and action lags are decision delays. Impact lag is the delay before the policy takes effect in the economy.
- Automatic stabilizer rule
- Income falls → tax receipts fall and transfers rise; income rises → tax receipts rise and transfers fall
- Needs no new legislation, so there is no action lag. Stabilizers reduce, but do not eliminate, cyclical swings.
- Budget balance
- Budget deficit = government spending − tax revenue
- Stabilizers widen the deficit in a recession without any policy decision.
- Easy money, easy fiscal
- Output ↑ ; interest rates ↕ (unclear) ; public sector ↑ ; private sector ↑
- Both boost aggregate demand. Output is higher. The effect on rates is mixed: monetary lowers them, fiscal borrowing raises them.
- Tight money, tight fiscal
- Output ↓ ; interest rates ↕ (unclear) ; public sector ↓ ; private sector ↓
- Both reduce aggregate demand. Output is lower. The effect on rates is mixed: tight money raises them, but reduced government borrowing lowers them.
- Tight money, easy fiscal
- Output ↕ (unclear) ; interest rates ↑↑ ; public sector ↑ ; private sector ↓
- Government spends more and borrows. Tight money and heavy borrowing both raise rates. High rates crowd out private investment.
- Easy money, tight fiscal
- Output ↕ (unclear) ; interest rates ↓↓ ; public sector ↓ ; private sector ↑
- Easy money and less government borrowing both lower rates. Low rates and a smaller deficit leave room for private investment.
- Aggregate demand link
- Easy policy → AD ↑ ; Tight policy → AD ↓
- Use this to decide output when both policies point the same way.
Quick revision
- Fiscal policy uses government spending and taxation; monetary policy uses interest rates and money supply.
- Expansionary policy: higher spending or lower taxes, which raises demand and usually widens the deficit.
- Contractionary policy: lower spending or higher taxes, which reduces demand and usually narrows the deficit.
- Spending multiplier = 1 ÷ [1 − MPC × (1 − t)].
- With a tax rate above zero, the multiplier is smaller than 1 ÷ (1 − MPC).
- Government spending changes usually have a larger multiplier than equal tax changes, because some of a tax cut is saved.
- Ricardian equivalence: people save today to pay expected future taxes, which offsets the deficit's stimulus.
- Crowding out: government borrowing pushes up interest rates and reduces private investment.
- Implementation lags: recognition, action and impact lags can make policy arrive late.
- A deficit adds to public debt; debt is usually compared with GDP.
- Automatic stabilizers, such as progressive taxes and unemployment benefits, work without new decisions.
- Fiscal and monetary policy can reinforce or offset each other, so always check both settings.
Common mistakes
- Treating transfer payments as government purchases of goods and services. Fix: Transfers move income without buying output. They are spending in the budget but not part of government purchases in GDP.
- Calling VAT or sales tax a direct tax. Fix: Direct taxes hit income or wealth. Taxes on goods and services are indirect, even if firms remit them.
- Treating a tax increase as expansionary. Fix: Think of the private sector: higher taxes reduce disposable income, so demand falls. Tax increase is contractionary.
- Assuming a larger deficit always means expansionary policy. Fix: Separate the automatic cyclical change from discretionary action. Judge the stance by deliberate changes in spending and tax rates.
- Treating the deficit and the debt as the same thing. Fix: Remember deficit is a yearly flow and debt is the accumulated stock. Deficits add to debt.
- Saying crowding out always happens. Fix: Link it to the economy's state. It is strongest near full capacity and weaker with idle resources.
- Saying automatic stabilizers have an action lag. Fix: Stabilizers are built into existing law, so no new decision is needed. They have essentially no action lag.
- Mixing up action lag and impact lag. Fix: Action lag ends when the measure is enacted. Impact lag starts after that and ends when the economy responds.
- Stating a definite output effect when the policies conflict Fix: For tight money with easy fiscal, or easy money with tight fiscal, output is uncertain. Look for that wording.
- Saying interest rates fall when both policies are easy Fix: With both easy, the rate effect is unclear. Monetary pushes rates down, fiscal borrowing pushes them up.
Exam tips
- Questions are usually classification or direction items. Name the tool first, then the effect.
- Check the economic condition before the policy: the same tool is expansionary or contractionary depending on direction.
- Watch for words like transfer, capital, direct and indirect. Each one points to a precise definition.
- Remember automatic stabilisers need no new decision. That detail often separates two options.
- With no penalty for wrong answers, always answer. Eliminate options that move demand the wrong way first.
- Questions are usually direction questions. Decide expansionary or contractionary first, then read the options.
- Watch for cases where a deficit rises because of a recession. The stem will say whether the change is discretionary or automatic.
- When spending and taxes move in opposite directions, check which change is larger or whether the stem states the net effect.