CFA Level III · Level III Core
Portfolio Management for Institutional Investors: formula sheet
Key formulas
- IPS structure
- Objectives (return, risk) + Constraints (liquidity, time horizon, taxes, legal/regulatory, unique circumstances)
- Use this frame for every institutional investor. Write one line per element, each linked to the liabilities.
- Spending-rule return requirement
- Required nominal return = (1 + spending rate + cost rate) × (1 + inflation) − 1, approximately spending rate + cost rate + inflation
- Use it for endowments and foundations that must preserve real capital. The additive approximation is slightly lower than the exact figure; state it as an approximation unless asked for the exact value.
- Funded ratio
- Funded ratio = Plan assets ÷ Present value of plan liabilities
- Below 100% means a deficit. A weak funded ratio reduces the plan's ability to take risk.
- Surplus
- Surplus = Assets − Liabilities
- Liability-relative investors manage the surplus, not the assets alone.
- Bank net interest margin idea
- Net interest income = Interest earned on assets − Interest paid on liabilities
- Banks care about the spread and about asset-liability mismatch in duration and liquidity.
- Funded status
- Funded status = Plan assets − Present value of plan liability
- A negative value is a deficit (underfunded). A positive value is a surplus.
- Funded ratio
- Funded ratio = Plan assets ÷ Present value of plan liability
- Below 1 means underfunded. Use the same liability measure the question specifies.
- Liability sensitivity to rates
- %ΔLiability ≈ −Duration × ΔDiscount rate
- Approximation for small changes. Falling rates raise the liability.
- Risk tolerance rule
- Risk tolerance = lower of ability and willingness
- If one is below average and the other above, the overall result is the more conservative one.
- Risk allocation in DB plans
- DB: sponsor bears investment, longevity and funding risk
- Benefit is fixed by formula. The sponsor must fund any shortfall.
- Risk allocation in DC plans
- DC: participant bears investment, longevity and decision risk
- Sponsor bears fiduciary risk in menu and default design, not funding risk.
- Cash balance account roll-forward
- Ending balance = Beginning balance + Pay credit + Interest credit
- Interest credit is a stated rate, for example a fixed rate or an index-linked rate, not the actual portfolio return. Pay credit is usually a percentage of pay.
- Interest credit
- Interest credit = Beginning balance × Credit rate
- Use the beginning balance unless the question says contributions earn interest in the year.
- Nominal required return
- (1 + spending rate + cost rate) × (1 + inflation) − 1
- Use this geometric form when the exam asks for precision. It is the CFA curriculum's convention: the spending and cost rates are treated as real rates, so their sum is the real need, which you then compound with inflation.
- Approximate required return
- Spending rate + cost rate + inflation
- Fine as a quick check. Say which version you used.
- Real required return
- Spending rate + cost rate
- The return above inflation needed to preserve real capital. This holds because the spending and cost rates are treated as real, as in the nominal formula above.
- Simple spending rule
- Spending = spending rate × market value at start of period
- Volatile spending that tracks the market.
- Rolling-average rule
- Spending = spending rate × average market value of last n periods
- Smooths spending but lags market moves.
- Geometric (hybrid) rule
- Spending(t) = w × [Spending(t−1) × (1 + inflation)] + (1 − w) × [spending rate × MV(t−1)]
- w is the smoothing weight on the inflation-adjusted prior spending. Use the weight given in the question.
- Net interest margin
- NIM = (Interest income − Interest expense) ÷ Average interest-earning assets
- Bank profitability measure; the core return driver for a bank.
- Duration gap
- Duration gap = Duration of assets − (Liabilities ÷ Assets) × Duration of liabilities
- The gap is leverage-adjusted, because liability duration is scaled by Liabilities ÷ Assets. A positive gap means asset dollar duration exceeds liability dollar duration, so a rise in rates reduces surplus (equity) and a fall in rates increases it. A negative gap works the other way: a rise in rates increases surplus and a fall reduces it.
- Change in surplus (approx.)
- ΔSurplus ≈ −D_A × A × Δy + D_L × L × Δy
- Surplus = Assets − Liabilities. Δy is a parallel shift in yields, the same for assets and liabilities. D is modified duration. Use consistent duration measures for both sides.
- Change in surplus from the duration gap
- ΔSurplus ≈ −(Duration gap) × A × Δy
- This is the same result as the line above, written with the leverage-adjusted gap. For example, a gap of −1.2 with A = 500 million and Δy = +0.005 gives −(−1.2) × 500 × 0.005 = +3.0 million.
- Combined ratio (non-life)
- Combined ratio = Loss ratio + Expense ratio
- Above 100% means an underwriting loss; investment income must cover it.
- Liability matching rule
- Match asset duration and cash flows to liabilities; add liquidity where liabilities have options
- Short, uncertain liabilities need liquid, short, high-quality assets; long, predictable ones allow longer, less liquid assets.
- SWF type to profile
- Stabilization: high liquidity, low risk, short horizon | Savings: long horizon, higher risk, illiquids allowed
- This is a guide to reasoning. Always check the facts given in the vignette.
- IPS structure
- Objectives (return, risk) + Constraints (liquidity, time horizon, tax, legal and regulatory, unique circumstances)
- Use this checklist for any institution.
- Required return for a spending fund
- Required nominal return ≈ spending rate + inflation + costs
- A simple approximation. Use it only when the question gives these inputs.
- Surplus
- Surplus = Market value of assets − Present value of liabilities
- Funded ratio = Assets ÷ PV of liabilities. A ratio below 1 means a deficit.
- Surplus return
- Surplus return = (Change in surplus) ÷ (Beginning assets)
- Check which base your question uses. Surplus return is often measured relative to beginning assets.
- Immunization conditions
- PV(assets) = PV(liabilities); Duration(assets) = Duration(liabilities); Convexity(assets) ≥ Convexity(liabilities)
- Protects against small parallel yield shifts only. Rebalance as time and yields change.
- Duration matching with weights
- w1 × D1 + w2 × D2 = D(liabilities), where w1 + w2 = 1
- Solve for w1 using w1 = (DL − D2) ÷ (D1 − D2) when two assets are used.
- Approximate price change
- %ΔPrice ≈ −Modified duration × ΔYield + ½ × Convexity × (ΔYield)²
- Use it to compare asset and liability value changes after a yield move.
Quick revision
- Objectives: return and risk. Constraints: liquidity, horizon, taxes, legal and regulatory, unique circumstances.
- Risk capacity is the ability to take risk. Risk willingness is the attitude to it. Overall risk tolerance is generally set by the lower of the two.
- DB plans: funded status is assets compared with the present value of liabilities. Surplus risk is the risk that assets fall short of liabilities.
- A stronger sponsor and a younger plan generally allow more risk. A weak sponsor and a mature plan call for less.
- In a DB plan, the participant has a promise and the sponsor bears the investment risk. In a DC plan, the participant bears it.
- DC plans: the design focus is the investment menu, defaults, and participant education, not liability matching.
- Endowments aim to maintain purchasing power while funding spending, so return needs to cover spending plus inflation plus costs.
- Spending rules smooth the budget and link spending to market value. Know the main types and their trade-offs.
- Banks focus on interest rate risk, liquidity and credit. Insurers match liabilities by type, and life and non-life differ.
- Sovereign wealth funds vary by mandate, such as stabilisation, savings or development. Match the policy to the stated purpose.
- LDI: use assets to hedge the liabilities, then seek return with the remainder. Cash-flow matching is tighter but costlier than duration matching.
Common mistakes
- Treating endowments and foundations as identical. Fix: Remember the differences: foundations often face a legal minimum payout and may lack new contributions, while endowments often receive gifts and set a spending rule linked to the institution's budget.
- Basing the risk objective on willingness alone. Fix: Assess both ability and willingness, then state that the lower of the two governs the risk tolerance.
- Treating the plan like an individual investor and setting the objective as maximum growth. Fix: Anchor the return objective to the liability and required contributions. Growth matters only to the extent it funds the promise.
- Saying a high equity allocation is fine because the time horizon is long. Fix: Check funded status, sponsor strength and the share of retirees first. A long horizon does not offset a large deficit.
- Treating a cash balance plan as a DC plan because it shows an account balance. Fix: Remember the account is hypothetical. The sponsor bears investment risk and the plan is a DB plan in form.
- Saying the sponsor has no risk in a DC plan. Fix: The sponsor still faces fiduciary, legal and reputational risk from poor menu or default design.
- Leaving inflation out of the return objective. Fix: Always add inflation, and add fund costs. Preserving real capital is the goal.
- Treating a high spending rate as a liquidity need. Fix: Spending is usually small relative to assets. Liquidity needs come from actual cash demands such as capital calls, debt or large grants.
- Treating a bank's investment portfolio as return-maximising. Fix: Anchor on liquidity, capital rules and interest rate risk; the portfolio supports lending and withdrawals.
- Saying life and non-life insurers have the same horizon and liquidity needs. Fix: Life: long, predictable liabilities. Non-life: shorter, uncertain claims needing more liquidity and higher quality.
Exam tips
- Link every IPS element to the liability or mission. Unlinked statements rarely earn full credit.
- When asked for risk tolerance, show ability and willingness separately, then state which governs.
- Match the investor to the answer set first. Many item-set options mix up endowment, foundation and insurer features.
- In essay answers, give calculations in full and keep justifications to one sentence each.
- Read the vignette for details on legal minimums, funded status and governance. Those are usually the hidden clues.
- Read the command word. Calculate means show the number. Determine or justify means state the conclusion and the reason.
- In risk tolerance answers, name ability and willingness separately, then the lower of the two. This earns the points quickly.
- Use case facts as evidence: funded status, retiree share, sponsor strength and correlation. Generic statements earn little.