CMA Final · Corporate and Economic Laws
Board Meetings and Procedures: formula sheet
Key formulas
- First Board meeting
- Within 30 days of the date of incorporation
- Section 173(1). Count from the date of incorporation.
- Minimum meetings and gap
- At least 4 meetings a year; gap between two consecutive meetings ≤ 120 days
- Both conditions must be met. The gap is counted between consecutive meetings.
- Notice period
- Not less than 7 days' written notice to every director
- By hand, post or electronic means, to the address registered with the company. Section 173(3).
- Shorter notice
- Urgent business: at least one independent director, if any, must be present; otherwise decisions need ratification by at least one independent director, if any
- Without ratification the decisions are not final.
- Penalty for failure to give notice
- ₹25,000 on the officer whose duty it is
- Section 173(4).
- OPC, small and dormant company
- At least 1 meeting in each half of the calendar year; gap between the two meetings ≥ 90 days
- Section 173(5). Section 173(5) and Section 174 do not apply to an OPC with only one director (proviso to Section 173(5)).
- Producer Company Board
- At least 4 meetings a year; at least once in every 3 months; 7 days' notice; ₹5,000 penalty on Chief Executive
- Section 378V. Shorter notice allowed, with reasons recorded in writing by the Board.
- Basic quorum
- Quorum = higher of (1/3 × total strength, rounded up) and 2
- Section 174(1). Total strength excludes vacant places. Video participation counts.
- Rounding rule
- Any fraction of a number = 1
- Explanation (i) to Section 174. 3.33 becomes 4; 2.67 becomes 3.
- Interested director rule
- If interested directors ≥ 2/3 of total strength, quorum = non-interested directors present, minimum 2
- Section 174(3). Interested director has the meaning in Section 184(2).
- Reduced Board
- Directors below quorum may act only to fill up to quorum or call a general meeting
- Section 174(2). They cannot take any other decision.
- Want of quorum
- Meeting stands adjourned to same day, same time and place next week; if that is a national holiday, next day that is not a national holiday
- Section 174(4). Applies unless the articles provide otherwise.
- One Person Company
- Section 174 does not apply to an OPC with only one director
- Proviso to Section 173(5).
- Modes of attendance
- In person OR video conferencing / other audio-visual means (Section 173(2))
- The facility must record and recognise participation and record and store proceedings with date and time.
- Quorum with remote directors
- Quorum = higher of one-third of total strength or 2 directors; remote directors count (Section 174(1))
- Fractions are rounded up to one; total strength excludes vacant places.
- Notified matters
- Matters notified by Central Government not to be dealt with by video conferencing, unless quorum is physically present (further proviso to Section 173(2))
- Then any other director may join remotely.
- Passing by circulation
- Draft + papers to all directors → approval by a majority of directors entitled to vote (Section 175(1))
- Majority is of directors entitled to vote, not of those who reply.
- Right to demand a meeting
- Directors requiring a meeting ≥ one-third of total number of directors → resolution goes to a Board meeting
- The chairperson must then put it to a meeting.
- Noting the resolution
- Circular resolution noted at a subsequent meeting and made part of its minutes (Section 175(2))
- Applies to Board and committee resolutions.
- Residual power of Board
- Board power = all company powers − powers reserved for general meeting (Section 179(1))
- Board is also bound by the Act, memorandum, articles and valid regulations made in general meeting.
- Powers only by Board resolution at meeting
- Section 179(3): calls, buy-back, issue of securities, borrowing, investment, loans/guarantee/security, approve financial statement and Board's report, diversification, merger/amalgamation/reconstruction, takeover/controlling stake
- These must be exercised by resolutions passed at Board meetings, not by one director acting alone.
- Delegable powers
- Clauses (d) to (f): borrow, invest, grant loans/guarantee/security
- Delegation is to a committee of directors, MD, manager or other principal officer (or branch principal officer), by a resolution passed at a meeting, on specified conditions.
- Resolution by circulation
- Draft + papers to all directors → approval by majority of those entitled to vote; if ≥ 1/3 of total directors require it, decide at a meeting (Section 175)
- Noted at the next Board or committee meeting and made part of its minutes.
- Minutes timing
- Prepared, signed and kept within 30 days of conclusion of meeting (Section 118(1))
- Kept in books with pages consecutively numbered. For postal ballot, 30 days from passing of the resolution.
- Contents of Board minutes
- Fair and correct summary + appointments + names of directors present + names of dissenting directors for each resolution
- Section 118(2) to (4).
- Matters excluded from minutes
- Chairman's opinion: defamatory, irrelevant or immaterial, or detrimental to company interests (Section 118(5))
- Chairman has absolute discretion under Section 118(6).
- Penalties under Section 118
- Default: company ₹25,000; each officer in default ₹5,000. Tampering: up to 2 years' imprisonment and fine ₹25,000 to ₹1,00,000
- Section 118(11) and (12).
Quick revision
- First Board meeting: within 30 days of incorporation.
- Minimum four Board meetings a year, with not more than 120 days between two consecutive meetings.
- Board meeting notice: at least seven days in writing to every director, by hand, post or electronic means.
- Shorter notice for urgent business is allowed if at least one independent director, if any, is present; otherwise decisions need ratification by at least one independent director, if any.
- Officer who fails to give notice: penalty of ₹25,000.
- One Person Company, small company and dormant company: at least one meeting in each half of the calendar year, with a gap of not less than 90 days.
- Board quorum: one-third of total strength or two directors, whichever is higher; fractions round up to one; vacancies are not counted in total strength.
- Directors attending by video conferencing or other audio visual means count towards quorum.
- If interested directors are two-thirds or more of total strength, the non-interested directors present (at least two) form the quorum.
- Meeting without quorum stands adjourned to the same day, time and place next week; if that is a national holiday, the next day that is not one.
- Minutes: signed and kept in numbered books within 30 days of the meeting; they must name directors present and any dissenting from a resolution.
- Default on minutes: ₹25,000 on the company and ₹5,000 on each officer in default; tampering is punishable with up to two years' imprisonment and a fine of ₹25,000 to ₹1 lakh.
Common mistakes
- Saying four meetings in a year is enough without checking the gap. Fix: Always compute the gap between each pair of consecutive meetings. It must not exceed 120 days.
- Applying the 90-day gap to all companies. Fix: The 90-day minimum gap with one meeting in each half-year applies only to OPC, small and dormant companies. Others use the 120-day maximum gap.
- Rounding down, such as taking 10 directors as a quorum of 3. Fix: One-third of 10 is 3.33. Any fraction counts as one, so quorum is 4.
- Using the sanctioned strength of the Board instead of actual directors. Fix: Total strength excludes vacant places. Count directors in office only.
- Saying a circular resolution needs a majority of directors who responded. Fix: Section 175 requires approval by a majority of the directors entitled to vote on the resolution.
- Treating a circular resolution as valid even when one-third of directors want a meeting. Fix: If not less than one-third of the total number of directors require it, the chairperson must put the resolution to a Board meeting.
- Saying all Section 179(3) powers can be delegated. Fix: Write that only borrowing, investing and loans/guarantee/security can be delegated. Buy-back, issue of securities and approval of accounts stay with the Board.
- Treating a Board resolution as the same as a special resolution. Fix: A Board resolution is passed by directors at a Board meeting. Ordinary and special resolutions are passed by shareholders in general meeting. Name the body first.
Exam tips
- Give the section number 173 and the exact figures: 30 days, four meetings, 120 days, seven days, ₹25,000.
- In case-based MCQs, compute every gap. Examiners often hide one long gap.
- Check the company type first. OPC, small and dormant companies have the 90-day rule.
- For short-notice questions, look for the independent director and the words 'if any'.
- If a question mentions a Producer Company, apply Section 378V, not Section 173.
- Always show the working: total strength, one-third, rounding, comparison with two. Marks go to the steps.
- In case scenarios, read for vacancies, video attendance and conflict of interest. These are the usual traps.
- Quote the section: Section 174(1) for quorum, 174(2) for reduced Board, 174(3) for interested directors, 174(4) for adjournment.