CMA Final · Risk Management in Banking and Insurance
Market Risk Management: formula sheet
Key formulas
- Market risk definition
- Market risk = potential loss from adverse movement in interest rates, exchange rates, equity prices or commodity prices
- Write the source of loss as a price movement, not a default.
- Four components
- Market risk = Interest rate risk + Equity price risk + Foreign exchange risk + Commodity price risk
- This is a classification, not an arithmetic sum. Use it as a memory list.
- Net open foreign exchange position
- Net open position = Foreign currency assets − Foreign currency liabilities (including off-balance sheet items)
- A positive position loses when the foreign currency weakens; a negative position loses when it strengthens.
- Bond price and rate link
- Interest rates ↑ ⇒ price of fixed-rate bond ↓; interest rates ↓ ⇒ price ↑
- Holds for a fixed-coupon bond, other things being equal.
- Trading book definition
- Trading book = positions held with trading intent + positions held to hedge trading book positions
- Intent is the test. The instrument type alone does not decide the book.
- Banking book definition
- Banking book = all positions not in the trading book
- It is a residual category. Loans, deposits and held-to-maturity investments usually sit here.
- Capital linkage
- Trading book → market risk capital; Banking book → credit risk capital (plus IRRBB supervision)
- Counterparty credit risk on trading book derivatives is still capitalised separately.
- Valuation linkage
- Trading book → fair value (mark to market); Banking book → cost or amortised cost, mostly
- Exact accounting follows the applicable standards and RBI norms.
- Reclassification rule
- Switching books after initial designation is allowed only in exceptional cases, with senior management approval and board-approved policy
- Any capital benefit from a switch is not allowed to the bank. State this as the principle.
- Parametric VaR (1 day)
- VaR = Portfolio value × z × σ
- σ is daily standard deviation of returns. Mean return is taken as zero unless the question gives it.
- Common z-values (one-tailed, normal)
- 95% → 1.645; 99% → 2.33
- Use the z-value the question supplies if it gives one.
- Holding period scaling
- VaR (N days) = VaR (1 day) × √N
- Valid under the square-root-of-time rule: independent returns with constant volatility.
- Two-asset portfolio standard deviation
- σp = √(w1²σ1² + w2²σ2² + 2 w1 w2 ρ σ1 σ2)
- Use when VaR is needed for a portfolio. Low correlation ρ gives diversification benefit.
- Historical simulation percentile
- Loss at (1 − confidence) percentile of ranked returns
- With 100 observations at 95%, VaR is the 5th worst outcome; at 99% it is the 1st worst (or interpolate, as the question directs).
- Undiversified vs diversified VaR
- Diversified VaR ≤ Sum of individual VaRs
- Equality holds only when correlation is +1.
- Backtesting exception
- Exception = day when actual loss > VaR
- Expected exceptions = observations × (1 − confidence). Under the Basel framework the number of exceptions over 250 days drives the multiplier on capital.
- Expected shortfall (discrete, equally likely outcomes)
- ES = Average of all losses that are greater than or equal to the VaR cutoff, i.e. the worst (1 − c) share of outcomes
- c is the confidence level. At 97.5%, ES uses the worst 2.5% of outcomes.
- Relation of ES to VaR
- ES ≥ VaR at the same confidence level
- ES is the average of tail losses. Never present ES as smaller than VaR.
- Number of tail observations
- Tail observations = N × (1 − c)
- With 200 observations at 95%, the tail has 10 observations.
- Stress loss from a sensitivity shock
- Loss ≈ Σ (Exposure × Shock)
- For a bond portfolio: Loss ≈ Modified duration × Δy × Market value, for small yield changes.
- Stress loss as share of capital
- Stress loss ÷ Capital × 100
- Used to judge whether capital is adequate after the shock.
- Repricing gap
- Gap = RSA − RSL
- Calculate for each time bucket. Cumulative gap is the running total up to the bucket you are testing.
- Change in NII
- ΔNII ≈ Gap × Δi
- Use the cumulative gap for the horizon (usually 1 year). Δi as a decimal, e.g. 0.5% = 0.005. Assumes a parallel shift and that all items reprice at the start of the bucket.
- Gap ratio
- RSA ÷ RSL
- Below 1 means liability-sensitive, above 1 means asset-sensitive.
- Macaulay duration
- D = Σ [t × CF_t ÷ (1 + y)^t] ÷ Price
- t is time in years, CF_t is the cash flow at time t, y is yield per period. The price is the sum of discounted cash flows.
- Modified duration
- MD = D ÷ (1 + y ÷ m)
- m is compounding periods per year. For annual compounding, MD = D ÷ (1 + y).
- Price change with duration and convexity
- ΔP ÷ P ≈ −MD × Δy + ½ × C × (Δy)²
- C is convexity. Drop the second term if the question gives no convexity. Use Δy in decimals.
- Convexity (annual cash flows)
- C = Σ [t × (t + 1) × CF_t ÷ (1 + y)^(t + 2)] ÷ Price
- Use only if the question asks you to compute it. Otherwise the value is usually given.
- Duration gap
- DG = D_A − (L ÷ A) × D_L
- A is the market value of assets, L is the market value of liabilities, D_A and D_L are the weighted durations.
- Change in equity value
- ΔE ≈ −DG × A × Δy ÷ (1 + y)
- Divide ΔE by E to get the percentage change in equity. A positive DG with rising yield gives a loss.
- Net open position (single currency)
- Net position = (Spot assets + Forward purchases) − (Spot liabilities + Forward sales)
- Positive = long, negative = short. Include all on- and off-balance sheet items in that currency.
- Overall net open position
- Overall NOP = larger of (Σ net long positions) and (Σ net short positions)
- Sum long and short currencies separately. Take the larger total. Do not net longs against shorts.
- Limit check
- Utilisation % = Overall NOP ÷ NOPL × 100
- If utilisation is above 100%, the bank breaches the limit and must square off the excess.
- Gap in a maturity bucket
- Gap = Forward purchases − Forward sales (for that bucket)
- Positive gap = net purchase. Negative gap = net sale.
- Aggregate gap
- Aggregate gap = Σ |gap in each bucket|
- Add absolute values, ignoring signs, then compare with the AGL.
- Gain or loss on an open position
- P&L = Net position (in foreign currency) × (New rate − Old rate)
- Positive for a long position when the rate rises. Reverse the sign for a short position.
- Total market risk capital (standardised, older method)
- Capital charge = Specific risk charge + General market risk charge
- The older method uses a maturity or duration method for interest rate positions and fixed percentage charges for specific and general market risk on equity positions. Add foreign exchange and commodity charges separately.
- Risk-weighted assets equivalent
- RWA for market risk = Capital charge × 12.5
- Under Basel, the market risk capital charge is converted into RWA by multiplying by 12.5, the reciprocal of the 8% minimum. RBI uses the same 12.5 conversion for market risk. Separately, RBI's minimum total capital ratio is 9% of total RWA, excluding buffers such as the capital conservation buffer. This ratio is applied to total RWA. It does not change the 12.5 factor.
- Revised standardised approach (FRTB)
- Capital = Sensitivities-based method charge + Default risk charge + Residual risk add-on
- The sensitivities-based method covers delta, vega and curvature risk across risk classes.
- Expected Shortfall
- ES = average loss in the worst 2.5% of outcomes (97.5% confidence)
- ES captures the size of tail losses. VaR only gives the threshold.
- Liquidity horizon scaling
- ES = √[ ES_T(P)² + Σ (j ≥ 2) (ES_T(P, j) × √((LH_j − LH_(j−1)) ÷ T))² ], with base horizon T = 10 days
- FRTB uses horizons (LH) of 10, 20, 40, 60 and 120 days by risk factor category. ES_T(P) is computed for the 10-day base horizon using all risk factors. This first term covers LH_1 = 10 days. The sum runs over j ≥ 2, where LH_(j−1) is the previous horizon. Each ES_T(P, j) is scaled by √((LH_j − LH_(j−1)) ÷ 10), and the terms are aggregated. ES_T(P, j) is computed using only risk factors whose horizon is at least LH_j. Less liquid factors get longer horizons, so they attract more capital.
- FRTB IMA test
- Desk approval = back-testing pass + P&L attribution pass
- A desk that fails the P&L attribution test, or breaches back-testing thresholds, is ineligible for IMA and is charged under the standardised approach. Minor back-testing exceptions lead to a higher capital multiplier first.
- Net Open Position (forex)
- NOP = larger of (Σ net short positions, Σ net long positions) across currencies
- A simplified shorthand. Use it to compare against the NOP limit approved by the board and RBI. In a question, follow the method given in the problem.
- Stop loss trigger
- Breach if Cumulative loss ≥ Stop loss limit
- Loss is measured from the cost or the start-of-period value. The usual action is to close the position or seek approval to continue.
- Limit utilisation
- Utilisation % = Actual exposure ÷ Approved limit × 100
- Above 100% means an excess that must be reported. Many banks also set early warning triggers below 100%.
- Hedge ratio
- Hedge ratio = Value of hedge instrument ÷ Value of exposure hedged
- 1 means a full hedge. Below 1 is a partial hedge. The question may ask for the unhedged amount.
- Futures hedge, number of contracts
- N = (Exposure value ÷ Value of one contract) × Hedge ratio
- Round to a whole number of contracts. Use the hedge ratio given, and 1 if it is not given.
- Forward cover result
- Hedged rupee amount = Foreign currency amount × Forward rate
- The forward rate is locked, so the rupee amount does not depend on the spot rate at maturity.
Quick revision
- Market risk is loss from changes in interest rates, exchange rates, equity prices and commodity prices.
- The trading book holds positions for short-term trading and is marked to market; the banking book holds positions for the longer term.
- VaR estimates the loss that should not be exceeded at a stated confidence level over a stated holding period.
- The three VaR methods are variance-covariance, historical simulation and Monte Carlo simulation.
- Under the usual square-root-of-time scaling, N-day VaR = 1-day VaR × √N; it assumes independent returns and is only an approximation.
- VaR does not tell you how large the loss is beyond the cutoff; expected shortfall averages the losses beyond it.
- Stress tests examine extreme but plausible scenarios and complement VaR, not replace it.
- A positive duration gap generally means the value of equity falls when interest rates rise; a negative gap means the opposite.
- Net open position in a currency is the difference between assets and liabilities in that currency, including off-balance-sheet items.
- Capital for market risk may be set by the standardised approach or by an approved internal model.
- Limits such as position, loss-stop and VaR limits turn risk appetite into daily controls.
- Hedging reduces risk but has a cost and can leave basis risk.
Common mistakes
- Calling a borrower's default caused by a rate rise purely market risk. Fix: Separate the two effects. The price loss on the bank's own positions is market risk. The borrower's failure to repay is credit risk.
- Saying market risk applies only to the trading book. Fix: State that interest rate and currency risk also arise in the banking book, for example through repricing mismatches.
- Classifying by instrument type, for example saying all government securities are banking book. Fix: The same security can sit in either book. Decide by intent and documented strategy.
- Saying the banking book carries no interest rate risk capital consideration. Fix: Banking book positions carry IRRBB, which is managed and supervised separately from trading book market risk capital.
- Using the wrong z-value, such as 1.645 for 99% confidence Fix: Write 95% → 1.645 and 99% → 2.33 at the top of your answer before computing.
- Multiplying by N instead of √N when scaling the holding period Fix: Volatility scales with the square root of time. Multiply 1-day VaR by √N.
- Stating that ES is the loss at the VaR point. Fix: VaR is the cutoff. ES is the average of losses beyond the cutoff, so it is equal to or larger.
- Averaging all losses instead of only the tail. Fix: Compute N × (1 − c) first and average only that many worst losses.
- Using the total gap instead of the cumulative gap up to the one-year horizon (or the wrong bucket). Fix: Add buckets only up to the horizon asked. Then multiply by the rate change.
- Getting the sign wrong in ΔNII or ΔE. Fix: Decide direction first from the sign rule. Check that your final number agrees with it.
Exam tips
- In MCQs, spot the word that signals the cause: price, rate or volatility points to market risk; default or downgrade points to credit risk; fraud, process or system points to operational risk.
- In case-based questions, name the exposed position and the direction of loss before naming the risk type.
- For difference questions, compare on cause, source of loss, and typical control, using clear sentences.
- Practise one quick currency position calculation. Check whether the bank is long or short before judging gain or loss.
- Mention both trading book and banking book when asked about the scope of market risk.
- Begin every classification answer with the word 'intent'. Examiners look for it.
- In a case scenario, underline phrases such as 'to sell shortly', 'market making' and 'hold to maturity'. They decide the book.
- Always pair the book with both valuation basis and capital charge. A half pair loses marks.