CMA Final · Strategic Cost Management
Business Application of Maxima and Minima: formula sheet
Key formulas
- Function
- y = f(x)
- Define the business quantity (profit, cost, revenue) as a function of one decision variable.
- First order (necessary) condition
- dy/dx = f′(x) = 0
- Solve for x to get stationary points. This alone does not tell you maximum or minimum.
- Second order condition for a maximum
- d²y/dx² < 0 at the stationary point
- The curve bends downward. Profit-type functions usually show this.
- Second order condition for a minimum
- d²y/dx² > 0 at the stationary point
- The curve bends upward. Cost-type functions usually show this.
- Inconclusive case
- d²y/dx² = 0
- The test fails. Check the sign of dy/dx on both sides of the point.
- Power rule
- d(axⁿ)/dx = a·n·xⁿ⁻¹
- The constant term differentiates to zero.
- Revenue and profit link
- Profit = Revenue − Cost; at the optimum, MR = MC
- Marginal revenue is dR/dx and marginal cost is dC/dx. This follows from setting d(Profit)/dx = 0.
- Total cost
- TC = FC + VC(x)
- FC is constant. It affects profit but not the profit-maximising output.
- Average and marginal cost
- AC = TC ÷ x ; MC = d(TC)/dx
- Find AC by dividing the whole TC by x before differentiating AC.
- Total, average and marginal revenue
- TR = p·x ; AR = TR ÷ x = p ; MR = d(TR)/dx
- Write p in terms of x from the demand function first.
- Linear demand case
- p = a − bx ⇒ TR = ax − bx² ; MR = a − 2bx
- MR has the same intercept as demand but twice the slope. This holds only for linear demand.
- Profit function
- π = TR − TC
- Use total figures, not per-unit figures, unless the question asks for per-unit profit.
- First-order condition for maximum profit
- dπ/dx = 0 ⇔ MR = MC
- This gives the candidate output. It is not yet proved to be a maximum.
- Second-order condition
- d²π/dx² < 0 ⇒ maximum ; d²π/dx² > 0 ⇒ minimum
- Equivalent to the MC curve cutting MR from below.
- Minimum average cost
- d(AC)/dx = 0 and d²(AC)/dx² > 0 ⇒ MC = AC
- At minimum AC the marginal cost equals average cost.
- Maximum revenue
- MR = 0 and d²(TR)/dx² < 0
- Revenue maximisation gives a different output from profit maximisation unless MC = 0.
- MR and price elasticity
- MR = p × (1 − 1/|e|)
- Here e is the price elasticity of demand. MR is positive only when |e| > 1.
- Profit function
- π = TR − TC, where TR = P × Q
- Write TC and TR in terms of Q before differentiating.
- Marginal revenue and marginal cost
- MR = d(TR)/dQ; MC = d(TC)/dQ
- MC is the derivative of total cost, so fixed cost drops out of MC.
- First-order condition for maximum profit
- dπ/dQ = 0, which gives MR = MC
- This finds the candidate output.
- Second-order condition for maximum profit
- d²π/dQ² < 0 (equivalently, slope of MR < slope of MC)
- Without this check you have not proved a maximum.
- Linear demand and its MR
- P = a − bQ gives TR = aQ − bQ² and MR = a − 2bQ
- MR falls twice as fast as price for a linear demand curve.
- Average cost and its minimum
- AC = TC ÷ Q; minimum where d(AC)/dQ = 0 and d²(AC)/dQ² > 0
- At this point MC = AC.
- Per-unit tax or royalty
- New TC = old TC + t × Q, so new MC = old MC + t
- A lump-sum fixed charge adds to TC but does not change MC, so the profit-maximising output stays the same.
- Total inventory cost
- TC(Q) = (A ÷ Q) × O + (Q ÷ 2) × C
- Add the purchase cost A × P only if price varies with order size. Otherwise it does not affect EOQ.
- First-order condition
- dTC/dQ = −AO ÷ Q² + C ÷ 2 = 0
- Setting this to zero gives the stationary point.
- Economic Order Quantity
- EOQ = √(2AO ÷ C)
- If carrying cost is a percentage i of unit price P, then C = i × P.
- Second-order condition
- d²TC/dQ² = 2AO ÷ Q³ > 0 for Q > 0
- A positive value confirms a minimum.
- Minimum total cost
- TC at EOQ = √(2AOC)
- Excluding purchase cost. Ordering cost equals carrying cost at this point.
- Number of orders and cycle
- Orders = A ÷ EOQ; Cycle time = EOQ ÷ A (in years)
- Multiply cycle time by 365 or 300 as the question states, to get days.
- Profit function
- π = R − C
- R = revenue, C = total cost. Maximise π, not R or C alone, unless the question asks for revenue or cost only.
- Condition for maximum
- dπ/dq = 0 and d²π/dq² < 0
- Equivalent to MR = MC. The second-order check is needed to show it is a maximum.
- Per-unit tax on producer
- C_new(q) = C(q) + t·q, so MR = MC + t
- t is the tax per unit. Use this when the producer bears the tax.
- Ad valorem tax on revenue
- π = (1 − k)·R − C
- k is the tax rate on sales value, written as a decimal.
- Lump-sum tax or fixed charge
- π_new = π − T
- T is a fixed amount. The optimal q does not change.
- Linear demand, constant MC, per-unit tax
- p = a − b·q; q* = (a − c − t) ÷ (2b)
- c is constant marginal cost. The price is p* = a − b·q*.
- Revenue maximisation (linear demand)
- R = p·q = (a − bq)·q; q = a ÷ (2b)
- Revenue peaks where MR = 0. Profit peaks at a lower output whenever MC > 0.
- Tax collected
- Tax revenue = t × q*
- Use the output after the tax, not the output before it.
- Equality constraint
- Substitute y = g(x) into π(x, y), then solve dπ/dx = 0
- Reduces two variables to one.
Quick revision
- Stationary point: first derivative equals zero.
- Second derivative negative: maximum. Positive: minimum.
- Revenue = price × quantity; profit = revenue − total cost.
- Profit is maximised where marginal revenue = marginal cost, provided the second-order condition holds.
- Marginal cost is the derivative of total cost; marginal revenue is the derivative of total revenue.
- Average cost is lowest where it equals marginal cost, given a standard U-shaped curve.
- EOQ = √(2 × annual demand × ordering cost per order ÷ carrying cost per unit per year).
- At EOQ, annual ordering cost equals annual carrying cost in the basic model.
- Number of orders per year = annual demand ÷ EOQ.
- A quantity discount changes the total cost, so compare total cost at each discount level, not just the EOQ.
- Always check that the answer is feasible: non-negative and within any capacity or constraint.
- Finish with a decision statement in rupees or units.
Common mistakes
- Stopping after dy/dx = 0 and calling the point a maximum or minimum. Fix: Always take the second derivative and state its sign. Marks are given for the condition.
- Substituting x into the derivative to find the maximum profit. Fix: The derivative gives the slope, which is zero there. Use the original function for the value.
- Using price p as marginal revenue. Fix: If price falls as x rises, always build TR = p·x first and differentiate it. For p = a − bx, MR = a − 2bx.
- Differentiating AC without dividing TC by x, or confusing AC with MC. Fix: AC = TC ÷ x. MC = dTC/dx. For minimum AC, differentiate AC and set it to zero. Then verify MC = AC.
- Setting price equal to MC instead of MR equal to MC when the firm faces a downward-sloping demand curve. Fix: If demand depends on Q, build TR = P × Q first and differentiate it. Use P = MC only if price is fixed and does not change with Q.
- Skipping the second-order condition. Fix: Always differentiate again, state the sign, and write 'maximum' or 'minimum'. It takes one line and secures marks.
- Using total order cost or carrying cost for the wrong period, such as monthly carrying cost with yearly demand. Fix: Convert A and C to the same period, normally one year, before calculating.
- Taking carrying cost as the average stock times C but using Q instead of Q ÷ 2. Fix: Always write carrying cost as (Q ÷ 2) × C when building the function.
- Adding the tax to revenue or subtracting it from price in the wrong place, which gives a wrong MC. Fix: For a tax paid by the producer, add t·q to total cost. Then MC becomes MC + t.
- Using the pre-tax output to calculate tax collected or profit after tax. Fix: Recompute q from the new profit function. Tax collected = t × new q.
Exam tips
- Show all three parts: first derivative set to zero, second derivative sign, and the final value. Each carries marks in written answers.
- In MCQs, check the sign of the second derivative first. It often eliminates two options at once.
- Read units carefully. Many questions give x in hundreds or ₹ in thousands, and the final answer must be converted.
- Write one line of business meaning, such as produce 3,000 units to earn the highest profit. SCM questions reward a clear recommendation.
- If the problem gives capacity or a minimum order, check the feasible range before you finalise x.
- In MCQs, check the formula first: MR = d(p·x)/dx, not p. Many wrong options are built from using price as MR.
- In written answers, show the second-order test as its own line with the sign. It is an easy mark to protect.
- Put the optimal x back into MR and MC as a check. If they differ, find the error before you write the answer.