CMA Final · Strategic Cost Management
Variance Analyses: formula sheet
Key formulas
- General variance rule (cost)
- Cost variance = Standard cost for actual output − Actual cost
- Positive means Favourable, negative means Adverse. Always use standard for actual output, not budgeted output.
- General variance rule (sales/profit)
- Sales or profit variance = Actual − Standard (or budgeted)
- Positive means Favourable, negative means Adverse. The sign convention is reversed from cost.
- Price-type variance
- (Standard price − Actual price) × Actual quantity
- Applies to material price, labour rate and overhead expenditure style variances.
- Quantity-type variance
- (Standard quantity for actual output − Actual quantity) × Standard price
- Applies to material usage and labour efficiency. Valued at standard price.
- Standard cost of a unit
- Standard cost = Standard quantity × Standard price (for each element), summed
- Prepare a standard cost card for material, labour, variable and fixed overheads.
- Standard cost for actual output
- Standard cost for actual output = Standard cost per unit × Actual units produced
- This is the flexed standard used for comparison.
- Material cost variance (MCV)
- MCV = (SQ × SP) − (AQ × AP)
- SQ is standard quantity for actual output. Positive means favourable, negative means adverse.
- Material price variance (MPV)
- MPV = (SP − AP) × AQ
- AQ is the actual quantity purchased if price is isolated at purchase, or actual quantity used if isolated at consumption. Follow the question.
- Material usage variance (MUV)
- MUV = (SQ − AQ used) × SP
- Valued at standard price. SQ is for actual output.
- Revised standard quantity (RSQ)
- RSQ of a material = Total actual input of all materials × (Standard quantity of that material ÷ Total standard input)
- Same total as actual input, but in the standard ratio.
- Material mix variance (MMV)
- MMV = (RSQ − AQ) × SP
- Calculated material by material. If the total actual input equals the total standard input for the output, this equals (SQ − AQ) × SP.
- Material yield variance (MYV)
- MYV = (SQ − RSQ) × SP, or (Actual output − Standard output for actual input) × Standard cost per unit of output
- Both forms give the same answer.
- Identities for checking
- MCV = MPV + MUV; MUV = MMV + MYV
- Use these to verify the answer. Signs must be added algebraically.
- Labour cost variance (LCV)
- LCV = (Standard hours for actual output × SR) − (Actual hours paid × AR)
- SR = standard rate per hour, AR = actual rate per hour. Positive is favourable, negative is adverse.
- Labour rate variance (LRV)
- LRV = (SR − AR) × Actual hours paid
- Some solutions use hours worked when there is no idle time. With idle time, use hours paid.
- Labour efficiency variance (LEV)
- LEV = (Standard hours for actual output − Actual hours worked) × SR
- Uses hours worked, not hours paid.
- Idle time variance
- Idle time variance = Idle hours × SR
- Always adverse, because idle hours earn no output.
- Reconciliation
- LCV = LRV + LEV + Idle time variance
- Use this to check your answer.
- Labour mix variance
- Mix variance = (Revised standard hours − Actual hours worked) × SR, for each grade
- Revised standard hours = total actual hours worked, shared in the standard ratio of grades.
- Labour yield variance
- Yield variance = (Standard hours for actual output − Revised standard hours) × SR, for each grade
- Overall it equals total hours difference × average standard rate per hour.
- Efficiency split
- LEV = Mix variance + Yield variance
- Holds when idle time is treated separately and hours worked are used.
- Standard variable overhead rate
- Budgeted variable overhead ÷ Budgeted hours (or units)
- Use hours if the question bases absorption on hours; use units if it bases on output.
- Standard fixed overhead rate
- Budgeted fixed overhead ÷ Budgeted hours (or units)
- Use the same base as the variable rate unless told otherwise.
- Variable overhead total variance
- (Standard hours for actual output × Standard rate) − Actual variable overhead
- Positive is favourable. Equals expenditure plus efficiency variance.
- Variable overhead expenditure variance
- (Actual hours × Standard rate) − Actual variable overhead
- Positive is favourable.
- Variable overhead efficiency variance
- (Standard hours for actual output − Actual hours) × Standard variable rate
- Positive is favourable.
- Fixed overhead total variance
- (Standard hours for actual output × Standard fixed rate) − Actual fixed overhead
- Equals expenditure plus volume variance.
- Fixed overhead expenditure variance
- Budgeted fixed overhead − Actual fixed overhead
- Positive is favourable.
- Fixed overhead volume variance
- (Standard hours for actual output × Standard fixed rate) − Budgeted fixed overhead
- Equivalent to (Actual output − Budgeted output) × Standard rate per unit.
- Fixed overhead efficiency variance
- (Standard hours for actual output − Actual hours) × Standard fixed rate
- Positive is favourable.
- Fixed overhead capacity variance
- (Actual hours − Revised budgeted hours) × Standard fixed rate
- Revised budgeted hours = budgeted hours × actual days ÷ budgeted days. If no calendar data is given, use budgeted hours.
- Fixed overhead calendar variance
- (Revised budgeted hours − Budgeted hours) × Standard fixed rate
- Favourable if more working days than budget.
- Volume variance check
- Volume = Efficiency + Capacity + Calendar
- Use this to verify your workings.
- Sales value variance (turnover)
- (AQ × AP) − (BQ × BP)
- AQ = actual quantity, AP = actual price, BQ = budgeted quantity, BP = budgeted price. Favourable if actual sales exceed budget.
- Sales price variance
- AQ × (AP − BP)
- Same figure under both methods. Favourable if actual price is higher.
- Sales volume variance (turnover)
- BP × (AQ − BQ)
- Always at budgeted price. Equals mix variance + quantity variance.
- Revised actual quantity (RAQ)
- Total actual units × (BQ of the product ÷ Total BQ)
- Actual total units spread in the budgeted proportion. Needed for mix and quantity variances.
- Sales mix variance (turnover)
- BP × (AQ − RAQ)
- Sum over all products. Compares actual mix with budgeted mix for the same total units.
- Sales quantity variance (turnover)
- BP × (RAQ − BQ)
- Sum over all products. Shortcut: (Total AQ − Total BQ) × average budgeted price per unit.
- Total sales margin variance (profit)
- Actual profit − Budgeted profit
- Actual profit here is sales less standard cost of the actual units sold.
- Sales margin volume variance
- Budgeted margin per unit × (AQ − BQ)
- Budgeted margin per unit = BP − standard cost per unit. Equals margin mix + margin quantity variance.
- Sales margin mix variance
- Budgeted margin per unit × (AQ − RAQ)
- Sum over all products.
- Sales margin quantity variance
- Budgeted margin per unit × (RAQ − BQ)
- Sum over all products. Shortcut: (Total AQ − Total BQ) × average budgeted margin per unit.
- Reconciliation checks
- Value variance = Price + Volume; Volume = Mix + Quantity
- The same holds for margin variances. Use these to verify your answer.
- Reconciliation identity
- Actual profit = Budgeted profit + Σ Favourable variances − Σ Adverse variances
- Use this as the spine of the statement. Always check it against actual sales less actual costs.
- Sales price variance
- (Actual price − Standard price) × Actual quantity sold
- Positive means favourable.
- Sales volume variance (absorption)
- (Actual quantity sold − Budgeted quantity) × Standard profit per unit
- Favourable if actual sales exceed budget.
- Sales volume variance (marginal)
- (Actual quantity sold − Budgeted quantity) × Standard contribution per unit
- Use contribution, not profit, in marginal costing.
- Material price and usage variances
- Price = (Standard price − Actual price) × Actual quantity; Usage = (Standard quantity for actual output − Actual quantity) × Standard price
- Standard quantity is based on actual output, not budgeted output.
- Labour rate and efficiency variances
- Rate = (Standard rate − Actual rate) × Actual hours; Efficiency = (Standard hours for actual output − Actual hours) × Standard rate
- Add an idle time variance if idle hours are given: Idle hours × Standard rate, adverse.
- Variable overhead variances
- Expenditure = (Standard rate × Actual hours) − Actual variable overhead; Efficiency = (Standard hours for actual output − Actual hours) × Standard rate
- Standard rate is per hour of the chosen base.
- Fixed overhead variances
- Expenditure = Budgeted fixed overhead − Actual fixed overhead; Volume = (Actual output − Budgeted output) × Standard fixed overhead rate per unit
- Volume variance appears only in absorption costing.
- Planning variance (material price)
- (Original standard price − Revised standard price) × Actual quantity
- Positive means favourable. Use the same logic for any element: original standard minus revised standard.
- Operational variance (material price)
- (Revised standard price − Actual price) × Actual quantity
- Positive means favourable. Measures performance against the revised standard.
- Total price variance check
- Planning variance + Operational variance = Variance on original standard
- Use this to check your split.
- Revised standard cost for actual output
- Revised standard quantity for actual output × Revised standard price
- Base for operational usage and efficiency variances.
- Operational usage variance
- (Revised standard quantity for actual output − Actual quantity) × Revised standard price
- Positive means favourable.
- Investigation rule of thumb
- Investigate if expected benefit of correction > cost of investigation
- Also consider size, trend, controllability and whether it is within tolerance limits.
- Standard costing entries (adverse variance)
- Dr Variance A/c, Cr Material/Wages/Overhead control A/c
- Favourable variance is the reverse: Dr control account, Cr Variance A/c.
Quick revision
- Variance = standard (or budget) figure minus actual figure for costs; the reverse for revenue and profit. Favourable means profit goes up.
- Always compute standard cost for actual output, not for budgeted output, when measuring cost variances.
- Material price variance = (standard price − actual price) × actual quantity purchased or used, as the question's basis states.
- Material usage variance = (standard quantity for actual output − actual quantity) × standard price.
- Material mix variance plus yield variance equals the usage variance.
- Labour rate variance uses actual hours paid; efficiency variance uses standard hours for actual output against actual hours worked.
- Idle time variance = idle hours × standard rate and is always adverse.
- Fixed overhead volume variance splits into capacity and efficiency, with calendar variance where the question gives days.
- Sales volume variance on a profit basis uses standard profit per unit; sales price variance compares actual and standard selling price on actual units.
- In reconciliation, favourable variances add to budgeted profit and adverse ones are deducted.
- Investigate a variance by size, trend, controllability and cost of investigation, not only because it is adverse.
- Check that sub-variances add to the total before you write the final answer.
Common mistakes
- Comparing actual cost with standard cost of budgeted output Fix: Always flex the standard to actual output before comparing.
- Marking a variance F or A by the sign of the number alone Fix: Ask whether profit rises or falls. Higher cost is A; higher sales or profit is F.
- Using actual price to value usage, mix or yield variances. Fix: Value every quantity variance at standard price. Actual price appears only in the price variance.
- Calculating RSQ with the standard total instead of the actual total input. Fix: RSQ always sums to the actual total input. Only the ratio comes from the standard.
- Using hours worked for the rate variance when idle time exists. Fix: Wages are paid for all hours paid. Compute rate variance on hours paid, and efficiency on hours worked.
- Valuing idle time at the actual rate. Fix: Idle time variance is idle hours × standard rate. The rate difference on those hours is already inside the rate variance.
- Using actual hours instead of standard hours for actual output when computing absorbed overhead. Fix: Always compute standard hours for actual output first: actual units × standard hours per unit.
- Mixing up the sign convention for fixed overhead expenditure variance. Fix: Use Budgeted − Actual. If you spent less than budget, it is favourable.
- Using actual price to value volume, mix or quantity variances Fix: Only the price variance uses AP. Volume, mix and quantity use budgeted price (turnover) or budgeted margin per unit (profit).
- Using selling price instead of margin in the profit method Fix: In the profit method, replace BP with budgeted profit per unit (BP − standard cost). Calculate it in a separate column first.
Exam tips
- Practise the F/A label until it is automatic. Many marks in MCQs are lost on direction, not calculation.
- For theory answers, list the types of standards with a one-line distinction each, then add attainability and motivation.
- In a case-based question, state the standard cost card first. It anchors every later variance.
- Write a short interpretation for each variance in descriptive questions, naming the likely cause and the responsible manager.
- When asked to differentiate standard costing and budgetary control, use points like unit versus total level, cost versus overall plan, and use for pricing and valuation.
- In MCQs, first decide whether the question wants a total or a material-wise variance, and whether it is favourable or adverse. Options often differ only in sign.
- With a single material, mix variance does not exist. Usage variance is the whole quantity variance.
- Check the wording on normal loss. If the standard has a normal loss, yield variance usually appears in the question.