CMA Final · Strategic Performance Management and Business Valuation
Business Valuation Methods and Approaches: formula sheet
Key formulas
- Fair market value (concept)
- FMV = price between a willing buyer and a willing seller, both informed, neither under compulsion
- Hypothetical market-based value. Not tied to any one buyer's synergies.
- Fair value (Ind AS 113)
- Fair value = price received to sell an asset or paid to transfer a liability in an orderly transaction between market participants at the measurement date
- An exit price from the market participant's view. Not the entity's own intended use.
- Investment value (concept)
- Investment value = value to a specific investor based on that investor's own requirements, synergies and expected returns
- Can differ from FMV. The gap often reflects the buyer's synergies.
- Premise of value
- Going concern value vs liquidation value (orderly or forced)
- Going concern normally gives a higher value than forced liquidation for a viable business.
- Valuation process
- Purpose → standard and premise → information → approach → computation → reconciliation → report
- Use this order as the skeleton of any descriptive answer.
- Net asset value (book)
- NAV = Total assets − Total outside liabilities
- Use assets that are real. Exclude fictitious assets such as preliminary expenses and debit balance of P&L.
- Adjusted net asset value
- Adjusted NAV = Fair value of all assets (including unrecorded) − Fair value of all liabilities (including unrecorded)
- Revalue each item. Add omitted items and remove overstated or fictitious ones.
- Liquidation value of equity
- Equity = Net realisable value of assets − Selling and liquidation costs − All liabilities
- Preference capital ranks before equity. Secured and statutory dues rank as per the legal order of payment.
- Value per equity share
- Value per share = Value attributable to equity ÷ Number of equity shares
- Deduct preference capital (with arrears if payable) before dividing.
- Replacement cost of an asset
- Replacement cost (net) = Current cost of equivalent new asset − Allowance for age and wear
- Apply the allowance only if you are valuing an existing used asset.
- FCFF
- FCFF = EBIT × (1 − t) + Depreciation − Capital expenditure − Increase in net working capital
- EBIT×(1−t) is NOPAT. Use only non-cash charges that you add back. Alternative: CFO + Interest × (1 − t) − Capex.
- FCFE
- FCFE = Net income + Depreciation − Capex − Increase in net working capital + Net borrowing
- Net borrowing = new debt raised − debt repaid. Also FCFE = FCFF − Interest × (1 − t) + Net borrowing.
- Cost of equity (CAPM)
- Ke = Rf + β × (Rm − Rf)
- (Rm − Rf) is the market risk premium. Use the beta that fits the firm's leverage.
- WACC
- WACC = E/(D+E) × Ke + D/(D+E) × Kd × (1 − t)
- Debt cost is taken after tax. Use target or market value weights.
- Present value of a cash flow
- PV = CF ÷ (1 + r)^n
- n is the year in which the cash flow arises.
- Terminal value (Gordon growth)
- TV at year n = CF(n+1) ÷ (r − g) = CF(n) × (1 + g) ÷ (r − g)
- Needs r > g. TV sits at the end of year n, so discount it by (1 + r)^n.
- Enterprise to equity value
- Equity value = Enterprise value − Debt + Cash and surplus assets
- Used with FCFF. Deduct debt at its market or book value as the question states.
- Capitalisation of earnings
- Value = Maintainable earnings ÷ Capitalisation rate
- Capitalisation rate = discount rate − growth rate when earnings grow steadily.
- Price-Earnings (P/E)
- P/E = Market price per share ÷ EPS = Market capitalisation ÷ Net profit
- Equity multiple. Target equity value = peer P/E × target net profit.
- Enterprise Value
- EV = Market capitalisation + Debt + Preference capital + Minority interest − Cash and cash equivalents
- Net debt = Debt − Cash. Include items consistently with the peers.
- EV/EBITDA
- EV/EBITDA = EV ÷ EBITDA
- Enterprise multiple. Target EV = peer multiple × target EBITDA.
- Price-to-Book (P/B)
- P/B = Market price per share ÷ Book value per share
- Equity multiple. Common for banks and financial firms.
- EV/Sales
- EV/Sales = EV ÷ Revenue
- Enterprise multiple. Used when earnings are negative or very low.
- Equity value from EV
- Equity value = EV − Net debt (− preference capital − minority interest)
- Always do this step after using an enterprise multiple.
- Value per share
- Value per share = Equity value ÷ Number of shares
- Use the shares outstanding for the target.
- EVA
- EVA = NOPAT − (WACC × Invested capital)
- NOPAT = EBIT × (1 − tax rate). Use capital at the start of the year unless the question says otherwise.
- Capital charge
- Capital charge = WACC × Invested capital
- Covers both debt and equity cost.
- Spread form of EVA
- EVA = (ROIC − WACC) × Invested capital
- ROIC = NOPAT ÷ Invested capital.
- MVA
- MVA = Market value of firm (equity + debt) − Capital invested
- Equity-only version: market capitalisation − book equity. Use the same basis on both sides.
- MVA from EVA
- MVA = Σ EVAt ÷ (1 + WACC)^t
- If EVA is a constant perpetuity, MVA = EVA ÷ WACC.
- Residual income
- RI = Profit − (Required rate × Capital)
- For equity: RI = Net profit − (Ke × Book equity).
- Residual income valuation
- Equity value = Book equity + PV of future RI
- Discount RI at the cost of equity.
- Excess earnings
- Excess earnings = Maintainable profit − (Normal rate × Net tangible assets)
- Goodwill = Excess earnings × years' purchase, or Excess earnings ÷ capitalisation rate.
- Control premium
- Control premium % = (Control value ÷ Marketable minority value) − 1
- Control value is the price per share for a controlling stake. The base is the marketable minority value.
- Value with control premium
- Controlling value = Marketable minority value × (1 + control premium)
- Use only when the base value is a minority value.
- Implied minority discount
- Minority discount % = 1 − [1 ÷ (1 + control premium)]
- Gives the discount that matches a given control premium. For a 25% premium it is 20%.
- Value after discounts
- Adjusted value = Base value × (1 − minority discount) × (1 − DLOM)
- Discounts are applied one after another (multiplicatively), not added together, unless the question says otherwise.
- Weighted final value
- Final value = Σ (Value by method × Weight), where Σ weights = 100%
- Weights reflect reliability of each method. Check that they add to 100%.
Quick revision
- The standard of value depends on the purpose of the valuation, so state it first.
- Going concern and liquidation premises can give very different values.
- Net asset value equals fair value of assets minus liabilities.
- DCF value equals the present value of forecast free cash flows plus the present value of terminal value.
- Free cash flows to the firm are discounted at WACC; flows to equity are discounted at cost of equity.
- Enterprise value minus net debt gives equity value, along with other claims as given in the question.
- Terminal value must use a growth rate below the discount rate.
- Use enterprise multiples for enterprise value and equity multiples for equity value.
- EVA = NOPAT − (invested capital × WACC).
- Positive EVA means returns exceed the cost of capital.
- Discounts and premiums apply after the base value, and only when the facts support them.
- Reconcile methods with reasoned weights and give one final value.
Common mistakes
- Treating fair market value and investment value as the same. Fix: Link FMV to a hypothetical informed buyer and seller, and investment value to one named investor with its own synergies.
- Saying a business has one true value. Fix: Say that value depends on purpose, standard, premise and date, and state these first.
- Deducting equity share capital and reserves as liabilities Fix: Deduct only outside liabilities and preference claims. Share capital and reserves are what you are trying to value.
- Keeping fictitious assets in the asset total Fix: Remove preliminary expenses, discount on issue of shares and the debit balance of the P&L account. They have no realisable value.
- Discounting FCFF at the cost of equity, or FCFE at WACC. Fix: FCFF is for all capital providers, so use WACC. FCFE is for shareholders only, so use cost of equity.
- Using the year-n cash flow instead of year n+1 in the terminal value. Fix: Multiply the last forecast cash flow by (1 + g) first. Then discount TV by the year-n factor, not n+1.
- Applying an EV multiple and reporting the result as equity value Fix: Whenever the multiple has EV in it, subtract net debt (and preference capital, minority interest) before stating equity value.
- Using a P/E multiple on EBITDA, or EV/EBITDA on net profit Fix: Write the multiple as a fraction first and apply it to the same denominator for the target.
- Deducting only interest instead of a full capital charge in EVA. Fix: Start from NOPAT before interest and charge WACC on total capital, debt plus equity.
- Using pre-tax cost of debt in WACC. Fix: Use Kd × (1 − t) in WACC every time.
Exam tips
- Begin every case answer with purpose, standard and premise. Examiners reward this structure.
- In MCQs, look for key phrases: willing buyer and seller points to fair market value; specific investor or synergy points to investment value; exit price at measurement date points to fair value.
- When comparing standards, use a three-point contrast and keep each point to one line.
- State the source of any definition you use, as company law, tax and accounting can differ in wording.
- For numerical differences between standards, identify the gap as buyer-specific synergy or similar item and explain it.
- Underline the premise word in the question: going concern, liquidation, forced sale or replacement. It decides which values you use.
- Show a clear schedule of adjustments. Marks are given for each correct revaluation even if the final figure is wrong.
- In case-based MCQs, ask which items are fictitious or unrecorded before you total anything.