CMA Final · Strategic Performance Management and Business Valuation
Fundamentals of Business Valuation: formula sheet
Key formulas
- Value versus price
- Value = estimate of worth (analysis, stated date, stated standard); Price = amount actually agreed and paid
- Price can differ from value. Never use the two words as if they mean the same.
- Valuation frame
- Valuation = Purpose + Valuation date + Standard of value + Premise + Approach
- Write these five items first in any answer. The premise is usually going concern or liquidation.
- Gain from a deal to a buyer
- Value to buyer = Standalone value of target + Value of synergies; Gain to buyer = Value to buyer − Price paid
- A buyer gains only if the price is below the value to that buyer.
- Gain to a seller
- Gain to seller = Price received − Seller's standalone value
- Both sides can gain when price lies between standalone value and value to the buyer.
- Fair market value test
- FMV = price between a hypothetical willing buyer and willing seller, both informed, neither under compulsion
- Not buyer-specific. Synergies special to one buyer are generally excluded.
- Fair value (Ind AS 113)
- Fair value = exit price in an orderly transaction between market participants at the measurement date
- Market-based, not entity-specific. Mention the measurement date.
- Investment value
- Investment value = value to a particular investor using that investor's own cash flows, synergies and required return
- Entity or investor specific, so it can differ from FMV.
- Intrinsic value comparison
- If intrinsic value > market price: undervalued. If intrinsic value < market price: overvalued
- Intrinsic value is an estimate, so the conclusion depends on the assumptions.
- Liquidation value
- Net liquidation value = Realisable value of assets − Costs of disposal − Liabilities settled
- Use lower values for forced sale and higher values for orderly sale.
- Going concern premise
- Going concern value = present value of expected future cash flows of continuing operations
- Typically higher than liquidation value for a profitable business.
- Value as present value of future cash flows
- Value = Σ [CFt ÷ (1 + r)^t] + Terminal value ÷ (1 + r)^n
- Cash flows, discount rate r and growth (inside terminal value) are the three channels through which every factor acts.
- Gordon growth terminal value
- TV = CF(n+1) ÷ (r − g)
- Valid only when r > g and g is a stable long-term growth rate. A small change in r or g changes value sharply.
- Capitalisation of maintainable earnings
- Value = Maintainable earnings ÷ Capitalisation rate
- Capitalisation rate rises with risk, so higher risk means lower value for the same earnings.
- Factor-to-channel rule
- Factor → effect on cash flow, risk or growth → effect on value
- Use this chain to explain any factor in a descriptive answer.
- Normalised earnings
- Normalised earnings = Reported profit ± non-recurring items ± non-market adjustments
- Add back one-off losses and subtract one-off gains. Adjust owner pay and related-party items to market levels. Consider the tax effect if the question asks for post-tax figures.
- Equity value from enterprise value
- Equity value = Enterprise value − Debt + Surplus (non-operating) assets
- Use cash and debt as at the valuation date. Add non-operating assets only if their income is excluded from the earnings you valued.
- Reconciled value
- Concluded value = Σ (value from each method × weight), where weights add up to 100%
- Weights must be justified by purpose and data reliability.
- Value after discount
- Adjusted value = Base value × (1 − discount %)
- Apply a marketability or minority discount only to the interest it relates to, and only once.
- Net Asset Value (NAV)
- NAV = Value of assets − Outside liabilities (including preference capital, if any, ranking before equity)
- Use fair values for the adjusted method. Exclude fictitious assets such as preliminary expenses and accumulated losses shown as assets.
- NAV per equity share
- NAV per share = (Assets − Outside liabilities − Preference capital) ÷ Number of equity shares
- Check whether the question wants value of the business or value per share.
- Capitalisation of maintainable earnings
- Value = Future maintainable profit ÷ Capitalisation rate
- Use profit after adjusting for non-recurring items. The rate is the required rate of return.
- Discounted Cash Flow
- Value = Σ [CFt ÷ (1 + r)^t] + Terminal value ÷ (1 + r)^n
- Terminal value by Gordon growth = CFn+1 ÷ (r − g), valid only when r > g.
- Equity value from enterprise value
- Equity value = Enterprise value − Debt + Cash and surplus assets
- Needed when a multiple such as EV/EBITDA or free cash flow to firm is used.
- Value using a multiple
- Value = Peer multiple × Subject company's metric (e.g. P/E × EPS)
- Peers must be similar in size, risk, growth and business.
- Present value
- PV = CF ÷ (1 + r)^n
- Use PV of annuity or perpetuity formulas for repeating cash flows.
- Growing perpetuity
- PV = CF₁ ÷ (r − g)
- Valid only when r > g. CF₁ is the cash flow one year ahead.
- CAPM cost of equity
- Ke = Rf + β × (Rm − Rf)
- (Rm − Rf) is the market risk premium. Do not subtract Rf twice.
- After-tax cost of debt
- Kd (after tax) = Kd × (1 − t)
- Use the tax rate that applies to the interest deduction.
- WACC
- WACC = E/(D+E) × Ke + D/(D+E) × Kd × (1 − t)
- Weights should be at market or target capital structure values.
- FCFF
- FCFF = EBIT × (1 − t) + Depreciation − Capex − Increase in working capital
- Discount at WACC to get enterprise value.
- FCFE
- FCFE = FCFF − Interest × (1 − t) + Net borrowing
- Discount at cost of equity to get equity value directly.
- Terminal value (Gordon growth)
- TV at year n = FCF(n+1) ÷ (r − g) = FCFn × (1 + g) ÷ (r − g)
- Discount TV back n years at the same rate used for the flows.
- Equity value from enterprise value
- Equity value = Enterprise value − Debt + Cash and surplus assets
- Needed when you use FCFF.
- Who values under the Companies Act
- Valuation event under the Act (e.g. section 62 preferential allotment by an unlisted company, section 192, sections 230-232) → registered valuer (registered for the asset class) → appointed as section 247 provides
- Section 247 is not a valuation event. It governs the appointment, qualifications and duties of the valuer: where the Act requires a valuation, the audit committee, or the Board if there is none, appoints the registered valuer. The events that need a valuation sit in other provisions. For example, under section 62(1)(c) read with Rule 13 of the Companies (Share Capital and Debentures) Rules, a valuation report from a registered valuer is required for a preferential allotment of shares by a company that is not listed. A listed company prices its preferential issue under SEBI ICDR. In a scheme under sections 230-232 the Tribunal can direct a valuation. Check the provision for the event in the question.
- Registered valuer route
- Qualification + experience + valuation exam → enrolment with RVO → registration with the designated authority
- Registration is asset-class specific. Do not state exact years of experience unless you are sure of them.
- Core ethical principles
- Integrity, independence, objectivity, competence, confidentiality, disclosure of interest
- Use these as headings in any code-of-conduct answer.
- Standards hierarchy
- Notified valuation standards → (if none) standards of professional bodies such as ICMAI
- Say the valuer must state the standard followed in the report.
Quick revision
- Valuation gives an estimate of worth for a stated purpose, date and standard; there is no single value for all purposes.
- Purpose decides the standard and premise of value, so state it first in any answer.
- Going concern premise assumes the business continues; liquidation premise assumes assets are sold off.
- Value depends on factors such as earnings, growth, risk, industry, economy, management and marketability.
- The valuation date matters because information and market conditions change over time.
- Asset approach values what the business owns less what it owes.
- Income approach converts expected future benefits into present value.
- Market approach uses prices of comparable businesses or transactions.
- Present value = future amount ÷ (1 + r)ⁿ, where r is the discount rate per period and n is the number of periods.
- Higher risk means a higher discount rate and, other things equal, a lower present value.
- A valuer must be independent, objective, competent and keep client information confidential.
- Where a method needs judgement, document your assumptions and reasons.
Common mistakes
- Treating value and price as the same thing. Fix: Define value as an estimate at a date and price as the amount agreed. Add one reason they differ, such as synergy or negotiation.
- Saying a business has one true value. Fix: Say value depends on purpose, standard of value, premise and assumptions. Different purposes can justify different figures.
- Treating fair market value and fair value as identical in every context. Fix: Say that fair value under Ind AS 113 is an exit price at the measurement date, while FMV is the price between a hypothetical willing buyer and seller. Note that they often give similar numbers but differ in definition and context.
- Confusing intrinsic value with market value. Fix: Market value is the price observed in trading. Intrinsic value is an analyst's estimate from fundamentals. Their gap signals under or overvaluation.
- Listing factors without saying how they change value. Fix: Add the direction and the channel for every factor: for example, rising interest rates raise the discount rate, so value falls.
- Putting external factors such as interest rates under internal factors, or the reverse. Fix: Ask whether management can decide it. Capital structure is internal. Market interest rates are external.
- Starting calculations before fixing the standard of value and valuation date. Fix: Always open by stating purpose, standard, premise and date. Use balance sheet figures as at that date.
- Adding back all expenses instead of only non-recurring ones. Fix: Adjust only items that will not recur or are not at market terms. Recurring costs stay.
- Using book values in NAV without adjusting for fair value or fictitious assets. Fix: Remove fictitious assets, revalue assets given in the question, and add omitted liabilities before computing NAV.
- Forgetting to deduct preference capital before finding value per equity share. Fix: Deduct preference capital (and arrears if stated) from net assets before dividing by equity shares.
Exam tips
- Begin every case answer with the purpose and valuation date. Examiners reward this framing.
- In MCQs, reject options that say value equals price or that one value fits every purpose.
- Link each purpose to its need in one line, such as exchange ratio for M&A or independence for litigation.
- When a deal price is given, compute value to the buyer (standalone plus synergy) and compare it with price to show who gains.
- Finish case answers with a clear recommendation, not just definitions.
- In MCQs, the keywords decide the answer: hypothetical buyer means FMV, specific buyer or synergy means investment value, exit price or Ind AS means fair value.
- When asked for differences, use a two-column style in sentences or bullets covering basis, party, synergies and typical use.
- In case answers, always state the premise as an assumption and say why the facts support it.