CMA Final · Strategic Performance Management and Business Valuation
Valuation of Assets and Liabilities: formula sheet
Key formulas
- Value vs price
- Value = estimated worth for a purpose and date; Price = amount actually paid
- Price can differ from value because of urgency, negotiation, or special buyer motives.
- Fair market value test
- FMV = price between hypothetical willing, informed buyer and seller, neither under compulsion
- It is a hypothetical, not a real, transaction. Buyer-specific synergies are excluded.
- Fair value (Ind AS 113)
- Fair value = exit price in an orderly transaction between market participants at the measurement date
- It is market-based, not entity-specific. Transaction costs are not deducted from the fair value.
- Investment value
- Investment value = worth to a specific investor given its own requirements and synergies
- It can be higher than fair market value. It is not a market-participant view.
- Premise link
- Going concern ≥ orderly liquidation ≥ forced liquidation (usual order of value)
- This is a general tendency for an asset, not a guaranteed rule. For a loss-making business, liquidation value can exceed going-concern value.
- Adjusted net asset value
- Adjusted net assets = Fair value of assets − Fair value of liabilities (including contingent liabilities that are likely)
- Add unrecorded assets such as brands if they can be valued. Value per share = adjusted net assets ÷ number of equity shares, after deducting preference capital if any.
- Market multiple valuation
- Value = Comparable multiple × Subject's metric (e.g. P/E × EPS, or EV/EBITDA × EBITDA)
- With an EV multiple you get enterprise value. Deduct net debt to reach equity value.
- Present value of a cash flow
- PV = CF ÷ (1 + r)^n
- r is the discount rate and n the year. Discount each year's cash flow separately.
- Terminal value (constant growth)
- TV at end of year n = CFₙ × (1 + g) ÷ (r − g)
- Valid only when r > g. Discount TV back using the year-n factor.
- Enterprise to equity value
- Equity value = Enterprise value − Debt + Cash and surplus assets
- Use FCFF discounted at WACC to get enterprise value.
- Depreciated replacement cost (DRC)
- DRC = Replacement cost new − Physical deterioration − Functional obsolescence − Economic obsolescence
- Use for plant, machinery and specialised buildings. If a question gives a total depreciation percentage, apply it to replacement cost new.
- Straight-line physical depreciation
- Depreciation % = Age ÷ Total useful life × 100
- Use effective age (condition-based) if the question gives it instead of actual age.
- Cost of replacement with price index
- Replacement cost new = Historical cost × (Current index ÷ Index at purchase)
- Use when no current quote is given. Index trending is only an estimate.
- Net realisable value (NRV)
- NRV = Estimated selling price − Cost to complete − Selling costs
- Compare with cost item by item or group by group, not on the grand total of unrelated items.
- Inventory carrying value
- Lower of cost and NRV
- This is the usual accounting rule under Ind AS 2. For fair value purposes, follow the basis stated in the question.
- Building value (cost method)
- Value = Land value + (Replacement cost of building − Depreciation)
- Value land separately by market comparison. Do not depreciate land.
- Capitalised rental value
- Value = Net annual income ÷ Capitalisation rate
- Net income is after outgoings such as property tax and maintenance.
- Scaling by capacity (cost approach)
- Cost of new asset = Cost of known asset × (New capacity ÷ Known capacity)^n
- Use only if the question gives the exponent n. Often n is given as 0.6.
- Relief-from-royalty value
- Value = Σ [Revenue_t × Royalty rate × (1 − Tax rate)] ÷ (1 + r)^t
- Use only the revenue attributable to the asset. Add terminal value if life is indefinite.
- Excess earnings
- Excess cash flow = After-tax operating profit from the asset − Contributory asset charges
- Contributory charge = fair value of asset × required return on that asset. Discount excess cash flow at the rate for the intangible being valued.
- Contributory asset charge
- Charge = Fair value (or carrying value) of contributory asset × Required return
- Charge is pre-tax or post-tax consistently with the profit it is deducted from.
- Goodwill under Ind AS 103
- Goodwill = Consideration + NCI + Fair value of previously held interest − Fair value of identifiable net assets
- A negative figure is a bargain purchase gain, recognised in other comprehensive income and accumulated in equity as capital reserve after reassessment.
- Cost method
- Value = Replacement or reproduction cost − Obsolescence
- Ignores future profit. Suits assembled workforce or internally developed software.
- Present value of annuity-type flows
- PV = CF ÷ (1 + r)^t, summed over useful life
- Limit the sum to the remaining useful life, for example customer attrition period.
- Bond value
- V = Σ [C ÷ (1 + r)^t] + M ÷ (1 + r)^n
- C is the periodic coupon, r the periodic YTM, M the redemption value, n the number of periods. Use half-yearly r and n for half-yearly coupons.
- Approximate YTM
- YTM ≈ [C + (M − P) ÷ n] ÷ [(M + P) ÷ 2]
- P is the current price. This is an estimate. Use trial and error with interpolation for an exact figure.
- Perpetual preference share or irredeemable debt
- V = D ÷ r
- D is the fixed annual dividend or interest. Applies only when the payments are perpetual and constant.
- Redeemable preference share
- V = Σ [D ÷ (1 + r)^t] + M ÷ (1 + r)^n
- Same structure as a bond, with the dividend in place of the coupon.
- Constant growth (Gordon) model
- P0 = D1 ÷ (r − g)
- D1 = D0 × (1 + g). Valid only when r > g and growth is constant forever.
- CAPM cost of equity
- r = Rf + β × (Rm − Rf)
- Rf is the risk-free rate, Rm the market return.
- Ind AS 113 hierarchy
- Level 1: quoted prices, identical items. Level 2: other observable inputs. Level 3: unobservable inputs
- Highest priority goes to Level 1. Classify by the lowest-level significant input.
- Convertible debenture split
- Liability component = PV of cash flows at the market rate for similar non-convertible debt; equity component = issue price − liability component
- Done at initial recognition. Equity part is not remeasured later.
- Present value of a single future payment
- PV = FV ÷ (1 + r)^n
- r is the discount rate per period and n the number of periods. Use the rate matching the liability's risk.
- Value of debt with periodic interest
- Value = Σ [Interest ÷ (1 + r)^t] + Redemption amount ÷ (1 + r)^n
- Interest is coupon rate × face value. r is the current market yield, not the coupon rate.
- Present value of an annuity
- PV = A × [1 − (1 + r)^−n] ÷ r
- Use for equal instalments at the end of each period (ordinary annuity).
- Expected value of a provision
- Expected value = Σ (Outflow × Probability)
- Suits a large population of items, such as warranties. For a single obligation, the most likely outcome may be the better estimate.
- Unwinding of discount
- Finance cost for the year = Opening provision × discount rate
- The discounted provision grows each year and the increase is charged as a finance cost.
- Equity value after liabilities
- Equity value = Enterprise value − Debt − Other debt-like items (provisions, guarantees likely to be called)
- Add cash and non-operating assets where relevant. Do not deduct the same item twice.
- Ind AS 37 treatment rule
- Probable + reliable estimate → Provision; Possible, or probable but not reliably measurable → Disclose; Remote → Ignore
- Apply it to every item in a case before computing anything.
- Recoverable amount
- Recoverable amount = Higher of (FVLCD, Value in use)
- If either one is above the carrying amount, the asset is not impaired and you need not estimate the other.
- Fair value less costs of disposal
- FVLCD = Fair value − Direct costs of disposal
- Costs include legal costs and transaction costs of sale. Finance costs and tax expense are not disposal costs.
- Value in use
- VIU = Σ [Cash flow in year t ÷ (1 + r)^t], including net disposal proceeds at end of life
- Use pre-tax cash flows and a pre-tax discount rate. Exclude financing cash flows, tax receipts or payments, and enhancement of the asset's performance not yet committed.
- Impairment loss
- Impairment loss = Carrying amount − Recoverable amount (only if positive)
- Recognise in profit or loss, or against revaluation surplus for a revalued asset.
- Allocation of CGU loss
- Step 1: reduce goodwill. Step 2: reduce other assets pro rata to carrying amounts.
- No asset is reduced below the highest of its FVLCD, its VIU (if determinable) and zero.
- Reversal limit
- Reversal ≤ Carrying amount that would have existed (net of depreciation) had no impairment been recognised
- Reversal is allowed for assets other than goodwill. Impairment of goodwill is never reversed.
Quick revision
- Value depends on purpose, date and the basis chosen; always state them first.
- Cost approach: what it would cost to replace or reproduce the asset, less obsolescence.
- Market approach: use prices of comparable assets or transactions, adjusted for differences.
- Income approach: present value of expected future benefits at a suitable discount rate.
- Present value = cash flow ÷ (1 + r)^n for a single cash flow in year n.
- Intangibles are usually valued by income methods when no market prices exist.
- Financial assets with active market prices are valued at those quoted prices.
- A provision is a present obligation with a reliable estimate; a contingent liability is only disclosed.
- Impairment loss = carrying amount − recoverable amount, when carrying amount is higher.
- Recoverable amount is the higher of fair value less costs of disposal and value in use.
- Always end with a clear final value and the assumptions behind it.
Common mistakes
- Treating value and price as the same thing. Fix: Write one line each: value is an estimate for a purpose and date; price is the amount actually paid. Show the gap if the question gives both.
- Adding buyer-specific synergies to fair market value. Fix: Include synergies only under investment value. Fair market value uses a hypothetical buyer and excludes them.
- Using book values in the adjusted net asset method. Fix: Restate every asset and liability to fair value first. Add unrecorded items and remove assets or liabilities that do not exist.
- Applying an EV multiple and stopping there. Fix: Always subtract debt and add cash to reach equity value before dividing by shares.
- Depreciating land along with the building. Fix: Split the property. Land stays at market value. Only the building is depreciated.
- Applying depreciation to historical cost instead of replacement cost new. Fix: In the cost approach, first update to today's cost of a new equivalent asset. Then deduct depreciation from that figure.
- Treating goodwill as an asset valued by royalty or excess earnings. Fix: Goodwill is a residual under Ind AS 103. Value identifiable assets first, then compute goodwill by subtraction.
- Applying the royalty rate to total company revenue. Fix: Apply the royalty only to revenue that uses the brand or patent.
- Using the annual rate and annual periods for a half-yearly coupon bond. Fix: Halve the coupon and the YTM, and double the number of periods before looking up any factor.
- Applying D ÷ r to a share whose dividend is growing, or using D0 instead of D1 in the Gordon model. Fix: Check the growth wording. If there is growth, compute D1 = D0 × (1 + g) first, then divide by (r − g).
Exam tips
- Open every theory answer with purpose, date, standard and premise. Examiners reward this framing.
- In MCQs, watch the keywords: 'exit price' means fair value, 'hypothetical' means fair market value, 'specific investor' means investment value.
- When a question gives both a price and a valuation, comment on the gap. Do not treat them as the same number.
- Be careful with absolute words such as 'always'. Liquidation value can exceed going-concern value for weak businesses.
- For case scenarios, name the standard you chose and give one line of reasoning. A clear recommendation earns more than a long list of definitions.
- Read the data first. Questions usually supply only what the intended approach needs.
- Show the equity bridge (EV less debt plus cash) on its own line. Examiners look for it.
- In MCQs, check the premise: liquidation points to net realisable asset values, going concern to income or market.