CMA Intermediate · Direct and Indirect Taxation
Composition Levy: formula sheet
Key formulas
- Turnover limit
- Aggregate turnover in preceding financial year ≤ ₹50,00,000
- Section 10(1) and 10(2A). The Government may notify a higher limit, not above ₹1,50,00,000, for section 10(1). Aggregate turnover includes supplies made from 1 April up to the date you become liable for registration, but excludes exempt interest or discount on deposits, loans and advances.
- Maximum rate ceilings in the Act
- Manufacturer: up to 1% | Restaurant-type supplies (Sch II para 6(b)): up to 2.5% | Other suppliers: up to 0.5% | Section 10(2A): up to 3%
- These are ceilings in the Act. The rate you actually pay is the one prescribed in Rule 7.
- Rates prescribed by Rule 7
- Manufacturers: 0.5% | Para 6(b) suppliers: 2.5% | Other eligible suppliers: 0.5% of turnover of taxable supplies | Section 10(2A) persons: 3%
- Rate applies to turnover in the State or Union territory. Turnover before becoming liable for registration and exempt interest services are excluded from this turnover.
- Services allowance
- Services value ≤ higher of (10% of preceding-year turnover in the State/UT, ₹5,00,000)
- Second proviso to section 10(1). It does not cover restaurant-type supplies under clause (b) of paragraph 6 of Schedule II.
- Excluded persons (section 10(2))
- No non-taxable supplies | No inter-State outward supplies | No supply through an e-commerce operator liable to collect tax under section 52 | No notified goods manufacture | Not casual taxable or non-resident taxable person
- Also, save as provided, you must not be engaged in the supply of services.
- Same PAN rule
- All registered persons with the same PAN must opt together
- Proviso to section 10(2) and 10(2A). If one of them does not opt, none is eligible.
- Effect of opting
- No tax collected from recipient; no input tax credit
- Section 10(4).
- Lapse of option
- Option lapses from the day aggregate turnover in the financial year exceeds the limit
- Section 10(3).
- Composition tax payable
- Tax = Rate × Turnover in the State or Union territory (as defined for composition)
- The tax is a single amount. Do not split it into CGST and SGST unless the question asks. It is payable in lieu of tax under section 9(1).
- Rule 7 Row 1: Manufacturers
- 0.5% of turnover in the State or Union territory
- Does not apply to manufacturers of goods notified by the Government, who are not eligible under section 10(2)(e).
- Rule 7 Row 2: Clause (b) of paragraph 6 of Schedule II suppliers
- 2.5% of turnover in the State or Union territory
- Restaurant-type supplies of goods as part of a service.
- Rule 7 Row 3: Any other supplier under section 10(1) and (2)
- 0.5% of turnover of taxable supplies of goods and services in the State or Union territory
- Traders fall here. The base is taxable supplies only.
- Rule 7 Row 4: Section 10(2A) suppliers
- 3% of turnover of supplies of goods and services in the State or Union territory
- For persons not eligible under section 10(1) and (2), such as service providers or mixed suppliers. Aggregate turnover in the preceding financial year must not exceed fifty lakh rupees.
- Statutory ceilings in section 10
- Manufacturer 1%; clause (b) of paragraph 6 of Schedule II supplier 2.5%; other suppliers 0.5%; section 10(2A) 3%
- These are maximums. Rule 7 rates are what apply. Manufacturers pay 0.5% against a 1% ceiling. For Row 4, the prescribed rate of 3% equals the ceiling.
- Turnover limit for opting
- Aggregate turnover in the preceding financial year ≤ ₹50 lakh (can be raised by notification up to ₹1.5 crore)
- Section 10(1) proviso. Eligibility is tested on aggregate turnover of the preceding financial year; Explanation 1 to section 10 adds supplies made from 1 April up to the date the person becomes liable for registration. The tax is levied on turnover in the State or Union territory, as defined in Explanation 2.
- Opting by a registered person
- FORM GST CMP-02 before the start of the financial year; ITC-03 within 60 days from the start of that year
- Rule 3(3). Rule 4(1): the option is effective from the beginning of the financial year.
- Opting at fresh registration
- Part B of FORM GST REG-01 = intimation
- Rule 3(2). Considered only after registration is granted; effective from the date fixed under rule 10(2) or (3) (Rule 4(2)).
- Stock details on opting (provisional registrants, rule 3(1))
- FORM GST CMP-03 within 90 days from the date the option is exercised
- Rule 3(4). Details of stock held on the day preceding the date of opting, including inward supplies from unregistered persons.
- Ceasing to satisfy conditions
- Liable under section 9(1) from the day of default; issue tax invoices; file CMP-04 within 7 days
- Rule 6(2).
- Voluntary withdrawal
- Application in FORM GST CMP-04 before the date of withdrawal
- Rule 6(3). Signed or verified by EVC, filed electronically.
- Officer's denial of option
- CMP-05 (show cause, reply within 15 days) → CMP-06 (reply) → CMP-07 (order within 30 days of reply)
- Rule 6(4) and (5). Denial can operate from the date of option or from the date of the contravention.
- Stock statement after withdrawal or denial
- FORM GST ITC-01 within 30 days from the date of withdrawal or the date of the CMP-07 order
- Rule 6(6). Covers inputs and inputs contained in semi-finished or finished goods held in stock.
- Returns under composition
- CMP-08 by the 18th of the month after each quarter; GSTR-4 annually, due 30 June for FY 2024-25 onwards
- Rule 62(1). Earlier text gave 30 April; the proviso moves it to 30 June from FY 2024-25.
- Tax payable under composition
- Tax = Turnover of taxable supplies in the State/UT × Rule 7 rate
- Rates are total rates, split equally between CGST and SGST/UTGST: 1% for traders (0.5% + 0.5%), 2% for manufacturers (1% + 1%), 5% for restaurants not serving alcohol (2.5% + 2.5%), and 6% for service providers under Section 10(2A) (3% + 3%). The base is turnover of taxable supplies in the State/UT, not profit.
- ITC position
- ITC on inputs = Nil; tax collected from customers = Nil
- Both are barred while you are in the scheme. Tax on purchases is a cost.
- Document to issue
- Bill of supply (not tax invoice)
- It must carry the words "composition taxable person, not eligible to collect tax on supplies".
- Returns and due dates
- CMP-08: 18th of the month after each quarter. GSTR-4: 30 April after the financial year
- CMP-08 is the quarterly statement-cum-challan. GSTR-4 is the annual return. Late payment attracts interest, and late GSTR-4 attracts late fee.
- Reverse charge
- Reverse charge tax on inward supplies at the normal rate, paid in cash, no ITC
- Composition does not remove your liability under reverse charge.
- Ceasing to be eligible
- Intimation in FORM GST CMP-04 within 7 days of the date of contravention; claim ITC on stock in FORM GST ITC-01 within 30 days of the date you become liable to regular tax
- You are a regular taxpayer from the date of the contravention, for example when turnover crosses the limit. For capital goods, ITC is allowed after reducing tax by 5 percentage points per quarter or part thereof from the invoice date.
Quick revision
- Composition is an optional scheme under section 10; the person pays tax on turnover at a flat rate.
- Under rule 5, a casual taxable person or a non-resident taxable person cannot opt.
- Under rule 5, the composition person pays tax under section 9(3) or 9(4) on inward supplies (reverse charge).
- Goods in stock bought from an unregistered supplier are allowed only if the person pays tax under section 9(4).
- A composition person issues a bill of supply, not a tax invoice, marked "composition taxable person, not eligible to collect tax on supplies".
- The words "composition taxable person" must be on every notice or signboard at the principal and every additional place of business.
- Rule 7 rates: manufacturers 0.5%; supplies under clause (b) of paragraph 6 of Schedule II 2.5%; other suppliers 0.5% of turnover of taxable supplies; section 10(2A) persons 3%.
- Option under rule 3(3) is effective from the beginning of the financial year; under rule 3(1) from the appointed day.
- No fresh intimation is needed every year; the option continues subject to the Act and Rules.
- On ceasing to meet a condition, tax is payable under section 9(1) from that day, and CMP-04 is due within seven days.
- Show-cause notice CMP-05 gives fifteen days; the officer's order CMP-07 comes within thirty days of the reply.
- ITC-01 stock statement is due within thirty days of withdrawal or of the CMP-07 order; withdrawal or denial for one place applies to all places on the same PAN.
Common mistakes
- Testing the current year's turnover for eligibility to opt. Fix: Eligibility to opt uses the preceding financial year. The current year matters only for lapse under section 10(3), when turnover exceeds the limit.
- Allowing a composition person to make inter-State outward supplies. Fix: Section 10(2)(c) bars inter-State outward supplies of goods or services. One such supply means the person is not eligible.
- Using 1% for manufacturers because section 10 says one per cent. Fix: Rule 7 is the operative rate for the question. Use 0.5% for manufacturers. Remember: section 10 is the ceiling, Rule 7 is the rate.
- Applying 2.5% to all service-related businesses. Fix: 2.5% applies to supplies of goods as part of a service under clause (b) of paragraph 6 of Schedule II. A general service provider under section 10(2A) pays 3%.
- Saying the option is effective from the date the CMP-02 is filed. Fix: Rule 4(1): for a CMP-02 intimation under rule 3(3), the option is effective from the beginning of the financial year.
- Mixing up CMP-02 and CMP-04. Fix: CMP-02 is for opting in; CMP-04 is for withdrawal or intimation of ceasing to be eligible.
- Claiming ITC on purchases because the supplier charged GST. Fix: ITC is barred for the composition taxpayer himself. The tax paid on purchases is simply part of cost.
- Showing GST separately on the customer bill. Fix: A composition taxpayer pays from his own pocket at a flat rate. He issues a bill of supply with no tax shown.
Exam tips
- In case studies, write the answer as a short checklist: turnover limit, exclusion list, services, PAN, Rule 5 conditions. Give one line of reasoning for each so you earn step marks.
- For MCQs, scan first for the red flags: inter-State supply, e-commerce operator under section 52, non-taxable supplies, casual or non-resident person. These usually decide the answer.
- Keep the limit and rates straight: ₹50 lakh preceding-year limit, ceilings in section 10, actual rates in Rule 7, and 3% for section 10(2A). Do not mix them up.
- Quote section 10(3) and 10(4) in your conclusion: the option lapses when turnover crosses the limit, and there is no tax collection or ITC.
- When a question gives a notified higher limit, use it for section 10(1), but never above ₹1.5 crore.
- In MCQs, the trap is nearly always the rate. Memorise the four Rule 7 rows: 0.5%, 2.5%, 0.5%, 3%.
- In written answers, name the row and the source, for example 'Rule 7 of the CGST Rules, 2017, Row 3', then show the multiplication. This earns step marks even if the figures slip.
- Read the facts for exclusions: pre-registration supplies and exempt interest. Examiners hide these in a line of the question.