CMA Intermediate · Direct and Indirect Taxation
Levy and Collection of CGST and IGST: formula sheet
Key formulas
- CGST charging rule (section 9(1))
- CGST = notified rate (not above 20%) × value under section 15, on intra-State supplies
- Levied on supply of goods or services or both. Liquor for human consumption is excluded.
- IGST charging rule (section 5(1) IGST Act)
- IGST = notified rate (not above 40%) × value under section 15 of the CGST Act, on inter-State supplies
- The value rule is borrowed from the CGST Act. Imports of goods follow the proviso.
- Who pays
- Taxable person (supplier) by default; recipient under section 9(3) or 9(4); e-commerce operator under section 9(5)
- Reverse charge and operator liability apply only to categories notified by the Government.
- Petroleum products
- Tax applies from a date to be notified (section 9(2); section 5(2) IGST Act)
- Covers petroleum crude, high speed diesel, petrol, natural gas and aviation turbine fuel.
- Imported goods
- IGST on imports of goods = levied under section 3 of the Customs Tariff Act, 1975, on value under that Act
- Collected when customs duty is levied under section 12 of the Customs Act, 1962. Notified goods are excluded.
- Basic test of supply (section 7(1)(a))
- Supply under clause (a) = supply of goods or services or both (in forms such as sale, transfer, barter, exchange, licence, rental, lease, disposal) + made or agreed to be made for a consideration + by a person in the course or furtherance of business
- Three elements are essential: a supply of goods or services or both, consideration, and the course or furtherance of business. The listed forms are examples ('such as'), not a closed list or a separate condition. Missing any essential element means it is not a supply under clause (a), unless clause (aa), (b) or (c) applies.
- Other inclusions in supply
- Section 7(1)(aa): supplies between a non-individual person and its members for consideration | Section 7(1)(b): import of services for consideration, business or not | Section 7(1)(c): Schedule I activities without consideration
- Clause (b) does not need the business condition. Clause (c) does not need consideration.
- Classification of a supply
- Section 7(1A): activities treated as supply of goods or services as per Schedule II
- This decides whether the supply is goods or services. It does not decide whether there is a supply.
- Not a supply
- Section 7(2): Schedule III activities, and notified public-authority activities = neither goods nor services
- This overrides section 7(1). Check it before concluding a transaction is taxable.
- Taxable person vs registered person
- Taxable person = registered OR liable to be registered | Registered person = actually holds registration
- Registered person is a subset of taxable person. This status is separate from the test of supply: it tells you who the person is, not whether a supply exists.
- CGST rate ceiling
- CGST rate ≤ 20% (Section 9(1), CGST Act)
- Applies to intra-State supplies. The actual rate is notified by the Government on the Council's recommendation.
- IGST rate ceiling
- IGST rate ≤ 40% (Section 5(1), IGST Act)
- Applies to inter-State supplies. Notified in the same manner.
- Alcoholic liquor exclusion
- No CGST or IGST on alcoholic liquor for human consumption, and on un-denatured extra neutral alcohol or rectified spirit used to make it
- The extra neutral alcohol and rectified spirit words were inserted w.e.f. 1-11-2024.
- Petroleum products
- CGST: Section 9(2). IGST: Section 5(2). Levy from a date notified on the Council's recommendation
- Covers petroleum crude, high speed diesel, petrol, natural gas and aviation turbine fuel.
- Value on which tax is charged
- Value determined under Section 15 of the CGST Act
- Both CGST and IGST use this value.
- IGST on imports
- Levied under Section 3 of the Customs Tariff Act, 1975, on value as per that Act, when customs duty is levied
- Proviso to Section 5(1) of the IGST Act. Notified goods are excluded from the proviso.
- Section 9(3) rule
- Notified goods or services → tax payable by the recipient
- Applies whether the supplier is registered or not, as the notification specifies. The recipient is treated as the person liable to pay tax.
- Section 9(4) rule
- Notified class of registered recipient + specified goods or services + unregistered supplier → recipient pays tax
- All three conditions must hold. Supply from a registered supplier does not fall under this sub-section.
- RCM tax computation
- Tax = Value of supply (section 15) × notified rate
- Intra-State: CGST + SGST/UTGST. Inter-State: IGST. No tax is charged by the supplier on the invoice.
- Input tax credit on RCM
- ITC = tax paid under RCM, if section 16 conditions are met
- Tax must actually be paid first, in cash. Credit can be taken only after payment, and only if the supply is for business.
- Section 9(5) rule
- Notified services supplied through an e-commerce operator → operator pays tax
- Separate from RCM under 9(3) and 9(4). The operator is treated as the supplier.
- Section 9(5) liability rule
- Notified service + supplied through operator + intra-State supply ⇒ operator pays CGST (as if operator is the supplier)
- Applies only to categories of services notified by the Government on the Council's recommendation. Not all services on a platform.
- Operator without physical presence
- Representative in taxable territory pays; if none, operator must appoint a person who pays
- Given in the two provisos to section 9(5).
- TCS under section 52(1)
- Amount collected = notified rate (not exceeding 1%) × net value of taxable supplies
- Applies where the operator collects the consideration. Rate is as notified.
- Net value of taxable supplies (section 52)
- Net value = taxable supplies by all registered persons through operator in the month (other than 9(5) services) − taxable supplies returned in the month
- Services notified under section 9(5) are excluded.
- TCS payment and statement dates
- Pay TCS and file monthly statement within 10 days after end of the month
- Annual statement is due before 31 December following the end of the financial year.
- Registration
- Persons liable under section 9(5) and every operator required to collect tax under section 52 must register
- Section 24(iv) and 24(x). Section 24(ix) covers suppliers supplying other than 9(5) services through an operator liable to collect TCS.
- Turnover limit (section 10(1) and 10(2A))
- Aggregate turnover in preceding financial year ≤ ₹50 lakh
- The Government may notify a higher limit under section 10(1), but not above ₹1.5 crore.
- Maximum rate under section 10(1)
- Manufacturer: up to 1%; supplies under para 6(b) of Schedule II: up to 2.5%; other suppliers: up to 0.5% of turnover in State or Union territory
- These are caps in the Act. The actual rate is prescribed in the rules. Para 6(b) of Schedule II covers supply of food or drink as part of a service.
- Maximum rate under section 10(2A)
- Up to 3% of turnover in State or Union territory
- For a person not eligible under section 10(1) and (2), subject to its own conditions.
- Services allowance (second proviso to section 10(1))
- Services value ≤ higher of (10% of preceding-year turnover in the State or UT) or ₹5,00,000
- Covers services other than para 6(b) of Schedule II. Interest or discount on deposits, loans or advances is ignored in this test.
- Key bars under section 10(2)
- No services (save as allowed); no non-taxable supplies; no inter-State outward supplies; no supply through e-commerce operator liable for TCS under section 52; not a notified manufacturer; not a casual or non-resident taxable person
- Same PAN rule: all registered persons with the same PAN must opt together.
- Effect of composition (section 10(4))
- No tax collected from recipient; no input tax credit
- Option lapses from the day aggregate turnover exceeds the limit (section 10(3)).
- Charging rule for IGST
- IGST = Value of supply (Section 15 CGST Act) × IGST rate
- Applies to inter-State supplies. The IGST rate equals the CGST rate plus the SGST rate for the same item.
- Rate structure
- IGST rate = CGST rate + SGST rate (for example, 18% = 9% + 9%)
- Notified rate ceiling for IGST is 40%.
- IGST on imported goods
- Assessable value + basic customs duty (and other duties forming part of value) = Value for IGST; IGST = this value × IGST rate
- Levied as additional duty of customs on the goods. Take the exact build-up given in the question.
- Inter-State supply (goods or services)
- Location of supplier and place of supply are in different States or Union territories
- Imports and supplies to or from a SEZ developer or unit are also inter-State supplies.
- Exclusion and deferred levy
- Alcoholic liquor for human consumption is outside IGST (Section 5(1))
- Under Section 5(2), IGST on petroleum crude, high speed diesel, motor spirit, natural gas and aviation turbine fuel applies only from the date notified on the Council's recommendation.
Quick revision
- Supply is the taxable event; the first step is always to test whether a supply exists.
- Decide the supplier, recipient and place of supply before deciding the type of tax.
- Intra-State supply attracts CGST plus SGST or UTGST; inter-State supply attracts IGST.
- Under reverse charge the recipient pays tax, and the supplier does not charge it on that supply.
- Reverse charge applies only to notified goods, services or suppliers, or to specified cases in the Act.
- Electronic commerce operators have collection or payment duties only in the cases the law specifies.
- Composition is optional, subject to a turnover limit and conditions; a composition taxpayer cannot collect tax from customers.
- Check the exclusions and special treatment of alcohol for human consumption and petroleum products.
- Read the rate and conditions from the current notification or text, and do not rely on memory.
- In numericals, show the working: value, rate, CGST, SGST or IGST, and total tax.
- Always state the provision and then apply it to the facts in written answers.
Common mistakes
- Stating that the Act fixes GST rates at 5%, 12%, 18% and 28%. Fix: The Act sets only ceilings: 20% for CGST and 40% for IGST. Actual rates are notified by the Government on the Council's recommendations.
- Saying liquor for human consumption is taxed under GST. Fix: Section 9(1) and section 5(1) exclude alcoholic liquor for human consumption, and un-denatured extra neutral alcohol or rectified spirit used to make it.
- Saying every transaction without consideration is not a supply. Fix: Always check Schedule I. Section 7(1)(c) makes those activities supplies even without consideration.
- Applying the business condition to import of services. Fix: Remember that section 7(1)(b) covers import of services for consideration whether or not in the course or furtherance of business.
- Writing that the ceiling is 20% for both CGST and IGST. Fix: Remember 20% for CGST (Section 9) and 40% for IGST (Section 5).
- Saying alcohol is exempt from GST in every form. Fix: Say 'alcoholic liquor for human consumption'. Industrial alcohol is not covered by this exclusion, except the extra neutral alcohol or rectified spirit used for making liquor for human consumption.
- Assuming every purchase from an unregistered person attracts RCM. Fix: Section 9(4) works only for a notified class of registered persons and specified goods or services. Check all conditions.
- Charging GST on the supplier's invoice and also paying RCM. Fix: Under RCM the supplier does not charge tax. Only the recipient pays.
- Saying the operator pays tax on every supply made through it. Fix: Liability under 9(5) arises only for categories of services notified by the Government. Other supplies are taxed in the hands of the supplier.
- Confusing section 9(5) with reverse charge under section 9(3) or 9(4). Fix: Under reverse charge the recipient pays. Under 9(5) the operator pays. Check who is named in the section.
Exam tips
- Memorise both ceilings: 20% for CGST and 40% for IGST. MCQs often test them with distractors like 28% or 18%.
- Quote the section number with the rule. Writing 'section 9(1) CGST' or 'section 5(1) IGST' earns step marks.
- For theory, list the four elements: supply, value under section 15, notified rate, and person liable.
- Remember the exclusions: liquor for human consumption, and petroleum products until notified.
- In numerical questions, state first whether the supply is intra-State or inter-State, then compute.
- In MCQs, watch words like 'only', 'every' and 'all'. Section 7 has exceptions both ways, so such options are often wrong.
- In written answers, name the element of section 7(1) you are testing, then apply the facts. Step marks come from this structure.
- Always state the conclusion on Schedule III and Schedule I explicitly, even if the facts do not trigger them.