CS Professional · Goods and Services Tax (GST) and Corporate Tax Planning
Overview of Goods and Services Tax: formula sheet
Key formulas
- Intra-State supply
- GST = CGST + SGST (or UTGST)
- CGST and SGST/UTGST are usually charged at equal rates on the same value.
- Inter-State supply
- GST = IGST
- Levied by the Centre. The share belonging to the destination State is passed to it.
- Constitutional articles
- Art. 246A: power to levy GST; Art. 269A: inter-State supply; Art. 279A: GST Council
- Inserted by the Constitution (101st Amendment) Act, 2016.
- Value added approach
- Net GST payable = Output tax − Input tax credit
- This is how the multi-stage tax avoids cascading.
- Appellate body under the CGST Act
- National Appellate Authority for Advance Ruling: President + Technical Member (Centre) + Technical Member (State)
- Constituted under section 101A, inserted w.e.f. 1-1-2020. President holds office for 3 years or until age 70; Technical Members for 5 years or until age 65, whichever is earlier.
- Intra-State supply
- Tax = CGST + SGST (or UTGST)
- Both levied on the same value. Rates are notified on the Council's recommendation.
- Inter-State supply, import, export
- Tax = IGST
- Levied under the IGST Act. Place of supply decides the destination.
- Taxable event
- Supply of goods or services or both
- Section 7 of the CGST Act gives its scope. Section 9 is the charging section.
- Destination principle
- Tax accrues where consumption takes place
- Governed by place of supply rules in Chapter V of the IGST Act.
- Taxable supply
- Taxable supply = supply leviable to tax under the Act
- Section 2(108). Exempt and non-taxable supplies are outside this.
- Input tax
- Input tax = CGST, SGST, UTGST or IGST charged on supply to a registered person
- Section 2(62). It does not include tax paid under composition levy.
- Section 146: Common Portal
- Government notifies the portal on the Council's recommendation
- Functions: registration, payment of tax, returns, computation and settlement of integrated tax, electronic way bill, and other prescribed functions.
- Section 158A: Consent based sharing
- Data shared by the portal only with notified systems, on Council's recommendation, as prescribed, and with consent
- Covers registration and return particulars, invoice preparation and outward supply details, and documents generated under section 68, plus other prescribed details.
- Section 158A(2): Whose consent
- Supplier: for clauses (a), (b), (c). Recipient: for clause (b), and for clause (c) only where the details include the recipient's identity information
- Consent is given in the prescribed form and manner.
- Section 158A(3): Protection
- No action against Government or portal for liability from shared information; no impact on tax liability
- The tax on the supply or return stays as it was.
- Section 49: Ledgers
- Cash ledger, credit ledger, liability register
- Section 49(1) cash ledger, 49(2) credit ledger, 49(7) liability register.
- Section 49(8): Order of discharge
- (a) self-assessed tax and dues of earlier periods; (b) self-assessed tax and dues of the current period; (c) any other amount, including demands under section 73, 74 or 74A
- Follow this order when a question asks how dues are paid.
- Section 133: Disclosure
- Imprisonment up to six months or fine up to ₹25,000, or both
- Prosecution needs prior sanction: Government for a Government servant, Commissioner for others.
- Source of power (CGST)
- Section 11A, CGST Act, 2017
- Inserted by Act 15 of 2024, section 116, w.e.f. 1-11-2024. Covers central tax.
- Matching provision (IGST)
- Section 6A, IGST Act, 2017
- Same power for integrated tax. Inserted by Act 15 of 2024, section 152, w.e.f. 1-11-2024.
- Condition (a)
- A practice was, or is, generally prevalent regarding levy of tax (including non-levy)
- The practice must be general, not limited to one taxpayer.
- Condition (b)
- Supplies were, or are, liable to (i) tax, where the practice was non-levy, or (ii) a higher amount than what was levied under the practice
- The supplies must actually be taxable or taxable at more. The practice does not change the law.
- Procedure
- Government satisfied + Council recommendation + notification in the Official Gazette
- All three are needed before any relief arises.
- Extent of relief
- Non-levy: whole tax not payable. Short-levy: only the excess over the practice amount not payable
- Relief applies to the supplies covered by the notification and levied per the practice.
- Source of the rules
- Section 48(1): approval, eligibility, duties, obligations and removal = as prescribed
- The Act only creates the framework. The detail on eligibility and conduct is in the CGST Rules.
- Authorised functions
- Outward supplies (s.37) + returns (s.39, s.44, s.45) + other prescribed functions
- Section 48(2). Inward supply details under section 38 were omitted from this sub-section from 1 October 2022.
- Who authorises
- Registered person authorises an approved GSTP
- The practitioner acts only for persons who have authorised them. Without the authorisation, the practitioner cannot file for that taxpayer.
- Responsibility rule
- Responsibility for correctness = registered person, always
- Section 48(3), notwithstanding sub-section (2). Filing by a GSTP does not shift liability.
- Eligibility categories (in plain words)
- Indian citizen, sound mind, not insolvent, no serious conviction + one of the prescribed qualifications
- Qualifications include retired tax officer, long-standing sales tax practitioner, prescribed degree, or final examination passed of ICAI, ICSI or ICMAI. Check the exact wording in the Rules before the exam.
- Section 149(1): assignment of score
- Registered person → may be assigned a GST compliance rating score by the Government, based on his record of compliance with the Act
- The word is 'may'. It applies to a registered person, and the basis is compliance record.
- Section 149(2): parameters
- Score determined on such parameters as may be prescribed
- The Act does not list the parameters. Do not state a formula or weights.
- Section 149(3): updating and publication
- Score may be updated at periodic intervals + intimated to the registered person + placed in the public domain in the prescribed manner
- Remember three actions: update, intimate, publish.
Quick revision
- GST is levied on supply of goods or services or both, and the Acts are split into CGST, IGST, SGST and UTGST.
- Section 11A (CGST) and section 6A (IGST) were inserted by Act 15 of 2024 with effect from 1 November 2024.
- Section 11A applies where a practice was or is generally prevalent on levy of central tax, including non-levy.
- Relief under section 11A needs the Government's satisfaction, a Council recommendation and a notification in the Official Gazette.
- Section 6A is the same power for integrated tax.
- Section 48: a registered person may authorise an approved GST practitioner to furnish outward supplies details and returns.
- Under section 48(3), responsibility for correctness of particulars stays with the registered person.
- Section 116: a person may appear by an authorised representative, except when required to appear personally for examination on oath or affirmation.
- Authorised representatives include a relative or regular employee, an advocate, a CA, CMA or CS holding a certificate of practice, certain retired officers and an authorised GST practitioner.
- A retired commercial tax officer cannot appear for one year from retirement or resignation.
- Section 149: every registered person may be assigned a compliance rating score based on prescribed parameters, updated periodically and placed in the public domain as prescribed.
- Section 79 lists the modes of recovery of unpaid tax, such as deduction from money owed, detention and sale of goods, and recovery as arrears of land revenue.
Common mistakes
- Saying GST replaced all indirect taxes. Fix: Say it subsumed many Central and State taxes. Customs duty continues, and some goods such as alcohol for human consumption remain outside GST.
- Writing that the GST Council makes binding law. Fix: Say it makes recommendations. The law comes from Parliament and State Legislatures.
- Saying GST is levied on manufacture or sale. Fix: Write that the taxable event is supply, and cite section 7 for its scope.
- Treating the producing State as the one that gets the tax. Fix: State that GST is destination-based, and that the place of supply decides the destination.
- Treating GSTN and the common portal as the same thing. Fix: Say that the portal is the platform notified under Section 146, and GSTN is the company that provides the service, described in Section 150(1)(n).
- Stating ownership percentages of GSTN as law. Fix: The Act supplied does not state them. Mention only that GSTN is a company registered under the Companies Act, 2013.
- Treating section 11A as a right any taxpayer can claim after a short-levy. Fix: Write that it is a discretionary power of the Government exercised only by notification on the Council's recommendation.
- Confusing it with section 128, the power to waive penalty or late fee. Fix: Remember that section 11A concerns the tax itself. Section 128 concerns penalties under sections 122, 123 and 125 and late fee under section 47.
- Writing that the practitioner alone is liable for errors in a return they filed. Fix: Quote section 48(3): the responsibility for correctness continues to rest with the registered person. Any claim against the practitioner is a private matter.
- Saying a GST practitioner can act for any taxpayer once enrolled. Fix: Enrolment makes a person an approved practitioner. Each registered person must still authorise them before they can act for that person.
Exam tips
- Expect short notes and 'explain with reasons' questions. Give structure: background, constitutional basis, model, Council.
- Quote article numbers 246A, 269A and 279A correctly. Examiners reward precision.
- Use a small numerical illustration for CGST, SGST and IGST. It makes the dual model clear.
- When the CGST Act is cited, give the section only if sure. Section 101A deals with the National Appellate Authority for Advance Ruling.
- Link the topic to later chapters, such as supply, levy and input tax credit, to show depth.
- Begin every answer with the taxable event: supply, and quote section 7 and the section 2 definitions.
- List all five Acts when asked about structure, with one line on each.
- Use short case facts with named States, and always state intra-State or inter-State before naming the tax.