CS Professional · Insolvency and Bankruptcy - Law and Practice
Bankruptcy for Individuals and Partnership Firms: formula sheet
Key formulas
- Persons covered (section 2(e) to (g))
- Personal guarantors to corporate debtors + partnership and proprietorship firms + other individuals
- Clauses (e), (f) and (g) of section 2. Individuals in (g) exclude those in clause (e).
- Minimum default (section 78)
- Default ≥ ₹1,000; Central Government may notify a higher limit, not more than ₹1,00,000
- The ₹1 lakh is a ceiling on the notified minimum, not the default minimum.
- Adjudicating Authority (sections 79(1), 179(1))
- Debt Recovery Tribunal with territorial jurisdiction
- Place where the debtor actually and voluntarily resides, carries on business or personally works for gain.
- Immediate family (section 79(17))
- Spouse + dependent children + dependent parents
- Used in the definitions of associate and excluded assets.
- Qualifying debt (section 79(19))
- Liquidated sum due, excluding (a) excluded debt, (b) secured debt to the extent secured, (c) debt incurred within three months before the fresh start application
- The three-month exclusion applies to the fresh start process application.
- Excluded debt (section 79(15))
- Fines + damages for negligence, nuisance or breach + maintenance + student loan + any other prescribed debt
- Five heads including the prescribed residual.
- Bankruptcy commencement date (section 79(6))
- Date on which the bankruptcy order is passed under section 126
- Bankruptcy debt is measured as on this date.
- Bankruptcy debt (section 79(5))
- Debt owed on commencement date + later liability from earlier transactions before discharge + interest under section 171
- Three limbs.
- Forum for individuals and firms
- Individuals and firms (Part III) → DRT with territorial jurisdiction (s. 179(1))
- Subject to section 60.
- Territorial test for DRT
- Place where the individual debtor actually and voluntarily resides, or carries on business, or personally works for gain
- Any one of these places can found jurisdiction.
- Forum for personal guarantors to corporate debtors
- Personal guarantor → NCLT where the corporate person's registered office is located (s. 60(1))
- If the corporate debtor's CIRP or liquidation is pending before an NCLT, file before that NCLT (s. 60(2)).
- Transfer of pending guarantor processes
- Pending process in any court or tribunal → stands transferred to the Adjudicating Authority handling the corporate debtor (s. 60(3))
- Applies to corporate and personal guarantors.
- DRT scope
- Suits, claims, priorities, questions of law or fact arising out of the individual's or firm's insolvency (s. 179(2))
- Operates notwithstanding any other law.
- Limitation
- Moratorium period is excluded from limitation for suits or applications in the debtor's name (s. 179(3))
- Section 60(6) is the corporate counterpart, for suits by or against a corporate debtor.
- Minimum default for Part III
- Default ≥ ₹1,000 (s. 78)
- The Central Government may notify a higher minimum, not above ₹1 lakh.
- Code of conduct
- Section 208(2)(a) to (e)
- Care and diligence, agency bye-laws, inspection, submit records, perform functions as specified.
- Income limit (Section 80(2)(a))
- Gross annual income ≤ ₹60,000
- The limit is 'does not exceed'. Income of exactly ₹60,000 still qualifies.
- Asset limit (Section 80(2)(b))
- Aggregate value of assets ≤ ₹20,000
- Tested on the total value of all assets.
- Qualifying debt limit (Section 80(2)(c))
- Aggregate qualifying debts ≤ ₹35,000
- Applies to qualifying debts, not every liability.
- Status conditions (Section 80(2)(d)-(g))
- Not an undischarged bankrupt; owns no dwelling unit (even if encumbered); no fresh start, insolvency resolution or bankruptcy process subsisting; no fresh start order in the preceding 12 months
- All conditions must be met together with the three financial limits.
- Who may apply (Section 80(2))
- Debtor personally or through a resolution professional
- Application goes to the Adjudicating Authority.
- Interim moratorium (Section 81(1))
- Starts on date of filing; ceases on date of admission or rejection
- Pending proceedings are stayed and creditors cannot start new ones.
- Appointment of RP (Section 82)
- Application through RP: AA directs Board within 7 days to confirm no disciplinary proceedings. Application by debtor personally: AA directs Board within 7 days to nominate; Board nominates within 10 days
- The AA then appoints the RP by order.
- Moratorium after admission (Section 85)
- Commences on admission; ceases after 180 days from admission unless the admission order is revoked earlier under Section 91
- Covers all debts.
- Replacement of RP (Section 89)
- AA refers to Board within 7 days; Board recommends within 10 days
- Debtor or creditor may apply.
- Revocation (Section 91)
- RP applies; AA admits or rejects within 14 days
- On admitting the revocation application, the moratorium and the fresh start process cease.
- Applicability (section 78)
- Default ≥ ₹1,000 (Central Government may notify a higher minimum, not more than ₹1,00,000)
- Applies to individuals and partnership firms under Part III.
- Adjudicating Authority (section 179)
- Debt Recovery Tribunal with territorial jurisdiction
- Place where the debtor resides, carries on business or personally works for gain.
- Report of resolution professional (section 106(1))
- Within 21 days from the last date of submission of claims under section 102
- Plan under section 105 is submitted with the report to the Adjudicating Authority.
- Contents of the report (section 106(2))
- Plan complies with law; reasonable prospect of approval and implementation; need for a creditors' meeting
- If no meeting is recommended, reasons must be given.
- Date of creditors' meeting (section 106(4))
- Not less than 14 days and not more than 28 days from submission of the report
- Professional must consider convenience of creditors for date and venue.
- Approval of repayment plan (section 111)
- More than three-fourth in value of creditors present in person or by proxy and voting
- Counted on those present and voting, not all creditors. Applies to modifications too.
- Report of the meeting (section 112)
- Approved or rejected, modifications, resolutions and decisions, creditors present, voting records
- Prepared by the resolution professional.
- Supervision (section 116)
- Resolution professional supervises implementation; may apply to Adjudicating Authority for directions
- Authority may issue directions on that application.
- Completion (section 117)
- Notice and report within 14 days of completion; extension up to 7 days on application
- Sent to persons bound by the plan and the Adjudicating Authority. Report summarises receipts and payments and extent of implementation.
- Trustee proposed in application
- AA directs Board within 7 days → Board confirms or rejects and nominates within 10 days
- Section 125(1) and (2). The Board checks that no disciplinary proceedings are pending against the proposed professional.
- No trustee proposed
- AA directs Board within 7 days → Board nominates within 10 days
- Section 125(3) and (4).
- Appointment
- Trustee confirmed or nominated is appointed by the AA in the bankruptcy order under section 126
- Section 125(5).
- Administration
- Trustee administers and distributes the estate in accordance with Chapter V
- Section 136.
- Resignation grounds
- Intends to cease practising as IP, or conflict of interest or change of personal circumstances
- Section 146(1). These are the only two grounds listed.
- Replacement after resignation
- AA directs Board within 7 days of accepting resignation → Board recommends within 10 days → AA appoints within 14 days
- Section 146(2) to (4). New trustee gives notice of appointment to the committee of creditors and the bankrupt within 7 days (section 146(7)).
- Release of trustee
- Replacement: from date of AA order appointing the new trustee. Completion: from date the committee of creditors approves the report under section 137
- Section 148(1) and (3). A released trustee must still share information and cooperate (section 148(2)).
- Vesting of estate
- Estate vests in bankruptcy trustee from date of appointment, without conveyance, assignment or transfer
- Section 154. Section 128(1)(a) links it to the bankruptcy order under section 126.
- Effect on creditors
- No action against property and no suit or proceeding, except with leave of the Adjudicating Authority
- Section 128(1)(c). Applies to a creditor claiming a bankruptcy debt. Secured creditors are dealt with in section 128(2).
- Secured creditor's 30-day rule
- No action to realise security within 30 days of bankruptcy commencement date ⇒ no interest after that date
- Proviso to section 128(2). The security itself is not lost.
- Undervalued transaction: look-back
- Two years ending on the filing of the application for bankruptcy, and it caused the bankruptcy process to be triggered
- Section 164(2). Transaction with an associate in the two years before the application is deemed undervalued (section 164(3)).
- What is undervalued
- Gift; no consideration received; consideration of marriage; or consideration significantly less in value than that provided by the bankrupt
- Section 164(6).
- Orders on undervalued transaction
- Declare void; vest property in trustee; any other order to restore the position
- Section 164(4). Ordinary-course defence under section 164(5) is open to the bankrupt but not for associate transactions.
- Extortionate credit transaction
- Credit on exorbitant terms or unconscionable under contract law; entered in two years ending on bankruptcy commencement date
- Section 167(2) and (5). Debt by a regulated financial service provider in compliance with law is excluded (section 167(6)).
- Completion
- Trustee convenes committee of creditors, gives report; committee approves within 7 days and decides on release under section 148
- Section 137.
- When trustee applies for discharge (s.138(1))
- Apply on expiry of 1 year from bankruptcy commencement date, OR within 7 days of committee of creditors approving completion of administration under s.137, if that approval comes earlier
- Two triggers. The second applies only where approval is obtained before the one-year period ends.
- Duty of the Adjudicating Authority (s.138(2))
- Adjudicating Authority shall pass a discharge order on the trustee's application
- The wording is mandatory. A copy goes to the Board for the register under section 196.
- Effect of discharge (s.139)
- Release from all bankruptcy debt, except: trustee's functions, Chapters IV and V of Part III, fraud or breach of trust debts, excluded debts
- Learn the four exceptions as a list.
- Excluded debts (s.79(15))
- Court or tribunal fines; damages for negligence, nuisance or breach of legal obligation; maintenance; student loan; other prescribed debt
- These survive discharge.
- Fresh start discharge (s.92)
- Final list of qualifying debts to Adjudicating Authority at least 7 days before the moratorium ends; discharge order at end of moratorium
- Also discharges penalties, interest and other contractual sums on qualifying debts from the application date to the order date. It does not discharge other persons (s.92(6)).
- Bankrupt's notice duty (s.150)
- Notify trustee within 7 days of acquiring or inheriting property or an increase in income
- Duties other than this notice continue after discharge.
- Ending of restrictions (ss.140(3), 141(2))
- Disqualifications and restrictions cease if the bankruptcy order is modified or recalled under s.142, or on discharge under s.138
- Both routes end them.
Quick revision
- Part III applies to individuals and partnership firms where default is at least ₹1,000; a notified higher minimum cannot exceed ₹1 lakh (section 78).
- The Adjudicating Authority is the Debt Recovery Tribunal with territorial jurisdiction (section 179 and section 79(1)).
- The DRT can decide suits, claims and questions of priority or law and fact related to the debtor's insolvency (section 179(2)).
- Moratorium time is excluded when computing limitation for suits by the debtor (section 179(3)).
- Immediate family means spouse, dependent children and dependent parents.
- Qualifying debt excludes excluded debt, the secured portion of a debt, and debt incurred within three months before the fresh start application.
- Fresh start limits: income ₹60,000, assets ₹20,000, qualifying debts ₹35,000; debtor must not own a dwelling unit, secured or not.
- A fresh start applicant must not have had a fresh start order in the preceding twelve months.
- For resolution, a firm's partners must apply jointly: all or a majority of them (section 94(2)).
- An undischarged bankrupt, or a debtor in fresh start, resolution or bankruptcy, cannot apply for resolution (section 94(4)).
- The DRT has fourteen days from the resolution professional's report to admit or reject a fresh start application, and creditors get a copy of the order within seven days (section 84).
- The bankruptcy trustee administers and distributes the estate under Chapter V (section 136).
Common mistakes
- Saying that the NCLT is the Adjudicating Authority for individuals and firms. Fix: For Part III, the DRT is the Adjudicating Authority under sections 79(1) and 179(1). The NCLT is for corporate persons.
- Stating that the minimum default is ₹1 lakh. Fix: The minimum is ₹1,000. ₹1 lakh is the highest figure the Central Government may notify as the minimum.
- Saying the DRT hears every individual case, including personal guarantors to corporate debtors. Fix: Always test for personal guarantor status first. Such guarantors go to the NCLT.
- Choosing the DRT by the creditor's location. Fix: Use the debtor's residence, place of business or place of working for gain.
- Treating the limits as 'less than' rather than 'not exceeding'. Fix: The Code says the figure 'does not exceed' the limit. A figure equal to the limit still qualifies.
- Ignoring the dwelling unit condition. Fix: Section 80(2)(e) bars a debtor who owns a dwelling unit, whether encumbered or not. A mortgaged house does not help.
- Treating the majority as three-fourth of all creditors. Fix: Write: more than three-fourth in value of creditors present in person or by proxy and voting.
- Saying three-fourth or at least 75%. Fix: Section 111 says more than three-fourth, so exactly 75% does not pass.
- Mixing up who nominates the trustee and who appoints. Fix: The Board confirms, rejects or nominates. The Adjudicating Authority appoints, in the bankruptcy order.
- Swapping the 7-day and 10-day periods, or applying them to every step. Fix: In section 125 and in section 146(2) and (3), the Adjudicating Authority's direction is 7 days and the Board's response is 10 days. After a resignation, the Adjudicating Authority's appointment of the recommended trustee takes up to 14 days (section 146(4)). The 7-day notice in section 146(7) is given by the newly appointed trustee, not by the Adjudicating Authority.
Exam tips
- Open your answer with the section 2 clause that brings the debtor within the Code. It earns marks quickly.
- Quote section 79 definitions in the Code's own words, such as immediate family, qualifying debt and excluded debt. Examiners look for exact terms.
- In case questions, write in this order: provision, application to the facts, conclusion.
- Write the ₹1,000 and ₹1 lakh figures carefully and say which is the minimum and which is the ceiling.
- Do not quote notification dates or section numbers you are unsure of. State the rule in plain words.
- Open every forum answer by classifying the debtor. The marks lie in noticing the personal guarantor exception.
- Quote 'subject to section 60' when citing section 179(1).
- In long case questions, tie the professional's role to the process and cite section 208(2) conduct duties.