CS Professional · Insolvency and Bankruptcy - Law and Practice
Bankruptcy Order for Individuals and Partnership Firms: formula sheet
Key formulas
- Adjudicating Authority for individuals and firms
- Section 179(1): DRT with territorial jurisdiction (subject to Section 60)
- Territory is the place where the debtor actually and voluntarily resides, carries on business or personally works for gain. For corporate persons the forum is the NCLT.
- Scope of DRT jurisdiction
- Section 179(2): suits/proceedings, claims, and questions of priorities, law or fact, by or against the debtor
- Applies notwithstanding any other law for the time being in force.
- Limitation during moratorium
- Section 179(3): moratorium period is excluded in computing limitation
- Only for suits or applications in the name and on behalf of the debtor, where a moratorium has been ordered under Part III.
- Processes an insolvency professional handles
- Section 208(1): fresh start, individual insolvency resolution, corporate insolvency resolution, pre-packaged resolution, individual bankruptcy, liquidation of a corporate debtor firm
- For this chapter, focus on the three Part III processes: fresh start, insolvency resolution and bankruptcy.
- Code of conduct of an insolvency professional
- Section 208(2)(a)-(e)
- Reasonable care and diligence; comply with IPA bye-laws; allow IPA inspection of records; submit copies of records of every proceeding before the Adjudicating Authority to the Board and the IPA; perform functions as specified.
- Triggers for a bankruptcy application
- Section 121(1): order under s.100(4) OR s.115(2) OR s.118(3)
- The applicant may be a creditor (alone or jointly) or the debtor. The application goes to the Adjudicating Authority.
- Time limit
- Filing period = 3 months from the date of the order (Section 121(2))
- Counted from the date of the Adjudicating Authority's order under the sections in s.121(1).
- Firm as debtor
- Any partner may file (Section 121(3))
- Contrast with Section 94(2), where a partner applying for resolution process needs all or a majority of partners to file jointly.
- Documents with debtor's application
- Section 122(1): (a) records of IRP + (b) statement of affairs on the date of application + (c) copy of order permitting debtor to apply
- Form, manner and fee are prescribed (s.122(3)).
- Proposal of trustee
- Debtor may propose an insolvency professional as bankruptcy trustee (Section 122(2))
- It is a proposal. The trustee is appointed under Section 125.
- Withdrawal
- No withdrawal without leave of the Adjudicating Authority (Section 122(4))
- Applies to the debtor's application.
- Interim moratorium
- Starts on the date of making the application; ceases on the bankruptcy commencement date (Section 124(1))
- Pending actions against the debtor's property for his debts are deemed stayed; creditors cannot start new ones. For a firm, it operates against all partners as on the date of application (s.124(2)).
- Who may apply (s.121(1))
- Creditor (alone or jointly) or debtor → Adjudicating Authority, after an order under s.100(4), s.115(2) or s.118(3)
- Without one of these orders, a bankruptcy application is not maintainable.
- Time limit (s.121(2))
- Filing deadline = date of the order + 3 months
- Counted from the date of the order, not from the date you receive it.
- Firm as debtor (s.121(3))
- Application may be filed by any of its partners
- One partner is enough.
- Demand notice (s.95(4)(b))
- Debtor fails to pay within 14 days of service of the notice of demand
- Part of the section 95 application. Do not confuse it with the 10 days in sections 8 and 9, which apply to corporate debtors.
- Contents of creditor's application (s.123(1))
- (a) records of the resolution process + (b) copy of order permitting creditor to apply + (c) debt details as on date + (d) other prescribed information
- The creditor may propose an insolvency professional as bankruptcy trustee (s.123(4)).
- Secured creditor (s.123(2)-(3))
- Either give up security for all creditors, or apply only for the unsecured part with its estimated value
- Under the second option, the secured and unsecured parts are treated as separate debts.
- Deceased debtor and withdrawal
- s.123(5): file against legal representatives; s.123(7): no withdrawal without permission
- Section 169 separately says proceedings against a bankrupt who dies continue as if he were alive.
- Interim moratorium period (s. 96)
- Starts: date of application under s. 94 or 95 | Ends: date of admission of the application
- Covers all debts. Pending proceedings are deemed stayed and creditors cannot initiate new ones. For a firm, it operates against all partners as on the date of application.
- Trustee confirmation timeline, proposed professional (s. 125(1)-(2))
- Direction to Board: within 7 days of application | Board confirms or rejects and nominates: within 10 days of direction
- The Board confirms that no disciplinary proceedings are pending against the proposed professional.
- Trustee nomination timeline, none proposed (s. 125(3)-(4))
- Direction to Board: within 7 days of application | Board nominates: within 10 days of direction
- The confirmed or nominated trustee is appointed in the bankruptcy order.
- Bankruptcy order timeline (s. 126)
- Order: within 14 days of confirmation or nomination of trustee | Documents to bankrupt, creditors, trustee: within 7 days of order
- Documents are a copy of the application and a copy of the order.
- Validity (s. 127)
- Order continues until the debtor is discharged under s. 138
- No fixed end date.
- Effects of order (s. 128)
- Estate vests in trustee (s. 154) + divided among creditors + creditors barred from actions against property and from suits without leave
- Secured creditors keep their right to realise security, but lose interest after the bankruptcy commencement date if they do not act within 30 days of that date.
- Firm bankruptcy (s. 128(3))
- Order against firm = order against each individual who is a partner on the date of the order
- Test partner status on the date of the order.
- Effect on creditors (s.128(1))
- Bankruptcy order → estate vests in trustee + estate divided among creditors + no action against property / no suit without leave of Adjudicating Authority
- The bar applies to creditors owed a bankruptcy debt.
- Secured creditor rule (s.128(2))
- Security can be realised as before; no interest after commencement date if no action within 30 days
- Subject to section 123. The 30 days run from the bankruptcy commencement date.
- Firm's bankruptcy (s.128(3))
- Order against firm = order against each partner on the date of the order
- Applies to individuals who are partners on that date.
- Vesting (s.154)
- Estate vests in trustee from date of appointment, without conveyance, assignment or transfer
- Vesting is automatic.
- Creditor list (s.132)
- List within 14 days from bankruptcy commencement date
- Based on the application, statement of affairs and claims received under section 130(2).
- Bankrupt's notice duty (s.150)
- Notice within 7 days of acquisition or devolution of property, or increase in income
- The other duties continue after discharge, but not this notice duty.
- Completion (s.137)
- Committee of creditors approves trustee's report within 7 days of receipt
- It also decides whether the trustee should be released under section 148.
- Surplus (s.176(5))
- Surplus after full payment with interest and expenses → bankrupt
- For a deceased bankrupt, surplus goes to legal representatives (s.170(4)).
- Discharge application timing (section 138(1))
- Trustee applies: (a) on expiry of 1 year from bankruptcy commencement date; or (b) within 7 days of committee of creditors' approval of completion of administration under section 137, if approval comes before 1 year
- The applicant is the bankruptcy trustee. Do not say the bankrupt applies.
- Duty of the Adjudicating Authority (section 138(2))
- On the trustee's application, the Adjudicating Authority shall pass a discharge order
- The wording is mandatory ('shall').
- Copy of order (section 138(3))
- Copy of discharge order → the Board → entry in the register under section 196
- Same record-keeping step appears in other orders under this Part.
- Effect of discharge (section 139)
- Release from all bankruptcy debt, except: fraud or breach of trust debt; excluded debt; and discharge does not affect trustee's functions or Chapters IV and V
- Learn the four carve-outs in the proviso.
- Excluded debt (section 79(15))
- Court or tribunal fines; damages for negligence, nuisance or breach of legal obligation; maintenance; student loan; any other prescribed debt
- These survive discharge.
- Restrictions on bankrupt (section 141(1))
- No directorship or role in promotion, formation or management of a company; no charge on estate or fresh debt without trustee's sanction; inform business partners; inform parties to prescribed-value transactions; no legal action on bankruptcy debts without Adjudicating Authority's sanction; no overseas travel without its permission
- Restrictions cease on recall or modification under section 142, or on discharge.
- Bankruptcy debt (section 79(5))
- Debt owed on the commencement date + debt arising later but before discharge from pre-commencement transactions + interest forming part of the debt under section 171
- This is what discharge releases.
Quick revision
- The Code applies to personal guarantors to corporate debtors, partnership and proprietorship firms, and other individuals (section 2).
- Part III applies where default is at least ₹1,000; the Central Government may notify a higher minimum, not above ₹1 lakh (section 78).
- The Adjudicating Authority for individuals and firms is the Debt Recovery Tribunal with territorial jurisdiction (section 179).
- The bankruptcy commencement date is the date the bankruptcy order is passed.
- On a bankruptcy order, the estate vests in the bankruptcy trustee and is divided among creditors (section 128).
- After the order, a creditor cannot act against the bankrupt's property or start proceedings without the Adjudicating Authority's leave.
- A secured creditor may still realise its security; it loses post-commencement interest if it takes no action within thirty days of the commencement date.
- A bankruptcy order against a firm operates as an order against each partner on the date of the order.
- Excluded assets include necessary tools and household items, a single dwelling unit of prescribed value, and unencumbered life insurance or pension plans.
- The trustee applies for discharge after one year from commencement, or within seven days of creditors' approval of completed administration if that comes earlier (section 138).
- The Adjudicating Authority passes the discharge order on the trustee's application; a copy goes to the Board for the register.
- The estate of a deceased bankrupt is administered under the same rules; funeral and testamentary expenses rank equally with secured creditors, and any surplus goes to legal representatives (section 170).
Common mistakes
- Naming the NCLT as the Adjudicating Authority for an individual or partnership firm. Fix: Check the debtor first. Under Section 179(1), individuals and firms go to the DRT. Corporate persons go to the NCLT.
- Ignoring territorial jurisdiction and saying any DRT can hear the case. Fix: Quote the test: the DRT with jurisdiction over the place where the debtor actually and voluntarily resides, carries on business or personally works for gain.
- Saying a debtor can apply for bankruptcy directly without any earlier process. Fix: Always cite the Section 121(1) triggers. The application follows an order in the insolvency resolution process.
- Counting the three months from the date of default or the date of the IRP application. Fix: Section 121(2) counts from the date of the Adjudicating Authority's order under the sections in Section 121(1).
- Citing section 169 as the statutory demand notice provision. Fix: Section 169 is about continuance of proceedings on the death of a bankrupt. The fourteen-day demand notice appears in section 95(4)(b).
- Using the ten-day notice period of sections 8 and 9 for individuals. Fix: Sections 8 and 9 concern operational creditors and corporate debtors. For section 95, the period is fourteen days from service of the demand notice.
- Saying the interim moratorium starts on admission of the application. Fix: Remember section 96: it starts on the date of the application and ceases on the date of admission.
- Saying the Adjudicating Authority for individuals and firms is the NCLT. Fix: Under section 179, it is the DRT with territorial jurisdiction over the place where the debtor resides, carries on business or works for gain.
- Saying secured creditors are also barred from enforcing security. Fix: Always add section 128(2): they may realise security as before, subject to section 123.
- Forgetting the 30-day condition. Fix: State that interest stops after the commencement date if no action to realise security is taken within thirty days.
Exam tips
- Write the forum in your first line: DRT for individuals and firms, NCLT for corporate persons. Examiners often test this contrast.
- Always add the territorial jurisdiction test from Section 179(1) when asked which DRT applies.
- Use the provision, analysis, conclusion format. Quote the section number with each point.
- When the facts mention a suit, claim or priority dispute, cite Section 179(2). When they mention a moratorium and time-barred claims, cite Section 179(3).
- For a question on insolvency professionals, list the Section 208(2) code of conduct points in order.
- Begin every answer with the Section 121(1) trigger. Examiners reward the link to the earlier order.
- Write the three-month limit and say it runs from the order. Many students lose the mark by omitting the starting point.
- List the three Section 122(1) documents as a numbered list. It is easy marks.