CS Professional · Intellectual Property Rights - Law and Practice
Biological Diversity: formula sheet
Key formulas
- Aims of the Act (CBD-based)
- Conservation + Sustainable use + Fair and equitable benefit sharing
- The three objectives of the CBD, which the Act implements in India.
- Access (Section 2(a))
- Collecting, procuring or possessing a biological resource from India or associated traditional knowledge, for research, bio-survey or commercial utilisation
- Purpose matters. Access for none of these purposes is not 'access' under the Act.
- Biological resources (Section 2(c))
- Plants, animals, micro-organisms or parts of their genetic material and derivatives, with actual or potential use or value for humanity; excludes value added products and human genetic material
- Two exclusions to remember.
- Value added products (Section 2(p))
- Products containing portions or extracts of plants and animals in unrecognisable and physically inseparable form
- Outside the meaning of biological resources.
- Commercial utilisation (Section 2(f))
- End uses such as drugs, industrial enzymes, food flavours, fragrance, cosmetics, emulsifiers, oleoresins, colours, extracts and genes for improving crops and livestock through genetic intervention; excludes conventional breeding and traditional practices in agriculture, horticulture, poultry, dairy farming, animal husbandry, bee keeping
- The list is illustrative ('such as'). The exclusion is specific.
- Bio-survey and bio-utilisation (Section 2(d))
- Survey or collection of species, subspecies, genes, components and extracts of a biological resource for any purpose, including characterisation, inventorisation and bioassay
- Note the words 'for any purpose'.
- Benefit claimers (Section 2(aa))
- Conservers of biological resources and their by-products, and creators or holders of associated traditional knowledge (excluding codified traditional knowledge only for Indians), and information on their use
- They are the people for whom benefit sharing is meant.
- Codified traditional knowledge (Section 2(ea))
- Knowledge derived from authoritative books specified in the First Schedule to the Drugs and Cosmetics Act, 1940
- Used in exemptions and in the benefit claimers definition.
- Benefit sharing modes (Section 21(2))
- Joint IPR ownership; transfer of technology; location of units; association of Indian scientists and local people; venture capital fund; monetary and non-monetary benefits
- The NBA determines them subject to regulations.
- Establishment and status (section 8)
- NBA = body corporate + perpetual succession + common seal; head office at Chennai
- Established by the Central Government by notification. Other offices need the Central Government's previous approval.
- Composition (section 8(4))
- 1 Chairperson + 16 ex officio + 4 State Board representatives + 5 non-official + 1 Member-Secretary
- The four State Board members serve on a rotational basis. The 16 ex officio members represent Ministries named in the Act.
- Regulatory duty (section 18(1) and (2))
- Make regulations (with Central Government approval) on access and benefit sharing; grant or reject approvals under sections 3, 4 and 6
- Section 3 covers certain persons and entities seeking access, section 4 covers transfer of research results, and section 6 covers applying for intellectual property rights. Know the section numbers only as the NBA's approval areas.
- Advisory powers (section 18(3))
- Advise the Central Government, advise State Governments on heritage sites, advise State Boards, and perform other necessary functions
- These are discretionary ('may'), unlike the regulatory duty, which is stated as a duty ('shall').
- Opposing foreign IP (section 18(4))
- NBA may, on behalf of the Central Government, take measures to oppose IP grants outside India on Indian biological resources or associated traditional knowledge
- It covers resources found in or brought from India, including those deposited in repositories outside India.
- Fund (section 27)
- Charges and benefit sharing amounts received by NBA go into the National Biodiversity Fund
- The Fund is used for channeling benefits to claimers, conservation, socio-economic development of source areas, and the Act's purposes.
- Duty to constitute a BMC (s.41(1))
- Gram Panchayat (rural) / Nagar Panchayat or Municipal Committee at Municipal Corporation level (urban) → must constitute a BMC
- The word is 'shall'. The State Government may also constitute BMCs at the intermediate or district Panchayat level.
- Size of a BMC (s.41(1B))
- 7 ≤ number of members ≤ 11
- Composition is prescribed by the State Government.
- Functions of a BMC (s.41(1A))
- Conservation + sustainable use + documentation of biological diversity, including chronicling of associated traditional knowledge
- Covers habitats, landraces, folk varieties, cultivars, domesticated breeds and microorganisms.
- Consultation duty (s.41(2))
- NBA / SBB must consult the BMC before any decision on use of biological resources or associated traditional knowledge in its area
- The duty falls on the NBA and SBB, not on the applicant.
- Collection fees (s.41(3))
- BMC may levy fees on persons accessing or collecting biological resources for commercial purposes from its area
- These fees are credited to the Local Biodiversity Fund under s.43(1)(d).
- Prior intimation to SBB (s.7)
- Commercial utilisation of a biological resource and associated knowledge → prior intimation to the concerned SBB
- Exempt: codified traditional knowledge, cultivated medicinal plants and products, local people and communities including growers and cultivators, and vaids, hakims and registered AYUSH practitioners practising for sustenance and livelihood.
- Cultivated medicinal plants (s.7(2)-(3))
- Exemption available only if a certificate of origin is obtained from the BMC
- The BMC issues it on the basis of entries in its books, in the prescribed manner.
- BMC accounts (s.46)
- Maintain accounts → audit as prescribed by State Government → send audited accounts and auditor's report to the local body and the SBB
- The due date is prescribed by the State Government.
- Section 19(1): access approval
- Section 3(2) person + access for research / commercial use / bio-survey and bio-utilisation / transfer of results → apply to NBA
- NBA may approve with terms (including royalty) or reject for recorded reasons, after a hearing. Under the proviso to section 19(3A) it may also prohibit or restrict a detrimental activity, for recorded reasons and after a hearing.
- Section 4: transfer of research results
- Transfer of results to section 3(2) persons → previous NBA approval
- Publication of papers or sharing at seminars or workshops is not a transfer if it follows Central Government guidelines.
- Section 20: transfer application
- Application to NBA in prescribed form and fee; NBA grants (with benefit sharing) or rejects; details placed in public domain
- Covers results on resources found in or brought from India, including those in repositories abroad, and associated traditional knowledge.
- Section 6(1): IPR by section 3(2) persons
- Prior NBA approval before grant of IPR
- Applies to IPR in or outside India for inventions based on research or information on resources accessed from India or associated traditional knowledge.
- Section 6(1A) and (1B): IPR by section 7 persons
- Section 7 person + IPR for an invention based on research or information on a biological resource accessed from India (including repositories abroad) or associated traditional knowledge → register with NBA before grant; prior NBA approval at commercialisation
- The duty depends on the invention being based on such a resource or knowledge. It is not a general duty of every Indian company. Do not mix it with the prior approval required of section 3(2) persons.
- Section 7: prior intimation
- Non-section 3(2) person + commercial utilisation → prior intimation to State Biodiversity Board
- Subject to listed exemptions; cultivated medicinal plants need a BMC certificate of origin.
- Section 21(2): modes of benefit sharing
- Joint IPR ownership; technology transfer; location of units; scientist and community involvement; venture capital fund; monetary and non-monetary benefits
- Money may go to the National Biodiversity Fund, or directly to a benefit claimer where access came from an identified individual, group or organisation.
- Section 6(3): plant variety exclusion
- Section 6 does not apply to applications under plant variety protection law
- The authority granting such a right endorses a copy to the NBA.
- Benefit sharing duty (Section 21(1))
- Approval terms must secure fair and equitable sharing, on mutually agreed terms between applicant and BMC (represented by NBA)
- Benefits arise from accessed resources, derivatives, innovations, practices and related knowledge.
- Modes of benefit sharing (Section 21(2))
- Joint IPR ownership | technology transfer | location of R&D units | association of scientists and local people | venture capital fund | monetary and non-monetary benefits
- Applies subject to regulations. The Act uses 'all or any' of these, so the NBA can choose one or more.
- Deposit of money (Section 21(3))
- Money ordered → National Biodiversity Fund; direct payment to benefit claimer allowed under the proviso
- Direct payment applies where the resource or knowledge was accessed from an individual, group or organisation.
- IPR rule (Section 6(1))
- Section 3(2) person applying for IPR → prior NBA approval before grant
- Covers IPR in or outside India, and resources in overseas repositories.
- Section 7 persons (Sections 6(1A), 6(1B))
- Register before grant of IPR; prior approval at commercialisation if IPR already obtained
- Section 19(2A) repeats this.
- Fee or royalty (Section 6(2))
- NBA may impose benefit sharing fee, royalty or both, or conditions
- Sharing of financial benefits from commercial use of the rights.
- Plant variety exception (Section 6(3), 6(4))
- Section 6 not applicable to plant variety protection applications; granting authority endorses a copy to NBA
- Do not state it as a complete exemption from the Act.
- Section 36B(1) duty
- State Government SHALL develop strategies, plans and programmes, in conformity with national ones
- Mandatory duty. Covers identification and monitoring of rich areas, in situ and ex situ conservation, incentives for research, training and public education.
- Section 36B(2) integration
- State Government shall, as far as practicable and wherever it deems appropriate, integrate conservation into sectoral or cross-sectoral policies, plans and programmes
- Qualified duty. Do not state it as absolute.
- Section 37 heritage sites
- State Board recommends (after consulting local body and BMC) → State Government notifies in Official Gazette
- The State Government has the power to notify; the Board only recommends. The State must frame compensation or rehabilitation schemes for affected people.
- Section 38 threatened species
- Central Government, in consultation with State Government, notifies species on verge of extinction or likely to become extinct in near future
- Can prohibit or regulate collection and take rehabilitation and preservation steps. If delegated to a State, the State consults the NBA first.
- In situ vs ex situ (section 36 Explanation)
- In situ = in natural surroundings; ex situ = outside natural habitats
- For domesticated or cultivated species, in situ means the surroundings where they developed their distinctive properties.
- Penalty under section 55
- ₹1,00,000 ≤ penalty ≤ ₹50,00,000; if damage > penalty, penalty = commensurate with damage
- Applies to contravention, attempt or abetment of section 3, 4, 6 or 7. Continuing failure: additional penalty up to ₹1 crore.
- Adjudicating officer (section 55A)
- Rank ≥ Joint Secretary (Government of India) or Secretary (State Government); appointed by Central Government
- Must hold an inquiry and give an opportunity of being heard before imposing penalty.
- Appeal against adjudicating officer's order
- Appeal to NGT within 60 days of receiving the copy of the order
- Section 55A(3) and (4). NGT may confirm, modify or set aside the order.
- Residual fine (section 56)
- First: up to ₹1 lakh; repeat: up to ₹2 lakh; continuing: further up to ₹2 lakh per day
- Only where no punishment is separately provided under the Act.
- Offences by companies (section 57)
- Company + persons in charge and responsible = deemed guilty, unless no knowledge or all due diligence
- Directors, managers, secretaries and officers are liable on consent, connivance or neglect. Company includes a firm or association of individuals.
- Appeal against NBA/SBB determination or order
- Section 52A: appeal to NGT, in accordance with the NGT Act, 2010
- Section 52 (High Court, 30 days) does not apply after the NGT Act, 2010 commenced, except for pending appeals.
- Execution (section 53)
- Determination or order, or High Court or NGT order in appeal = deemed decree of civil court on a certificate
- Certificate is issued by an officer of the NBA or SBB, or the Registrar of the High Court or NGT.
- Local Biodiversity Fund (section 42)
- State Government grants or loans after due appropriation by State Legislature
- Used for the purposes of the Act.
Quick revision
- The Act is the Biological Diversity Act, 2002, amended by Act 10 of 2023 with effect from 1 April 2024.
- Section 18: the NBA makes regulations, with Central Government approval, on access and benefit sharing.
- The NBA regulates activities under sections 3, 4 and 6 by granting or rejecting approvals.
- Section 18(4): the NBA may act for the Central Government to oppose IPR grants abroad on Indian biological resources or associated knowledge.
- Section 6(1): persons under section 3(2) need prior NBA approval before an IPR is granted.
- Section 6(1A) and (1B): persons under section 7 register before grant and obtain prior approval at commercialisation.
- Section 6(2): the NBA may impose a benefit sharing fee, royalty or both, or other conditions.
- Section 6(3): section 6 does not apply to applications under plant variety protection law.
- Section 21: benefit sharing is on mutually agreed terms, and money may go to the National Biodiversity Fund or directly to benefit claimers.
- Section 36: the Centre develops national strategies in consultation with States and Union territories.
- Section 36B: the State Government develops strategies and plans in conformity with national ones.
- In situ means conservation in natural habitats; ex situ means outside them.
Common mistakes
- Treating value added products as biological resources. Fix: Remember the exclusion: extracts in unrecognisable and physically inseparable form are outside Section 2(c).
- Saying human genetic material is covered. Fix: State that biological resources do not include human genetic material.
- Writing that the head office of the NBA is at Delhi or in the Ministry's city. Fix: Remember that section 8(3) fixes the head office at Chennai. Other offices need Central Government approval.
- Mixing up the NBA with the State Biodiversity Board. Fix: The NBA regulates activities under sections 3, 4 and 6. The State Board regulates activities under section 7 (section 23). Say which body fits the facts.
- Saying a BMC is constituted by the State Government or the SBB in every case. Fix: Under s.41(1) the local body constitutes it. The State Government may additionally constitute BMCs at intermediate or district Panchayat level.
- Giving the wrong membership range, such as 5 to 11 or 'at least 7 with no upper limit'. Fix: Remember 'not less than seven and not exceeding eleven'. The composition itself is prescribed by the State Government.
- Saying every user needs NBA approval. Fix: Only section 3(2) persons need NBA approval for access. Other persons give prior intimation to the State Biodiversity Board for commercial use.
- Treating all IPR applicants alike, or saying every Indian company must register with the NBA. Fix: Section 3(2) persons: prior approval before grant. Section 7 persons: registration before grant and approval at commercialisation, but only where the invention is based on research or information on a biological resource accessed from India, or associated traditional knowledge.
- Saying NBA approval is needed after the IPR is granted Fix: For Section 3(2) persons, approval is before grant. Approval at commercialisation applies to Section 7 persons who already hold the IPR.
- Treating benefit sharing as only a money payment Fix: List all Section 21(2) modes, including joint IPR ownership, technology transfer, scientist association and venture capital fund.
Exam tips
- Write the CBD background in two lines and then the three objectives; examiners reward the link to the Act.
- Learn definitions with their exclusions; case questions are built on them.
- Do not quote section numbers unless certain; Sections 1, 2, 3, 6, 7 and 21 are safe from the text.
- Close fact-based answers with a practical step: seek NBA approval or give prior intimation to the State Board.
- Use short bullet lists for benefit sharing modes under Section 21(2).
- Write the section number next to each point. Sections 8 and 18 carry most of the marks for this topic.
- Use a short list for composition and a short paragraph for functions. Examiners look for completeness.
- In case-based questions, name the correct body first (NBA or State Board), then apply the provision and conclude.