FRM Part II · FRM Exam Part II
The Rise and Risks of Private Credit: formula sheet
Key formulas
- Strategy risk ladder (senior to junior)
- Direct lending (senior) → Mezzanine (junior debt) → Distressed / Special situations (event or recovery driven)
- Higher position in the loss queue means lower expected loss and lower expected return. Mezzanine ranks below senior debt and above equity.
- Growth drivers
- Growth = Bank retrenchment (supply gap) + Borrower and sponsor demand + Investor search for yield
- A memory aid, not a numerical formula. Name all three when asked for causes.
- Private credit vs syndicated loan
- Private credit: bilateral or small club, held to maturity, bespoke terms. Syndicated: bank-arranged, many lenders, tradable.
- The key distinction is who holds the loan and whether it can easily trade.
- Illiquidity compensation
- Expected spread ≈ credit spread + illiquidity premium + complexity premium
- A conceptual decomposition. It is not a precise pricing formula.
- Borrower trade-off
- Private credit: higher spread + speed + flexibility + tailored terms vs Public markets: lower spread + liquidity + scale
- A qualitative rule. Use it to justify why a borrower picks one route; it is not a pricing formula.
- Covenant types
- Maintenance covenant = tested on a schedule; Incurrence covenant = tested only when an action is taken
- Covenant-lite loans have no maintenance financial covenants, typically only incurrence tests.
- Funding comparison
- Bank: deposits + wholesale funding; Private credit fund: investor commitments (plus possible fund leverage); BSL/bond: capital-market investors
- Run risk is a bigger concern for deposit-funded banks than for closed-end funds with locked capital.
- Spread decomposition
- Spread ≈ expected credit loss + liquidity premium + complexity premium + risk premium
- Illustrative decomposition. Private loans usually carry a larger illiquidity and complexity premium.
- Fund leverage ratio
- Debt-to-equity = Fund borrowings ÷ Net asset value (equity)
- Gross assets = equity + debt. Regulators and funds may also quote debt ÷ total assets, so check the definition.
- Return on equity with leverage
- ROE = r_A + (D ÷ E) × (r_A − r_D)
- r_A is return on assets, r_D is cost of debt, D ÷ E is debt-to-equity. Ignores fees and taxes.
- Loss impact on equity
- Equity loss % = Asset loss % × (1 + D ÷ E)
- Applies to a fall in asset value with debt cost ignored. The leverage multiplier is assets ÷ equity.
- Borrower interest cover
- Interest cover = EBITDA ÷ Interest expense
- Lower cover means higher borrower-level default risk, especially with floating rates.
- Incentive fee with hurdle (no catch-up)
- Fee = Rate × max(0, Return − Hurdle) × Capital
- With a full catch-up, the manager gets the rate on all profit once the hurdle is passed.
- Expected loss
- EL = PD × LGD × EAD
- Use for borrower default risk. LGD = 1 − recovery rate.
- Recovery and loss given default
- LGD = 1 − recovery rate
- Weak covenants and weak documentation tend to lower recovery, so raise LGD.
- Cash-pay interest coverage
- Cash interest coverage = EBITDA ÷ cash interest expense
- Exclude PIK interest from cash interest. Compare with total coverage including PIK to see hidden stress.
- PIK share of interest
- PIK share = PIK interest ÷ total interest
- A rising share signals borrowers conserving cash. It is a warning sign, not proof of default.
- Discounted cash flow value of a loan
- Value = Σ CFt ÷ (1 + r)^t
- Higher discount rate or spread lowers value. Small input changes can move the mark materially.
- Unsmoothed return
- rt(true) = [rt(reported) − α × rt−1(reported)] ÷ (1 − α)
- Use for first-order smoothing, where α is the smoothing weight between 0 and 1. Unsmoothing raises measured volatility.
- Redemption coverage
- Liquid assets ÷ expected redemption requests
- Below 1 means the fund must sell illiquid assets, gate or borrow.
- Interest coverage ratio
- Interest coverage = EBITDA ÷ Interest expense
- Falls when floating rates rise. Lower coverage signals borrower stress and higher default probability.
- Debt service burden after a rate rise
- New interest = Debt × (Base rate + Spread)
- For floating-rate loans the base rate resets, so the rise passes to the borrower almost fully.
- Leverage (fund level)
- Leverage = Total assets ÷ Equity
- Higher leverage magnifies NAV falls: a fall in assets of x% cuts equity by about x% × leverage.
- Bank exposure to a fund after drawdown
- Exposure = Drawn amount + (Undrawn commitment × expected draw rate)
- Credit lines can be drawn in stress, so use stressed draw rates, not current usage.
- Expected loss
- EL = PD × LGD × EAD
- Use it to turn a higher default rate into a bank loss estimate.
- Interest coverage ratio
- Interest coverage = EBITDA ÷ Interest expense
- Core stress-test metric for borrowers. Falls when rates rise on floating-rate debt or earnings drop.
- Leverage multiple
- Debt ÷ EBITDA
- Borrower-level leverage. Compare against covenant limits and under stressed EBITDA.
- Loan-to-value
- LTV = Loan amount ÷ Value of the borrower's enterprise or collateral
- Higher LTV means less cushion before lenders take losses.
- Expected loss
- EL = PD × LGD × EAD
- Stress tests raise PD and LGD together because recoveries tend to fall when defaults rise.
- Fund leverage
- Fund leverage = Total assets ÷ Fund equity
- Fund-level borrowing magnifies losses on the underlying loans.
- Stressed loss on equity
- Loss on equity (%) = Asset loss (%) × Fund leverage
- Simple approximation that ignores financing costs. Shows why leverage matters.
Quick revision
- Private credit is non-bank lending to firms, mostly negotiated directly, outside public bond markets.
- Growth was helped by tighter bank regulation, investor demand for yield and borrower demand for tailored financing.
- Loans are usually bespoke, held to maturity and rarely traded, so market prices are scarce.
- Compared with banks, private credit funds do not take deposits, but they may use leverage and bank credit lines.
- Compared with public bonds, private loans have less disclosure and less liquidity.
- Leverage at fund level magnifies both returns and losses.
- Valuation often relies on models and manager judgement, so marks can lag true conditions.
- Illiquidity risk grows when investors can redeem faster than assets can be sold.
- Credit risk can be hidden by weak covenants and by borrowers that refinance or defer interest.
- Bank links include lending to funds and to private credit vehicles, which can transmit stress.
- Limited data on exposures makes system-wide risk hard to measure.
- Controls include stress testing, independent valuation, liquidity management, covenant monitoring and better data reporting.
Common mistakes
- Treating private credit as the same as syndicated bank lending. Fix: Remember who holds the loan. Private credit is held by non-bank funds, often bilaterally, and is far less tradable.
- Saying mezzanine is senior debt. Fix: Mezzanine sits below senior debt and above equity, which is why it earns a higher return.
- Saying private credit is unregulated. Fix: Say funds face different regulation, often without bank-style capital or liquidity rules, but are still subject to securities and investor-protection oversight.
- Treating all private credit loans as having tight covenants. Fix: Say private loans tend to have tighter maintenance covenants and easier renegotiation, but terms vary and some large deals loosen protections.
- Treating interval funds and BDCs as the same as closed-end drawdown funds for liquidity. Fix: Separate asset liquidity from investor liquidity. Interval funds offer periodic repurchases, so they carry a liquidity mismatch that drawdown funds do not.
- Using debt ÷ total assets as debt-to-equity. Fix: Read the definition. Debt-to-equity divides by equity. With debt ₹60 and equity ₹40, D/E is 1.5, not 0.6.
- Treating low reported volatility as low risk Fix: Remember marks are model-based and smoothed. Unsmoothing raises volatility and lowers the apparent Sharpe ratio.
- Counting PIK loans as performing without caution Fix: Check cash coverage. PIK means no cash was paid. A growing PIK share points to hidden stress.
- Treating private credit as fully separate from banks. Fix: Remember that banks fund and service these funds through credit lines, leverage facilities and prime services.
- Assuming rising rates help floating-rate lenders without risk. Fix: Also consider borrower stress: higher interest burden lowers coverage and raises defaults.
Exam tips
- Expect scenario questions that describe a loan and ask you to name the strategy. Locate the loan in the capital structure first.
- Always pair a feature with its risk: illiquidity, opaque valuation, leverage, or bank linkages.
- Watch for absolute words such as 'always' or 'never' in options; they are usually wrong.
- For growth questions, name regulation-driven bank retrenchment plus demand and investor yield search to be safe.
- This topic is part of Current Issues, so be ready to connect it to financial stability concerns.
- Expect case-style questions asking you to match a borrower profile to a funding route; read size, speed and confidentiality cues first.
- Know the difference between maintenance, incurrence and covenant-lite terms; options often mix them up.
- Watch for absolute words in options; the correct answer usually states a tendency.