NISM Certifications · NISM-Series-XV: Research Analyst
Company Analysis - Business and Governance: formula sheet
Key formulas
- Porter's Five Forces
- 1) Threat of new entrants; 2) Bargaining power of suppliers; 3) Bargaining power of buyers; 4) Threat of substitutes; 5) Rivalry among existing competitors
- Strong forces lower industry profit. Learn the exact five names. Do not add 'government' or 'complementors' as a force.
- Market share
- Market share (%) = Company sales ÷ Total industry sales × 100
- Use the same period and the same market definition for both numbers.
- Operating margin
- Operating margin (%) = Operating profit ÷ Revenue × 100
- A margin above peers can hint at pricing power or cost advantage.
- Revenue concentration
- Share of top customer (%) = Revenue from top customer ÷ Total revenue × 100
- A high share signals dependence risk.
- Generic strategies
- Cost leadership | Differentiation | Focus
- These are the three ways a firm builds competitive advantage in Porter's framework.
- Moat test (economic profit)
- Economic profit = (ROIC − Cost of capital) × Invested capital
- A moat shows up as ROIC staying above the cost of capital for many years, not for one year.
- Cost leadership vs differentiation
- Cost leadership = lowest cost; Differentiation = unique value and premium price
- Cost leaders compete on cost position. Differentiators compete on features, brand or service.
- Sustainability rule
- Moat = advantage + durability + difficulty to copy
- An advantage that can be copied quickly is not a moat.
- Gross margin
- Gross margin = (Revenue − Cost of goods sold) ÷ Revenue × 100
- Stable or high margins relative to peers can hint at pricing power or cost advantage.
- Capital allocation test
- Return on new investment > Cost of capital → value created
- A qualitative rule of thumb. Good management invests only where expected returns exceed the cost of capital.
- Execution check
- Actual results ÷ Past guidance or promises
- Compare over several years. Repeated shortfalls signal weak execution.
- Five areas of management assessment
- Experience + Capital allocation + Execution + Integrity + Succession
- Use this as a checklist to classify any exam scenario.
- Promoter pledge ratio
- Promoter shares pledged ÷ Total promoter shares held × 100
- A rising ratio signals financial stress or risk to promoter control. Treat it as a flag, not proof of wrongdoing.
- Pledged percentage of promoter holding
- Pledged % of promoter holding = Pledged shares ÷ Promoter shares × 100
- The base is the promoter's own shares, not total company shares.
- Pledged percentage of total equity
- Pledged % of total shares = Pledged shares ÷ Total shares outstanding × 100
- Equals promoter holding % × pledged % of promoter holding ÷ 100.
- Cash conversion check
- Operating cash flow ÷ Net profit
- A persistent ratio well below 1 suggests earnings may not be turning into cash. It is a prompt to investigate, not proof.
- RPT share of revenue
- RPT sales ÷ Total revenue × 100
- A high or rising share means dependence on connected parties. Test whether pricing is at arm's length.
- Promoter holding
- Promoter holding % = Shares held by promoter and promoter group ÷ Total shares outstanding × 100
- Public holding % = 100 − promoter holding %, when only these two categories exist.
- Pledge ratio
- Pledged % = Pledged promoter shares ÷ Total promoter shares × 100
- Check the base. It is usually promoter shares, not total shares. Read the question wording.
- ESG components
- ESG = Environmental + Social + Governance
- Know which factor each example belongs to. Board independence is G, emissions is E, worker safety is S.
- BRSR indicators
- Essential = mandatory; Leadership = voluntary
- Both sit under the principle-wise performance disclosures.
- Change in holding
- Change = Holding % this quarter − Holding % last quarter
- Quote in percentage points, not percent.
Quick revision
- A business model explains who the customers are, what is sold, and how the company earns revenue and profit.
- An economic moat is a lasting advantage that protects a company's returns from competitors.
- A temporary advantage, such as a short-term price cut, is not a moat.
- Common moat sources include brand, cost advantage, switching costs, network effects and regulatory licences.
- Management quality is judged by track record, capital allocation, consistency of statements and delivery.
- Corporate governance is the system by which a company is directed and controlled in the interest of its stakeholders.
- Independent directors and board committees are key checks on promoters and management.
- Related party transactions need close scrutiny for fairness of terms and for disclosure.
- Frequent auditor changes, aggressive accounting and unexplained promoter pledging are typical red flags.
- ESG stands for environmental, social and governance factors.
- Shareholding pattern shows promoter, institutional and public holdings, and changes in it carry information.
- Check exact regulatory limits and definitions in the NISM workbook before the exam.
Common mistakes
- Confusing threat of substitutes with rivalry among existing competitors. Fix: Rivals sell the same kind of product in the same industry. Substitutes meet the same need in a different way, such as a ride-hailing app against a personal car.
- Saying high entry barriers mean a high threat of new entrants. Fix: High barriers mean a low threat of entry. Always state the direction of the force.
- Treating a large market share as proof of a moat. Fix: Ask whether the lead is durable and hard to copy. Share alone is not a moat.
- Confusing cost leadership with simply charging low prices. Fix: Cost leadership is about having a lower cost base. Low prices without low cost only hurt margins.
- Judging management only on one year of profit growth. Fix: Look for consistency across cycles and compare actual delivery with earlier guidance.
- Treating a charismatic or famous promoter as proof of quality. Fix: Rely on facts: capital allocation record, disclosures, treatment of minority holders and regulatory history.
- Treating pledged shares as shares the promoter has sold. Fix: Remember ownership stays with the promoter unless the lender invokes the pledge. Pledging is a charge on shares held.
- Calculating pledged percentage on total shares when the question asks for percentage of promoter holding. Fix: Read the base words. 'Of promoter holding' means divide by promoter shares.
- Putting board independence or related party dealings under social factors. Fix: Anything about board, control, disclosure, audit or shareholder rights is governance. Social is about employees, customers and communities.
- Treating Leadership indicators in BRSR as mandatory. Fix: Essential indicators are mandatory. Leadership indicators are voluntary.
Exam tips
- Learn the five force names exactly and practise matching a one-line clue to a force and its direction.
- Watch the direction words: high barriers lower entry threat; strong suppliers or buyers hurt the company.
- Questions are often scenario based. Underline the clue before reading the options.
- Be careful with absolute words like 'always' and 'only'; they often mark wrong options.
- Under negative marking, skip a scenario only if you cannot tell the force. Most can be solved by keyword mapping.
- Learn the difference between a strategy (cost leadership, differentiation) and a source (brand, scale, switching costs, network effects).
- Watch for the words 'sustainable', 'durable' and 'hard to copy'. They signal a moat question.
- In scenario questions, match the customer behaviour described to the source before reading the options.