Skip to content

Business Management · Business and consumer needs, the industry value chain and competitive forces

Stakeholders and Their Objectives in an Insurance Business

Updated 11 October 2026 · Fact-checked

Stakeholders are the groups with an interest in a financial services business: customers or policyholders, shareholders, regulators, employees, distributors, and others such as government and the wider public. Each wants something different. To answer exam questions, name the group, state its objective, then show where it aligns or conflicts with others.

Understand Stakeholders and Their Objectives

A stakeholder is any person or group that affects, or is affected by, what a business does. In an insurer the main ones are policyholders, shareholders, regulators, employees, distributors, reinsurers, and the government and society.

Each group has its own objectives. Policyholders want products that meet their needs, fair prices, good service, prompt claim payment and confidence that the insurer will still be solvent when a claim arises. Shareholders want a good return on the capital they provide, through dividends and growth in share value. Regulators want policyholders protected, the insurer to stay solvent, fair treatment of customers and a stable financial system. Employees want fair pay, job security, development and a good working environment. Distributors such as agents, brokers and banks want commission, products that sell easily, and good support.

These interests often align. A well-run insurer that prices accurately, pays claims fairly and keeps strong capital will usually keep policyholders, satisfy the regulator and earn returns for shareholders over time. Happy employees tend to give better service.

They also conflict. Shareholders may want higher prices, lower capital held and higher dividends, while policyholders want lower premiums, better benefits and strong security. Regulators may demand more capital than shareholders would choose. Distributors may favour products with high commission, which may not be best for the customer. In participating business, how profit is split between policyholders and shareholders is a direct conflict.

An actuary must see all these views. Good advice balances them, treats customers fairly and stays within regulation and professional standards. In the exam, always link your points to the situation in the question.

How to solve Stakeholders and Their Objectives questions

Use this method for any question asking about stakeholders, their objectives or conflicts.

  1. 1Read the scenario and list the stakeholders actually involved. Do not give a generic list if the case names specific groups.
  2. 2For each stakeholder, state in one line what they want from the business.
  3. 3Link each objective to the decision in the question, such as a price change, new product, bonus declaration or change in distribution.
  4. 4Identify where interests align, for example good service helping both retention and profit.
  5. 5Identify where they conflict, and say why, for example premium level versus shareholder return.
  6. 6Explain how the business could balance or manage the conflict, such as regulation, communication, product design or profit-sharing rules.
  7. 7Give a clear conclusion or recommendation that fits the question's wording.

Quickest way: Stakeholder, Want, Conflict

When to use it: Use for short written questions and MCQs where you have only a few minutes.

  1. Write the stakeholder names in a row: policyholders, shareholders, regulator, employees, distributors.
  2. Add a two or three word objective under each.
  3. Pick the one or two pairs that clash most in the scenario.
  4. Write one sentence per pair explaining the clash and one way to resolve it.
  5. Check you used the case details, not only textbook points.

Common mistakes in Stakeholders and Their Objectives

  • Listing stakeholders without stating their objectives.

    Students memorise names but not what each group wants.

    Fix: Always write the stakeholder and a specific objective together, then link it to the scenario.

  • Treating shareholders and policyholders as always opposed.

    The conflict is emphasised in notes, so alignment is forgotten.

    Fix: State both sides. Fair treatment and solvency support long-term profit and customer trust.

  • Forgetting the regulator or treating its aim as the same as shareholders'.

    Students focus on commercial parties.

    Fix: Remember the regulator mainly aims to protect policyholders and keep the market stable, which can mean more capital or tighter conduct rules.

  • Ignoring distributors and employees.

    They seem less central than customers and owners.

    Fix: Mention how commission, incentives and workload affect selling behaviour and service quality.

  • Giving generic answers not tied to the case.

    Students write a memorised list under time pressure.

    Fix: Use the product, channel or decision in the question in every point you make.

  • Stating a conflict but offering no way to manage it.

    Students stop once the clash is described.

    Fix: Add a short remedy such as clear disclosure, profit-sharing rules, balanced incentives or regulatory oversight.

Worked examples

Example 1

An insurer plans to raise premiums on a health product to improve profit. Identify the stakeholders affected and explain where their objectives conflict.

Show the solution
  1. Stakeholders: policyholders, shareholders, regulator, distributors, employees.
  2. Shareholders want a higher return, so they favour better margins.
  3. Policyholders want affordable cover and may lapse or switch if prices rise.
  4. The regulator wants fair pricing and may review the increase if customers could be treated unfairly.
  5. Distributors may find the product harder to sell, reducing their commission income.
  6. Conflict: shareholders versus policyholders and regulator on price. Alignment: if claims costs have truly risen, a sound price protects solvency, which helps all parties.
  7. Management: justify the rise with claims data, communicate clearly and consider benefit design changes.

Answer: The rise helps shareholders but hurts policyholders and distributors, and the regulator may challenge it. It is easier to defend if it reflects real cost increases, which also supports solvency.

Example 2

A life insurer sells with-profits policies. Explain how policyholder and shareholder objectives can conflict in deciding the bonus declared.

Show the solution
  1. Policyholders want high bonuses, giving better returns on their policies.
  2. Shareholders want to retain as much profit as the rules allow, to increase their return.
  3. A higher bonus reduces the profit available for shareholders, and a lower bonus may disappoint policyholders and damage sales.
  4. The regulator wants bonus decisions to be fair, within the policy terms and consistent with solvency.
  5. Alignment: moderate, steady bonuses keep customers and protect long-term capital, supporting future shareholder returns.
  6. Management: follow a clear, documented bonus policy and the stated profit-sharing basis, and communicate it.

Answer: Each rupee of bonus declared is a rupee not available to shareholders, so they conflict directly. The conflict is managed through a transparent profit-sharing policy, regulatory oversight and a long-term view that sustains both groups.

Exam tips

  • Always tie each stakeholder's objective to the scenario given. Generic lists earn few marks.
  • For conflict questions, name a pair of stakeholders and give the reason, not just the word conflict.
  • Include the regulator, as it is easy to forget and often carries marks.
  • For MCQs, pick the option that matches the stakeholder's main objective, such as solvency protection for the regulator or return on capital for shareholders.
  • End written answers with a short way of balancing interests to show judgement.

Practice questions from Business and consumer needs, the industry value chain and competitive forces

Stakeholders and Their Objectives in other exams

The same ground in other exams, if you are preparing for more than one or want another angle on it.

Stakeholders and Their Objectives: frequently asked questions

Who are the main stakeholders of an insurer?

The main ones are policyholders, shareholders, regulators, employees and distributors. Others include reinsurers, the government and society. Use the case details to decide which matter most.

What is the difference between shareholder and policyholder objectives?

Shareholders want a return on the capital they invested, through profit, dividends and growth. Policyholders want suitable products, fair prices, good service and security that claims will be paid. The two often align over the long term but can clash on price, capital and profit sharing.

What do regulators want from an insurer?

Regulators aim to protect policyholders, keep insurers solvent, ensure fair treatment of customers and support a stable financial system. This can mean requiring more capital or stricter conduct than shareholders would choose.

Do stakeholder interests ever align?

Yes. A well-run insurer with sound pricing, fair claims handling and strong capital tends to satisfy customers and the regulator while generating sustainable returns. Exam answers should show both alignment and conflict.