FRM Part II · FRM Exam Part II · Estimating Default Probabilities
A risk manager wants to use default probabilities for two purposes: (1) calculating a one-year credit VaR for a loan portfolio for economic capital, and (2) marking to market a credit default swap position held by the trading desk. Which choice of default probability is most appropriate?
Use real-world probabilities for credit VaR and economic capital, because these estimate actual potential future losses, and risk-neutral probabilities for marking a CDS, because valuation must be consistent with market prices that include risk premia.
- ARisk-neutral probabilities for both purposes
- BReal-world probabilities for both purposes
- CReal-world probabilities for (1) and risk-neutral probabilities for (2)Correct
- DRisk-neutral probabilities for (1) and real-world probabilities for (2)
Explanation
Scenario analysis of potential future losses, such as credit VaR and economic capital, needs the actual likelihood of default, so real-world probabilities apply. Valuing a CDS today requires consistency with market prices, which embed risk premia, so risk-neutral probabilities are used. The reverse assignment would misstate both loss estimates and prices.
Did you get it right without looking?
One question tells you little. A timed set on Estimating Default Probabilities shows your real accuracy, how long you take and where you lose marks.
More Estimating Default Probabilities questions
- A credit analyst at a bank uses the original Altman Z-score model for publicly traded manufacturing firms. Z = 1.2X1 + 1.4X2 + 3.3X3 + 0.6X4…
- A trader uses a constant hazard rate implied from a 3-year CDS spread of 180 basis points with a 40% recovery rate (hazard = spread / (1 - R…
- An analyst estimates the average annual hazard rate from historical data. A rating class has a seven-year cumulative default probability of …
- A simple three-state annual transition matrix has states A, B and D (default). From A: 90% stay in A, 8% move to B, 2% default. From B: 10% …
- A practitioner compares Merton-model default probabilities with agency ratings for a portfolio of listed firms. Which is a recognized limita…
- A bank's risk committee debates whether to rely on through-the-cycle agency ratings or point-in-time internal ratings for monitoring its loa…