FRM Part II · FRM Exam Part II · Case Study: Model Risk and Model Validation
A validator wants to test whether a credit risk model's performance deteriorates when applied to a borrower segment not represented in the development sample. Which technique is most appropriate?
Out-of-sample and out-of-time testing is most appropriate, because it applies the model to data not used in development, such as the new borrower segment, showing whether performance generalizes. Refitting on development data, adding variables or reviewing documentation cannot reveal that weakness.
- AOut-of-time and out-of-sample testing on data from that segmentCorrect
- BRe-estimating parameters on the full development sample
- CIncreasing the number of explanatory variables
- DReviewing the model documentation for completeness
Explanation
Out-of-sample (and out-of-time) testing applies the model to data not used in development, revealing whether it generalizes to new segments. Re-estimating on the development sample or adding variables risks overfitting and does not test generalization. Documentation review does not measure performance.
Did you get it right without looking?
One question tells you little. A timed set on Case Study: Model Risk and Model Validation shows your real accuracy, how long you take and where you lose marks.
More Case Study: Model Risk and Model Validation questions
- A risk manager reviews a fund that, like LTCM, has equity of USD 4.7 billion and assets of USD 125 billion. Its leverage ratio (assets/equit…
- A bank's validation of a credit model shows strong performance, but the validator discovers the validation sample was drawn from the same be…
- A validation team reviews a bank's VaR model and finds that a spreadsheet macro used to aggregate position data silently drops positions who…
- In the London Whale case, the CIO's trading positions grew while VaR limits were exceeded, and the 10-Q VaR was temporarily reported using t…
- A validator wants to assess how sensitive a pricing model's output is to a key assumption, such as a volatility input, holding the model str…
- Two models, A and B, price the same loan portfolio. Both pass backtesting, but they give materially different fair values because each rests…