FRM Part I · FRM Exam Part I · External and Internal Credit Ratings
During a recession, a bank's portfolio is rated using a point-in-time (PIT) system and, separately, a through-the-cycle (TTC) system. Which outcome is most consistent with the known properties of these systems?
Point-in-time based capital would rise more sharply in a recession. PIT ratings react quickly to worsening conditions, producing fast downgrades and higher estimated default probabilities, which makes capital requirements procyclical. Through-the-cycle ratings are stable and so generate smaller capital swings over the cycle.
- APIT-based regulatory capital would be expected to rise more sharply than TTC-based capital because PIT ratings migrate downward fasterCorrect
- BTTC-based capital would be expected to rise more sharply than PIT-based capital because TTC ratings are more volatile
- CBoth systems would produce identical capital requirements because default probabilities are unchanged
- DPIT-based capital would fall because current conditions make borrowers appear safer
Explanation
PIT ratings respond to deteriorating conditions, so downgrades and higher PDs arrive quickly, raising capital requirements and making them procyclical. TTC ratings are stable, so capital changes less. The option claiming TTC is more volatile reverses this relationship.
Did you get it right without looking?
One question tells you little. A timed set on External and Internal Credit Ratings shows your real accuracy, how long you take and where you lose marks.
More External and Internal Credit Ratings questions
- When a bank validates its internal rating system, it finds that borrowers rated in the best grades defaulted at a similar rate to borrowers …
- A risk manager reviews an annual transition matrix for a portfolio of rated bonds and wants to infer default risk from it. Which observation…
- A risk analyst reviews criticisms of external ratings for structured finance products during the 2007-2009 crisis. Which statement most accu…
- A simplified annual transition matrix has three states. From A: 90% stay A, 8% move to B, 2% default. From B: 10% move to A, 80% stay B, 10%…
- A risk manager notes that observed historical default rates for a given rating differ between the start of a recession and the end of an exp…
- Which feature is generally associated with agency external ratings such as those from major rating agencies, relative to internal ratings bu…