ACCA Strategic Professional · Strategic Business Leader · Reporting to stakeholders
Harlow Energy's sustainability report is prepared entirely by its marketing department, reports only favourable indicators, and has no external verification. Critics describe it as a public relations exercise that overstates the company's environmental performance. Which weakness of voluntary social and environmental reporting does this best illustrate?
It illustrates a credibility problem. Because the report is voluntary, prepared by marketing, selective in what it shows and lacks independent assurance, stakeholders cannot trust it, which is the risk of greenwashing in social and environmental reporting.
- ALack of credibility because of selective disclosure and absence of independent assuranceCorrect
- BExcessive cost caused by mandatory disclosure rules
- CDuplication of the statutory financial audit
- DInability to report any non-financial data
Explanation
Voluntary reports can be selective and unverified, which damages credibility, a key criticism often called greenwashing. The reporting is not mandatory, does not duplicate the financial audit, and clearly does include non-financial data.
Did you get it right without looking?
One question tells you little. A timed set on Reporting to stakeholders shows your real accuracy, how long you take and where you lose marks.
More Reporting to stakeholders questions
- Aurelia Group publishes a glossy sustainability narrative reporting record emissions cuts and strong stakeholder engagement. Analysts note i…
- Orlin Chemicals wants to show investors and communities the full effect of its activities. It decides to report on three dimensions: economi…
- Tamsin Retail's board wants its social and environmental audit to give the most useful insight into whether the company is meeting stakehold…
- Orlin Mining's board states in its annual report that it applies 'integrated thinking'. Analysis shows the sustainability team, finance team…
- Halvorsen Marine plc, a listed shipping group, publishes an annual report with a long financial section but only a brief, generic paragraph …
- Zentara plc, a listed mining group, wants its annual report to show how its strategy, governance, performance and prospects lead to value cr…