CMA Final · Direct Tax Laws and International Taxation
Grievance Redressal: formula sheet
Key formulas
- Draft order trigger
- AO proposes variation prejudicial to eligible assessee → draft order must be forwarded first
- Section 275(1). Applies only to an eligible assessee.
- Eligible assessee
- (i) variation arises from TPO order under section 166(6); or (ii) non-resident (not a company) or foreign company
- Section 275(17)(b). Persons in section 292(1) or 295 are excluded under section 275(18).
- Assessee's response time
- Within 30 days of receipt of draft order: accept, or object to DRP and AO
- Section 275(2). Objections go to both the DRP and the AO.
- Order on acceptance or no objection
- Final order within one month from the end of the month of acceptance or of expiry of the 30-day period
- Section 275(4)(a), as substituted w.e.f. 1-4-2026.
- Time limit for DRP directions
- Not after nine months from the end of the month in which the draft order is forwarded
- Section 275(13).
- Order after DRP directions
- Final order within one month from the end of the month in which the directions are received, without further hearing of the assessee
- Section 275(14)(a).
- DRP powers
- Confirm, reduce or enhance; no set aside; no direction for further enquiry and passing of order
- Section 275(8).
- Appeal route
- Order passed per DRP directions → Appellate Tribunal (section 362(1)(d)); excluded from CIT(A) under section 357(d) and (e)
- Tribunal appeal within two months from the end of the month of communication (section 362(3)).
- Waiver of penalty: concealment cases
- Additional income-tax = 100% × tax payable on under-reported income
- Section 440(1)(b): applies where penalty was levied in the circumstances in section 439(11)(a) to (f). Paid within the period in the notice of demand, in lieu of penalty.
- Waiver of penalty: misreporting case
- Additional income-tax = 120% × tax payable on under-reported income
- Section 440(1)(c): applies where penalty was levied in the circumstances in section 439(11)(g). Paid within the notice of demand period.
- Time limit for application under section 440
- Within 1 month from the end of the month in which the order is received
- Section 440(2). Example: order received on 12 July, application due by 31 August.
- Decision on application
- Order accepting or rejecting within 3 months from the end of the month of receipt
- Section 440(5). Rejection needs a hearing (section 440(6)). The order is final (section 440(7)).
- Immunity from prosecution by the Central Government
- Immunity conditional on full and true disclosure of the whole circumstances
- Section 519(1). Withdrawn if conditions are broken, concealment continues or false evidence is given (section 519(3)); the person can then be tried and penalised (section 519(4)).
- High Court appeal: condition
- Appeal lies from Tribunal order only if substantial question of law is involved
- Section 365(1). The High Court must be satisfied and must formulate the question (365(4)).
- High Court appeal: time limit
- 120 days from receipt of the order
- Section 365(2)(a). Late appeal admissible on sufficient cause (365(3)). Form: memorandum stating the question precisely.
- Who can appeal to High Court
- Assessee or PCCIT / CCIT / PCIT / CIT
- Section 365(2).
- Revision: limit on own motion
- No suo motu revision if order is more than 1 year old
- Section 378(2).
- Revision: assessee's application
- Within 1 year of communication or knowledge, whichever is earlier; fee ₹500
- Section 378(3), (6). Delay condonable for sufficient cause (378(4)).
- Revision: outcome
- Order must not be prejudicial to the assessee
- Section 378(1)(c). Declining to interfere is not prejudicial (378(11)(b)).
- Revision: bar
- No revision where appeal lies and time not expired, right not waived, or appeal already made
- Section 378(5).
- Disposal time for assessee's revision application
- Within 1 year from end of the financial year of application
- Section 378(7). Extended to 60 days if remaining time is less (378(9)).
- Identical question: department's appeal after final decision
- 60 days to Tribunal or 120 days to High Court from communication of the final order
- Section 376(6). Application to be filed within 120 days of receiving the order (376(3)).
- Rectification time limit (section 287(8))
- No amendment after 4 years from the end of the financial year in which the order or intimation was passed
- Subject to the exception in section 288. Applies to the authority's own motion and to taxpayer requests.
- Disposal of rectification application (section 287(9))
- Order within 6 months from the end of the month in which the application is received
- The order may amend or refuse the claim.
- Notice before adverse amendment (section 287(4))
- Notice of intention + reasonable opportunity of being heard
- Needed where the amendment enhances assessment, reduces refund or increases liability.
- Tribunal rectification (section 363(2))
- Within 6 months from the end of the month in which the order was passed; fee ₹50 for assessee's application
- Mistake may be brought by the assessee or the Assessing Officer. Adverse amendment needs an opportunity of being heard.
- Advance ruling rejection grounds (section 384(3))
- Reject if question is (a) pending before authority, Tribunal or court, (b) fair market value of property, (c) prima facie designed for tax avoidance
- Exceptions exist for resident applicants under section 380(b)(iii), and for (c) also section 380(b)(iv) applicants. Rejection needs a hearing and reasons (section 384(4)).
- Advance ruling timeline and appeal
- Ruling within 6 months of application; appeal to High Court within 60 days, plus up to 30 days if sufficient cause
- Sections 384(6) and 389(1) and (2).
Quick revision
- An appeal to the Appellate Tribunal under section 362 must be filed within two months from the end of the month in which the order is communicated.
- The Commissioner can direct the Assessing Officer to appeal to the Tribunal against an order of the Commissioner (Appeals) if he objects to it.
- Cross-objections can be filed within 30 days of receiving notice of the other party's appeal, even if that party had not appealed earlier.
- The Tribunal can admit a late appeal or cross-objections if there is sufficient cause for the delay.
- Tribunal fee: ₹500 up to ₹1,00,000 income; ₹1,500 above ₹1,00,000 up to ₹2,00,000; 1% of assessed income above ₹2,00,000, capped at ₹10,000.
- No fee is payable for the department's appeal or for cross-objections; a stay application carries a fee of ₹500.
- Section 365 covers appeals to the High Court and section 367 covers appeals to the Supreme Court.
- Section 375: an assessee may give a declaration that he will not raise an identical question of law if the final decision in the other case is applied to his case.
- An order admitting or rejecting a claim under section 375(3) is final and cannot be questioned in appeal or revision.
- Section 376: a collegium of two or more senior officers may tell the Commissioner not to appeal now where an identical question is pending; the application is due within 120 days.
- Under section 376(6), a later appeal is due within 60 days to the Tribunal or 120 days to the High Court from communication of the final decision.
- Always use Income-tax Act, 2025 section numbers and the tax year 2026-27 for this exam.
Common mistakes
- Treating every assessee as eligible for the DRP route. Fix: Quote section 275(17)(b): TPO-linked variation, non-resident non-company, or foreign company. Check the exclusions.
- Counting the nine-month limit from the date of the draft order. Fix: Take the last day of the month in which the draft order is forwarded, then add nine months.
- Treating the Settlement Commission as the current forum. Fix: Write that the Commission is historical and the Interim Board handles settlement now. Mention section 360(1)(c) as the only trace in the supplied text.
- Applying 100% additional tax in a misreporting case. Fix: Clauses (a) to (f) of section 439(11) carry 100%. Clause (g) carries 120%.
- Saying the High Court appeal lies on any ground, including facts. Fix: Write that the appeal needs a substantial question of law, formulated by the Court.
- Using 60 days for the High Court appeal. Fix: High Court is 120 days under section 365(2)(a). The 60 days applies to the Tribunal in section 376(6).
- Counting four years from the date of the order. Fix: Count from the end of the financial year in which the order or intimation was passed.
- Allowing rectification of a matter decided in appeal. Fix: Section 287(2) excludes matters considered and decided in appeal or revision.
Exam tips
- Learn the four time limits as a set: 30 days, one month, nine months, one month. Examiners test which period starts where.
- In case studies, first decide eligibility. A resident Indian company with no TPO variation has no DRP route, so say so.
- Always write the section number (275 for the process, 362 for the Tribunal appeal) next to each conclusion.
- For MCQs, watch for traps: DRP can enhance, cannot set aside, has three members, and its directions bind the AO.
- Remember the 2026 substitution of sub-sections (4) and (14), which tie the time limits to the draft order being forwarded within the time allowed under section 286.
- Learn the 100% versus 120% split with the clause ranges; it is a favourite MCQ.
- Write the time limits exactly: one month from the end of the month, three months for the decision.
- In case questions, tick each condition in a line before giving the conclusion.