CMA Final · Direct Tax Laws and International Taxation
Income Computation and Disclosure Standards (ICDS): formula sheet
Key formulas
- Method of accounting
- Business / other sources income = computed on cash OR mercantile system, regularly employed (s. 276(1))
- Subject to notified ICDS. Consistency matters: the method must be regularly followed.
- Power to notify ICDS
- Central Government may notify ICDS for any class of assessees or any class of income (s. 276(2))
- ICDS apply only where notified, and only for these two heads.
- Grounds for assessment under section 271
- (a) accounts incorrect or incomplete; (b) method not regularly followed; (c) income not computed as per notified standards (s. 276(3))
- Any one ground is enough. Learn them as A-B-C.
- Inventory valuation (s. 277(1)(i))
- Inventory = lower of actual cost or net realisable value, as per ICDS
- Cost includes tax, duty, cess or fee actually paid or incurred to bring goods to location and condition (s. 277(1)(ii)).
- Securities as inventory
- Unlisted, or listed but not regularly quoted: actual cost initially recognised. Other securities: lower of cost or NRV (s. 277(1)(iii),(iv))
- Comparison of cost and NRV is category-wise (s. 277(3)).
- Contracts (s. 57)
- Construction contracts and service contracts: percentage of completion method; services of not more than 90 days: project completion; indeterminate acts over a period: straight line
- Contract revenue includes retention money; contract costs are not reduced by incidental interest, dividends or capital gains.
- Fundamental assumptions (ICDS I)
- Going concern + Consistency + Accrual
- Assumed to be followed. Non-compliance must be disclosed.
- Change in accounting policy (ICDS I)
- Change only if required by law/ICDS OR gives a more appropriate presentation
- Material effect must be disclosed. Impact is disclosed where it can be ascertained.
- Specific borrowing (ICDS IX)
- Amount capitalised = Actual borrowing cost incurred on the loan for the period of capitalisation
- Do NOT deduct income earned on temporary investment of the unused loan.
- General borrowing (ICDS IX)
- Amount capitalised = (A × B) ÷ C
- A = average of cost of the qualifying asset on the first and last day of the previous year. B = actual cost of general borrowings during the year (excluding specific borrowings). C = average of total assets in the balance sheet on the first and last day of the previous year.
- Qualifying asset test
- Listed tangible and intangible assets: qualify, no time test. Inventories: 12 months or more to reach saleable condition
- The 12-month test applies only to inventories.
- Commencement
- Expenditure being incurred + Borrowing costs being incurred + Activities to prepare the asset begun
- All three conditions must be met before capitalisation starts.
- Cessation
- Capitalisation stops on the date the asset is first put to use
- Borrowing cost after that date is a revenue expense.
- Inventory valuation rule
- Value = lower of (actual cost, NRV)
- Section 277(1)(i). Applies to inventory generally, as computed per the notified ICDS.
- Net realisable value
- NRV = Estimated selling price − Estimated cost of completion − Estimated selling costs
- Compare with cost for each item or category as the standard requires.
- Cost of inventory
- Cost = Purchase price + Conversion costs + Other costs to bring goods to present location and condition + Taxes, duties, cess or fees paid or incurred
- Section 277(1)(ii) and (4). Include the tax even if a credit or right arises from paying it.
- Unlisted or irregularly quoted securities
- Value = actual cost initially recognised
- Section 277(1)(iii). Applies to securities held as inventory that are not listed, or are listed but not quoted with regularity. No lower-of-cost-or-NRV test.
- Other securities
- Value = lower of (cost, NRV), compared category-wise
- Section 277(1)(iv) and 277(3).
- Depreciation on a block
- Depreciation = Prescribed % × WDV of the block
- Section 33(1) and (3)(a). Covers buildings, machinery, plant, furniture and specified intangibles acquired on or after 1 April 1998 (not goodwill), used wholly and exclusively for business.
- Half-rate rule
- If acquired in the tax year and used for less than 180 days: normal depreciation = 50% of prescribed rate
- Section 33(4). It restricts normal depreciation only, not additional depreciation.
- Additional depreciation
- 20% of actual cost of new machinery or plant (10% if used for less than 180 days, and 10% in the next tax year)
- Section 33(8) and (9). Only for manufacture, production, or power generation, transmission or distribution, and subject to the listed exclusions.
- Stage of completion (cost method)
- Stage of completion % = Costs incurred to date ÷ Total estimated contract cost × 100
- Use costs that reflect work done. Costs for future work, such as advance payments to suppliers, are excluded from the numerator.
- Revenue recognised in the year
- Revenue for year = (Stage of completion % × Total contract revenue) − Revenue recognised in earlier years
- Total contract revenue includes retention money (section 57(3)(a)).
- Profit for the year
- Profit = Revenue for the year − Contract costs for the year
- Do not reduce costs by incidental interest, dividend or capital gains (section 57(3)(b)).
- Service contract exceptions
- Duration ≤ 90 days: project completion method. Indeterminate acts over a specified period: straight line method. Otherwise: percentage of completion.
- From section 57(2).
- Grant for depreciable asset
- Revised actual cost or WDV = Cost or WDV − Grant
- Depreciation is then computed on the reduced value.
- Section 43 charge
- Exchange gain or loss on foreign currency transactions = income or loss, computed as per ICDS
- Subject to section 42. Covers monetary and non-monetary items, translation of foreign operations, forward contracts and translation reserves.
- Variation in liability (section 42)
- A = B – C
- A = variation in liability. B = payment in rupees at the time it is made. C = corresponding liability in rupees at the time of acquiring the asset.
- B for section 42
- B = payment made (a) towards cost of the asset, or (b) towards repayment of money borrowed, with interest in foreign currency, specifically for acquiring the asset
- Any part of the liability met directly or indirectly by another person or authority is excluded.
- Effect on cost
- Revised actual cost = Original cost ± A
- A positive A (rupee payment is higher) increases cost; a negative A reduces it. Applies to actual cost under section 39, capital expenditure under section 32(i) or 45(1)(a)(i), or cost of acquisition for section 72.
- Forward contract with authorised dealer (section 42(4))
- Use the rate specified in the contract for the part of the sum available to discharge the liability
- The contract must be with an authorised dealer under FEMA, 1999, for a specified sum on or after a stipulated future date at a stated rate.
- Business income after ICDS adjustment
- Taxable business income = Book profit + ICDS-based additions − ICDS-based deductions
- Add back any book deduction that ICDS does not allow. Deduct any item ICDS allows but books did not charge. Other normal tax adjustments are made separately.
- Inventory valuation rule (section 277(1)(i))
- Value of inventory = lower of actual cost and net realisable value
- Compare item by item for goods. For securities, the comparison is category-wise (section 277(3)).
- Cost of inventory (section 277(1)(ii))
- Cost includes tax, duty, cess or fee actually paid or incurred to bring goods to their location and condition
- This applies whatever the name of the levy. Section 277(4) says it includes such payment irrespective of any right arising from it.
- Unlisted or thinly traded securities held as inventory
- Value = actual cost initially recognised
- No write-down to net realisable value under section 277(1)(iii).
- Other securities held as inventory
- Value = lower of actual cost and net realisable value, category-wise
- Section 277(1)(iv) and (3).
- Effect of closing stock error on profit
- Higher closing stock → higher profit; lower closing stock → lower profit
- Use this to decide whether to add or deduct when ICDS value differs from book value.
Quick revision
- Section 276(1): income from business or other sources follows the cash or mercantile system regularly employed.
- Section 276(2): the Central Government notifies ICDS for any class of assessee or income.
- Section 276(3): the Assessing Officer can assess under section 271 if accounts are doubtful, the method is not regularly followed, or ICDS are not applied.
- Inventory is valued at lower of actual cost or net realisable value under section 277(1)(i).
- Taxes, duties, cess and fees paid to bring goods to their location and condition are included in valuation.
- Unlisted or irregularly quoted securities held as inventory are valued at actual cost initially recognised.
- Other securities are valued at lower of cost or NRV, compared category-wise.
- Section 57: construction and service contracts use percentage of completion, subject to exceptions.
- Service contracts of not more than ninety days use project completion; indeterminate acts over a period use straight line.
- Contract revenue includes retention money, and contract costs are not reduced by interest, dividends or capital gains.
- Section 43 covers forex gains and losses on monetary and non-monetary items, forward contracts, translation and reserves.
Common mistakes
- Applying ICDS to salary, house property or capital gains. Fix: Remember that section 276(1) covers only business or profession and other sources.
- Saying an assessee may freely switch between cash and mercantile every year. Fix: The method must be regularly employed. Irregular following is a ground under section 276(3)(b).
- Deducting income from temporary investment of the loan from the interest capitalised. Fix: Under ICDS IX, capitalise the actual interest. Treat the investment income as income from other sources.
- Stopping capitalisation when the asset is ready for use, or pausing it during delays. Fix: Stop on the date the asset is first put to use. Do not suspend for breaks in activity.
- Excluding duty or tax from cost because credit is available. Fix: Section 277(4) includes such payment irrespective of any right arising. Add it to cost for this section.
- Applying lower of cost and NRV to securities that are unlisted or not quoted regularly. Fix: Securities held as inventory that are not listed, or are listed but not quoted with regularity, are valued at actual cost initially recognised (section 277(1)(iii)).
- Excluding retention money from contract revenue Fix: Section 57(3)(a) says contract revenue includes retention money. Include it in full.
- Reducing contract cost by interest or dividend earned on advances Fix: Section 57(3)(b) bars this. Show such income separately under its own head.
- Taking an exchange loss on an imported machine straight to the profit and loss account. Fix: Remember section 42 applies first. For imported business assets the variation on payment is added to or deducted from the cost of the asset.
- Using the year-end rate in the section 42 calculation. Fix: Section 42 compares the rate at the time of payment with the rate at the time of acquisition. The year-end rate is not used.
Exam tips
- Quote section 276(1), (2) and (3) by sub-section; examiners reward exact references.
- Learn the three section 276(3) grounds as alternatives and apply them to the case facts.
- In MCQs, watch for traps such as 'all heads of income' or 'issued by ICAI'.
- When asked to differentiate ICDS and accounting standards, give purpose, issuing authority, scope of heads and the effect of conflict.
- Link the framework to section 277 and section 57 when a question mixes inventory or contracts.
- In MCQs, the usual traps are the 12-month rule, not netting investment income, and cessation on first put to use. Check these three first.
- For comparison questions with AS 16, write the difference point by point: qualifying asset test, investment income, cessation and suspension.
- Show A, B and C separately in the general borrowing formula. Even if the final number is wrong, you keep method marks.