CMA Final · Indirect Tax Laws and Practice
Duty Drawback: formula sheet
Key formulas
- Section 74 drawback rate
- Drawback = 98% × duty paid on importation
- Applies to easily identifiable goods, subject to the Act's other provisions. Used goods get a different rate under Section 74(2).
- Section 74 conditions
- Goods identified to the officer's satisfaction + entered for export within 2 years from date of payment of duty
- The Board may extend the 2 years on sufficient cause shown.
- Used goods under Section 74(2)
- Rate = as notified by the Central Government
- Fixed having regard to duration of use, depreciation in value and other relevant circumstances.
- Section 75 base
- Drawback of customs duty on imported materials used in manufacture, processing or operation on exported goods
- Allowed only where the Central Government notifies it and subject to the drawback rules.
- Section 75 first proviso
- No drawback if export value < value of imported materials used, or not more than a notified % of that value
- Applies to goods the rules specify.
- Section 75 second proviso
- Sale proceeds not received within FEMA time → drawback deemed never allowed
- Exceptions apply as the Central Government specifies by rule.
- Date of entry for export
- Date used to calculate rate of duty under Section 16
- Section 74(4)(a). For provisional assessment under Section 18, the date of payment of provisional duty is treated as the date of payment of duty.
- Drawback on unused goods
- Drawback = 98% × customs duty paid on importation
- Applies only if both conditions in section 74(1) are met: identification and entry for export within two years.
- Time limit
- Entry for export ≤ 2 years from the date of payment of duty
- The Board may extend for a further period on sufficient cause shown (proviso to section 74(1)).
- Used goods
- Rate = as notified by the Central Government (section 74(2))
- Fixed having regard to duration of use, depreciation in value and other relevant circumstances. The Act gives no fixed percentage.
- Date of entry for export
- Date of entry for export = date used for rate of duty under section 16
- Section 74(4)(a). For provisional assessment under section 18, the date of payment of provisional duty is the date of payment of duty (section 74(4)(b)).
- Refund route for drawback
- Drawback under sections 74 and 75 is paid to the applicant (section 27(2) first proviso, clause (e))
- Section 27 does not make drawback go to the Fund; drawback is paid to the applicant.
- Drawback on unused goods (Section 74(1))
- Drawback = 98% × Customs duty paid on importation
- Applies only if goods are identified as the imported goods and entered for export within two years from the date of payment of duty (extendable by the Board).
- Drawback on used goods (Section 74(2))
- Drawback = Notified rate (%) × Customs duty paid on importation
- The rate is fixed by Central Government notification, based on duration of use, depreciation and other circumstances. Use the rate given in the question.
- Time limit for entry for export
- Entry for export ≤ 2 years from date of payment of duty
- The Board may extend the period on sufficient cause. Provisional assessment: date of payment of provisional duty counts.
- Interest on delayed drawback (Section 75A(1))
- Interest at section 27A rate, from the day after one month from the claim date until payment
- Payable in addition to the drawback if it is not paid within one month of filing the claim.
- Drawback on unused re-exported goods
- Drawback = 98% × import duty paid
- Section 74(1). Applies only if the goods are identified and entered for export within two years of payment of duty.
- Time limit
- Entry for export ≤ 2 years from date of payment of duty
- Board may extend on sufficient cause shown (proviso to Section 74(1)).
- Used goods
- Drawback = rate notified by Central Government under Section 74(2)
- Rate depends on duration of use, depreciation in value and other relevant circumstances. No fixed percentage in the Act.
- Deemed date of entry for export
- Date used for rate of duty under Section 16
- Section 74(4)(a).
- Provisional assessment
- Date of payment of provisional duty = date of payment of duty
- Section 74(4)(b), for goods assessed provisionally under Section 18. The two-year period runs from this date.
- Confiscation link
- Export under drawback claim without import duty paid = liable to confiscation
- Section 113(j).
Quick revision
- Section 74 applies to imported goods, capable of being easily identified, on which duty was paid on importation, when they are exported.
- Under Section 74(1), 98% of the duty is repaid as drawback, subject to the conditions.
- The goods must be identified to the satisfaction of the Assistant Commissioner or Deputy Commissioner of Customs as the goods that were imported.
- The goods must be entered for export within two years from the date of payment of duty.
- The Board can extend the two-year period on sufficient cause being shown.
- For used goods, the rate under Section 74(2) is fixed by Central Government notification, considering duration of use, depreciation and other circumstances.
- Goods are deemed entered for export on the date used to compute the rate of duty under Section 16.
- For provisional assessment, the date of payment of provisional duty is treated as the date of payment of duty.
- Section 75 covers imported materials used in manufacture, processing or any operation on goods that are then exported, through notification and rules.
- Section 75 drawback can equal the duty actually paid on the materials or an average amount fixed in the rules.
- Under Section 75A(1), interest is payable if drawback is not paid within one month of filing the claim.
- Under Section 75A(2), erroneously paid drawback must be repaid with interest within two months of demand.
Common mistakes
- Applying Section 74 to goods that were manufactured in India using imported inputs. Fix: Section 74 needs the imported goods themselves to be exported and identified. Manufactured goods go under Section 75.
- Allowing 98% drawback on used goods. Fix: For goods used after import, the rate is what the Central Government notifies, considering duration of use and depreciation.
- Giving 100% of duty as drawback on unused goods. Fix: Remember the Act repays ninety-eight per cent of the duty.
- Treating the two-year limit as fixed with no extension. Fix: State that the Board may extend the period on sufficient cause being shown.
- Applying 98% to goods that have been used. Fix: 98% is for Section 74(1). Used goods fall under Section 74(2), where the Central Government notifies the rate.
- Calculating drawback on the value of goods instead of duty paid. Fix: The base is always the customs duty actually paid on importation.
- Giving 100% of duty as drawback on unused re-exported goods. Fix: Remember that Section 74(1) repays ninety-eight per cent of the duty.
- Counting the two years from the date of import or arrival. Fix: The Act counts from the date of payment of duty. For provisional assessment, it is the date of payment of the provisional duty.
Exam tips
- Open any classification answer with one line: same goods or manufactured goods. Then name the section.
- Memorise three Section 74 numbers: 98%, two years, and the Board's power to extend.
- In MCQs, watch for the word used. It points to Section 74(2) and a notified rate.
- For a theory question on types, write Section 74, Section 75, then AIR and Brand Rate as forms under Section 75.
- Mention the FEMA realisation condition. It earns marks in Section 75 case answers.
- Quote the three conditions: duty paid, easily identifiable and identified, entry for export within two years.
- Write 98% and the words of sub-section (2) for used goods; do not invent a percentage for used goods.
- In date problems, write the two-year end date first, then compare.