CS Executive · Capital Market and Securities Laws
Delisting of Equity Shares: formula sheet
Key formulas
- SCRA Section 21A(1): power to delist
- Recognised stock exchange may delist securities, after recording reasons, on prescribed grounds
- Proviso: no delisting unless the company has been given a reasonable opportunity of being heard.
- SCRA Section 21A(2): appeal
- Appeal to Securities Appellate Tribunal within 15 days of the exchange's decision
- Can be filed by the listed company or an aggrieved investor. SAT may allow a further period not exceeding one month if sufficient cause prevented filing in time.
- SEBI Act Section 12A: prohibitions
- No person shall, directly or indirectly, use manipulative or deceptive devices, defraud, engage in insider trading, deal while in possession of material or non-public information, or acquire control beyond the permitted limit
- Applies to securities listed or proposed to be listed on a recognised stock exchange. Clauses (a) to (f).
- SCRA Section 12A: SEBI directions
- After inquiry, if satisfied it is necessary, SEBI may issue directions in the interest of investors or orderly development of the securities market
- Can include disgorgement of wrongful gain made or loss averted. Note this is Section 12A of the SCRA, not of the SEBI Act.
- SCRA Section 31: regulations
- SEBI may by notification make regulations consistent with the Act and its rules to carry out its purposes
- Regulations must be laid before Parliament.
- Shareholder approval
- Public shareholders' votes in favour ≥ 2 × public shareholders' votes against
- Special resolution through postal ballot and e-voting. The two-times test applies to votes cast by public shareholders.
- Success threshold
- (Promoter and acquirer holding + shares accepted in offer) ÷ Total share capital × 100 ≥ 90
- Total share capital as per the regulations. Both the 90% test and the minimum public participation test must be met.
- Shares needed to reach 90%
- Shares required = 90% × Total shares − Existing promoter and acquirer shares
- Use this first in numerical questions. It tells you how many shares must be tendered.
- Discovered price (reverse book building)
- Lowest bid price at which cumulative shares tendered (from the lowest bid upward) ≥ shares required
- Sellers accept any price at or above their bid, so add up bids from the lowest price upward.
- Consideration payable
- Exit price × Number of shares accepted
- The acquirer pays the exit price to all who tendered at or below it.
- Penalty for breach of delisting conditions (SCRA s. 23E)
- Not less than ₹5,00,000; may extend to ₹25,00,00,000
- Applies to a company that fails to comply with listing or delisting conditions or grounds.
- Power to delist (section 21A(1), SCRA)
- Recognised stock exchange + recorded reasons + prescribed ground = delisting
- The grounds are prescribed, not listed in section 21A. Reasons must be recorded.
- Hearing safeguard (proviso to section 21A(1))
- No delisting without a reasonable opportunity of being heard
- Applies to the company concerned. Failure to hear makes the decision open to challenge.
- Appeal period (section 21A(2))
- Appeal to SAT within 15 days of the decision
- The proviso lets SAT allow the company, if prevented by sufficient cause, to file within a further period not exceeding one month.
- Who can appeal (section 21A(2))
- Listed company or aggrieved investor
- Both can appeal, not only the company.
- Procedure for appeals
- Sections 22B to 22E of SCRA apply as far as may be
- These sections govern the appeal procedure before SAT.
- Relisting bar after voluntary delisting
- Earliest relisting = date of delisting + 5 years
- Relisting is through a fresh public issue as per the SEBI issue rules. Confirm the exact regulation text in your study material.
- Relisting bar after compulsory delisting
- Earliest relisting = date of delisting + 10 years
- Compulsory delisting carries the longer bar.
- Section 15H penalty
- Minimum ₹10 lakh; maximum = higher of ₹25 crore and 3 × profits made from the failure
- Covers failure to disclose holdings, make a public announcement, make a public offer, or pay consideration.
- Section 15HA penalty
- Minimum ₹5 lakh; maximum = higher of ₹25 crore and 3 × profits made from the practice
- For fraudulent and unfair trade practices relating to securities.
- Section 23E SCRA penalty
- Minimum ₹5 lakh; maximum ₹25 crore
- For breach of listing or delisting conditions. No profit-based limb.
- Section 21A appeal
- Appeal to SAT within 15 days; further period up to 1 month if sufficient cause
- Delisting needs recorded reasons and a reasonable opportunity of being heard first.
Quick revision
- Delisting is the permanent removal of a company's securities from a recognised stock exchange.
- The two routes are voluntary delisting and compulsory delisting.
- Voluntary delisting is initiated by the promoter or acquirer through an exit offer to public shareholders.
- Compulsory delisting is ordered by the stock exchange for non-compliance.
- SEBI may specify listing requirements and the transfer of securities under section 11A(2) of the SEBI Act.
- Section 12A of the SEBI Act prohibits manipulative and deceptive devices and insider trading in listed securities.
- Section 15H of the SEBI Act is a takeover provision: it penalises non-disclosure of acquisition of shares and takeovers.
- Section 15H applies where a person fails to disclose aggregate shareholding before acquiring shares, make a public announcement at a minimum price, make a public offer by letter of offer, or pay consideration to shareholders who sold under the offer.
- The section 15H penalty is at least ten lakh rupees, up to twenty-five crore rupees or three times the profit, whichever is higher.
- Do not present section 15H as the delisting penalty. Delisting-specific consequences come from the SEBI delisting regulations and the general penalty provisions.
- Always state the process in order: approval, offer, price discovery, outcome.
- Check the latest SEBI delisting regulations for exact numbers before the exam.
- End every answer with a conclusion that applies the rule to the facts.
Common mistakes
- Mixing up Section 12A of the SEBI Act with Section 12A of the SCRA. Fix: Remember: SEBI Act 12A is the prohibition on manipulative devices and insider trading. SCRA 12A is SEBI's power to issue directions.
- Saying the company can be delisted without a hearing. Fix: Always mention the reasonable opportunity of being heard and that reasons must be recorded.
- Adding bids from the highest price downward Fix: In reverse book building sellers name their minimum price. Accumulate from the lowest price upward and stop when the shares needed are reached.
- Treating 90% as 90% of public shares Fix: The 90% is of the total share capital, counting the promoter and acquirer's existing holding plus the shares accepted.
- Saying the grounds for delisting are listed in section 21A. Fix: Write that section 21A allows delisting on grounds prescribed under the Act. Name grounds only as examples from your study material.
- Forgetting the hearing requirement. Fix: Always add: no delisting without a reasonable opportunity of being heard.
- Mixing up the 5-year and 10-year relisting bars. Fix: Link 5 years to voluntary and 10 years to compulsory delisting. Compulsory is the stricter case, so the longer period.
- Stating the Section 15H maximum as only ₹25 crore. Fix: Always write: higher of ₹25 crore or three times the profits made from the failure. Compute both.
Exam tips
- Write the section number for every point, and name the Act. Examiners reward the provision-analysis-conclusion pattern.
- Keep Section 12A of the SEBI Act and Section 12A of the SCRA clearly separate in your answer.
- In short notes, give meaning, types, source of power and safeguards in that order.
- Do not quote regulation numbers or pricing figures unless you are certain; describe the rule in plain words instead.
- Link this topic to the voluntary and compulsory delisting topics so your answer shows how the framework works in practice.
- Write the procedure as a numbered sequence. Examiners reward the right order: board, special resolution, exchange approval, public announcement, reverse book building.
- Always mention the two-times vote test for public shareholders. It is the point most often missed.
- In numerical questions, show the shares-needed line and the cumulative table. Marks go to method even if the arithmetic slips.