CS Executive · Capital Market and Securities Laws
Mutual Funds: formula sheet
Key formulas
- Three-tier structure
- Sponsor → Trust (Trustees) → Asset Management Company; Custodian holds securities
- Learn this order. The sponsor creates, trustees hold and supervise, the AMC manages, the custodian safekeeps.
- Legal form of a mutual fund
- Mutual fund = a trust, not a company
- Unitholders are beneficiaries of the trust. The AMC is a company, but the fund itself is the trust.
- Registration requirement (SEBI Act, section 12(1B))
- No person shall sponsor or carry on a venture capital fund or collective investment scheme, including mutual funds, without a SEBI certificate of registration
- Quote this when asked about the legal basis for registration.
- Penalty for AMC failure (SEBI Act, section 15E)
- Penalty not less than ₹1 lakh, up to ₹1 lakh per day of continuing failure, maximum ₹1 crore
- Applies where an AMC fails to comply with regulations restricting its activities.
- Penalty for running a mutual fund without registration (section 15D(a))
- Penalty not less than ₹1 lakh, up to ₹1 lakh per day, maximum ₹1 crore
- The same range applies to the other defaults listed in section 15D.
- Registration requirement
- Sponsor or carry on a mutual fund → certificate of registration from SEBI is compulsory (SEBI Act, s. 12(1B))
- Applies to sponsoring and to carrying on, including causing it to be done.
- Application
- Application in the manner and with the fees set by regulations (s. 12(2))
- Manner and fees are not fixed in the Act; they come from regulations.
- Suspension or cancellation
- SEBI order + reasonable opportunity of being heard (s. 12(3))
- No order without a hearing. This is a favourite point in answers.
- Penalty for carrying on without registration
- Not less than ₹1,00,000, may extend to ₹1,00,000 for each day of the default, maximum ₹1,00,00,000 (s. 15D(a))
- Use the text of the section as it stands; the same ceiling applies to the other defaults in s. 15D(b) to (f).
- Penalty for AMC
- Not less than ₹1,00,000, may extend to ₹1,00,000 for each day of failure, maximum ₹1,00,00,000 (s. 15E)
- Applies where an AMC fails to comply with regulations restricting its activities.
- Mutual fund and CIS
- Contributions in the nature of subscription to a mutual fund → not a CIS (s. 11AA(3)(viii))
- Keeps the two regimes separate.
- ULIP exclusion
- A unit linked insurance policy is not a collective investment scheme or mutual fund (Explanation to s. 12)
- Applies to instruments with an investment component alongside insurance.
- Net Asset Value per unit
- NAV = (Market value of investments + Other assets − Liabilities and accrued expenses) ÷ Number of units outstanding
- Use the same date for assets and units. Deduct expenses before dividing.
- Number of units allotted
- Units = Amount invested ÷ Applicable NAV (or issue price)
- Check whether any entry load or charge applies under the offer document, and use the price stated for the scheme.
- Open-ended vs close-ended
- Open-ended: no fixed maturity, continuous sale and repurchase. Close-ended: fixed tenure, exit via listing or maturity.
- State this contrast in every classification answer.
- Portfolio-based types
- Equity: mainly shares. Debt: mainly fixed income. Hybrid: mix of both.
- Classification follows the stated investment objective.
- SEBI Act section 11A power
- SEBI may specify disclosure by regulations and, by orders, prohibit or condition a prospectus, offer document or advertisement.
- Applies for protection of investors.
- Mutual fund and CIS
- Section 11AA(3)(viii): contributions in the nature of subscription to a mutual fund are not a collective investment scheme.
- Useful to separate mutual funds from CIS.
- Net Asset Value (NAV) per unit
- NAV = (Market value of scheme's investments + Other assets − Liabilities and accrued expenses) ÷ Number of units outstanding
- Use this for any numerical or conceptual NAV question. Always deduct liabilities and accrued expenses before dividing.
- Total Expense Ratio (TER)
- TER = (Total annual scheme expenses ÷ Average net assets of the scheme) × 100
- Expressed as a percentage per annum. Compare it with the permitted cap for the scheme type.
- Penalty under section 15D (defaults by mutual funds)
- Not less than ₹1,00,000, extending to ₹1,00,000 per day while the default continues, subject to a maximum of ₹1,00,00,000
- Applies to running a mutual fund without registration, breaching registration conditions, failing to list, despatch unit certificates, refund application money or invest money as the regulations require.
- Penalty under section 15E (AMC restrictions)
- Not less than ₹1,00,000, extending to ₹1,00,000 per day while the failure continues, subject to a maximum of ₹1,00,00,000
- Applies where an AMC fails to comply with regulations restricting its activities.
- Registration requirement (section 12(1B))
- No person shall sponsor or carry on a mutual fund or collective investment scheme without a certificate of registration from SEBI
- The base rule behind many penalty questions.
- Penalty under section 15D (all clauses)
- Penalty ≥ ₹1,00,000; may extend to ₹1,00,000 per day of default; maximum ₹1,00,00,000
- The same range applies to each of clauses (a) to (f). It is a range, not a fixed amount. The authority decides the amount within it.
- Defaults under section 15D
- (a) no registration; (b) breach of registration terms; (c) no listing application; (d) no despatch of unit certificates; (e) no refund of application money; (f) no investment as specified
- Remember the six as: register, comply, list, despatch, refund, invest.
- Section 15E: asset management company
- Breach of regulations restricting AMC activities: ≥ ₹1,00,000; up to ₹1,00,000 per day; maximum ₹1,00,00,000
- Applies to an asset management company of a registered mutual fund, not to the fund as such.
- Section 12(3) and section 15JA
- SEBI may suspend or cancel registration after a hearing; penalties go to the Consolidated Fund of India
- A hearing is mandatory before suspension or cancellation.
Quick revision
- A mutual fund pools investors' money and invests it in securities through a registered structure.
- Constituents: sponsor, trust and trustees, asset management company, custodian and investors.
- Section 12(1B) of the SEBI Act: no person may sponsor or carry on a mutual fund without a SEBI certificate of registration.
- Under Section 12(3), SEBI may suspend or cancel registration, but only after giving the person a reasonable opportunity of being heard.
- Section 11AA(3)(viii): contributions that are subscriptions to a mutual fund are not a collective investment scheme under that section.
- Section 15D lists defaults by mutual funds: no registration, breach of registration terms, no listing application, no dispatch of unit certificates, no refund of application money, and wrong investment of money.
- Section 15D and Section 15E penalty: not less than ₹1,00,000 but up to ₹1,00,000 per day of default, subject to a maximum of ₹1,00,00,000.
- Section 15E applies when an asset management company breaches regulations restricting its activities.
- Section 15JA: penalties realised under the Act are credited to the Consolidated Fund of India.
- Written answers: state the provision, apply it to the facts, then give a clear conclusion.
Common mistakes
- Saying a mutual fund is a company Fix: Write that the fund is a trust and the AMC is only its manager, appointed to run the schemes.
- Treating sponsor and trustee as the same Fix: The sponsor sets up the fund and settles the trust. The trustees hold the trust property for unitholders and supervise. Different roles, different persons.
- Saying a mutual fund is a collective investment scheme. Fix: Quote s. 11AA(3)(viii): a subscription to a mutual fund is excluded from CIS. Mutual funds are governed by their own regulations.
- Saying SEBI can cancel registration straight away. Fix: Always add the proviso to s. 12(3): no order without a reasonable opportunity of being heard.
- Saying close-ended units can be redeemed any time at NAV. Fix: Remember close-ended means fixed tenure; exit is through listing or at maturity.
- Forgetting to deduct liabilities and expenses when computing NAV. Fix: Always compute net assets first: assets minus liabilities, then divide.
- Quoting exact percentage limits from memory and getting them wrong Fix: Revise limits from the latest study material. If unsure, state the principle clearly rather than a wrong figure.
- Forgetting to deduct liabilities when computing NAV Fix: Always write the full NAV formula and subtract liabilities and accrued expenses first.
- Treating the penalty as a fixed ₹1 lakh per day. Fix: Write it as a range: at least ₹1 lakh, up to ₹1 lakh per day, capped at ₹1 crore.
- Ignoring the ₹1 crore maximum when many days are given. Fix: Always compare the product with ₹1 crore and state the lower figure as the upper limit.
Exam tips
- Begin every answer with the definition and the trust form. Examiners look for it.
- Draw a small flow of sponsor, trust, AMC and custodian. It makes the answer clear and quick to read.
- For a distinction question, write role, function and relationship to unitholders for sponsor and trustee side by side in sentences.
- Cite section 12(1B) for registration and sections 15D and 15E for penalties, with the exact amounts and cap.
- Always finish with a short conclusion that answers the question asked.
- Begin every answer with section 12(1B) of the SEBI Act; it earns the provision marks.
- Draw the three-tier structure in one line: sponsor, trustees, AMC.
- Use the current penalty figures of s. 15D and s. 15E, not older ones.