CS Executive · Company Law and Practice
Memorandum and Articles of Association and its Alteration: formula sheet
Key formulas
- Name clause (Section 4(1)(a))
- Public company: last word "Limited". Private company: last words "Private Limited".
- This does not apply to a company registered under Section 8.
- Registered office clause (Section 4(1)(b))
- State in which the registered office is to be situated
- Only the State is stated in the memorandum, not the full address.
- Objects clause (Section 4(1)(c))
- Objects for which the company is proposed to be incorporated + any matter considered necessary in furtherance thereof
- This decides what the company may lawfully do.
- Liability clause (Section 4(1)(d))
- Shares: liability limited to the amount unpaid, if any, on shares held. Guarantee: the amount each member undertakes to contribute.
- A guarantee company's amount applies in winding up, while he is a member or within one year after he ceases to be one. It also covers winding-up costs and adjustment among contributories.
- Capital clause (Section 4(1)(e))
- Share capital amount + division into shares of fixed amount + number of shares each subscriber takes (at least one share)
- Applies only to a company having a share capital.
- OPC clause (Section 4(1)(f))
- Name of the person who becomes member on the death of the subscriber
- Applies only to a One Person Company.
- Name restrictions (Section 4(2) and (3))
- No name identical with or too nearly resembling an existing company's name; no name implying Government connection or patronage, unless prescribed approval is obtained
- Also barred: a name whose use is an offence under any law or is undesirable in the Central Government's opinion.
- Name reservation (Section 4(4) and (5))
- Reserved for 20 days, or 60 days for an existing company applying or changing its name, or such other prescribed period
- The 60-day period is stated in the proviso to Section 4(5)(i).
- Ultra vires act
- Act beyond objects in the memorandum → void, cannot be ratified, not enforceable
- Not even a unanimous vote of members can validate it.
- Intra vires but irregular act
- Within objects but beyond directors' authority or procedure → can be ratified by members
- Ratify through the procedure the articles or the Act require.
- Constructive notice
- Outsider is deemed to know the memorandum and articles, which are public documents
- It covers the content of public documents, not the internal working of the company.
- Doctrine of indoor management
- Outsider dealing in good faith may presume internal formalities were complied with
- It protects the outsider and acts as a limit on constructive notice.
- Exceptions to indoor management
- No protection where: (1) outsider had actual knowledge of the irregularity; (2) outsider was put on inquiry by suspicious circumstances; (3) the document is forged; (4) the act is beyond the public documents themselves
- A forged document is void, so there is nothing to presume. Dealing as an insider, such as a director, also weakens the protection.
- Link between the two doctrines
- Constructive notice: check the public documents. Indoor management: do not check internal procedure.
- Use this one-line contrast in the difference questions.
- General power to alter
- Alteration of memorandum = special resolution + compliance with section 13 procedure (section 13(1))
- Subject to section 61, which governs alteration of share capital.
- Change of name
- Name change = special resolution + written Central Government approval; effective only on fresh certificate of incorporation (section 13(2), (3))
- No approval is needed if the only change is deleting or adding the word "Private" on conversion of one class of company to another.
- Shifting registered office to another State
- Shift between States = special resolution + Central Government approval; application disposed of within 60 days (section 13(4), (5))
- The Central Government may check consent of creditors, debenture-holders and others, or that debts are provided for or secured.
- Filing with Registrar
- File special resolution (and Central Government approval if name changes) with the Registrar (section 13(6))
- Opens with "Save as provided in section 64", which deals with notice of alteration of share capital.
- Effect of shifting office
- Certified copy of Central Government order filed with the Registrar of each State; the new State's Registrar issues a fresh certificate (section 13(7))
- The time and manner are as prescribed.
- Change of objects after prospectus money
- Special resolution + newspaper publication (English and vernacular) + website + exit opportunity for dissenters (section 13(8))
- Applies only while some money raised by prospectus is unutilised.
- Registration of objects alteration
- Registrar registers and certifies within 30 days of filing the special resolution (section 13(9))
- Applies to alteration of objects.
- Effectiveness
- No alteration has effect until registered (section 13(10))
- Use this as the closing line in conclusions.
- Guarantee company bar
- In a company limited by guarantee without share capital, an alteration giving anyone a right to share divisible profits otherwise than as a member is void (section 13(11))
- A short fact often asked in one-line questions.
- Meaning of articles
- Articles = regulations for management of the company (Section 5(1))
- They also contain prescribed matters. A company may add extra matters it considers necessary (Section 5(2) proviso).
- Prescribed forms
- Articles must follow Tables F, G, H, I and J of Schedule I, as applicable (Section 5(6))
- Table F is the model for a company limited by shares. A company may adopt all or any of the model regulations (Section 5(7)).
- Default model articles
- Model regulations apply if registered articles do not exclude or modify them (Section 5(8))
- Applies to companies registered after the commencement of the Act, so far as applicable.
- Binding effect
- Registered articles bind company and members as if signed by each and containing covenants (Section 10(1))
- Subject to the provisions of the Act.
- Money due from member
- Sum payable by a member under the articles = debt due to the company (Section 10(2))
- Useful for calls on shares and similar dues.
- Entrenchment
- Stricter than special resolution to alter specified articles (Section 5(3)); adopted by unanimity of members (private) or special resolution (public) (Section 5(4))
- Notice to the Registrar is required (Section 5(5)).
- Producer Company articles
- Producer Company articles contain mutual assistance principles (Section 378G(2))
- Examples: voluntary membership, one member one vote, limited return on share capital, equitable distribution of surplus.
- Power to alter articles
- Special resolution + subject to the Act and the memorandum
- Section 14(1). The articles cannot be altered to contradict the Act or the memorandum.
- Private to public
- Alteration removing the private-company restrictions → company ceases to be private from the date of alteration
- First proviso to Section 14(1). The special resolution is the step that does this.
- Public to private
- Special resolution + order of the Central Government approving the alteration
- Second proviso to Section 14(1). Without the order, the alteration is not valid.
- Filing with the Registrar
- Within 15 days: the alteration, the copy of the Central Government order (where required) and a printed copy of the altered articles
- Section 14(2). The Registrar registers the alteration.
- Effect of registration
- Registered alteration is valid as if originally in the articles
- Section 14(3), subject to the provisions of the Act.
- Baseline power to alter articles
- Alteration of articles = special resolution (Section 14(1)), subject to the Act and the memorandum
- Entrenchment sets a stricter standard for named articles only.
- Entrenchment provision
- Specified articles can be altered only on conditions or procedures more restrictive than a special resolution
- It is optional. The articles may contain it.
- Time limit for filing altered articles
- Every alteration of articles is filed with the Registrar within 15 days, in the prescribed manner (Section 14(2))
- Learn the separate entrenchment adoption steps from the study material. Do not mix them with this 15-day filing rule.
- Filing of altered articles (Section 14(2))
- Filing with Registrar within 15 days, with a printed copy of the altered articles (and the Central Government order where public is converted to private)
- The Registrar registers it. After registration it is valid as if originally in the articles (Section 14(3)).
- Public to private conversion (Section 14(1), second proviso)
- Alteration is not valid unless approved by an order of the Central Government
- A special resolution alone is not enough.
- Noting alterations (Section 15(1))
- Every alteration is noted in every copy of the memorandum or articles
- Applies to both documents.
- Penalty (Section 15(2))
- ₹1,000 × number of copies issued without the alteration
- Company and every officer in default are liable.
- Memorandum alteration filings (Section 13)
- File the special resolution with the Registrar; the alteration has no effect until registered (Section 13(10))
- A name change also needs the Central Government's written approval and a fresh certificate of incorporation.
Quick revision
- Articles contain the regulations for management of the company (section 5(1)).
- A company may adopt all or any of the model articles; where registered articles do not exclude them, model article regulations apply so far as applicable.
- Memorandum is altered by special resolution and the procedure in section 13, save as provided in section 61.
- A change of name needs written Central Government approval, except where only the word 'Private' is added or deleted on conversion.
- Name change takes effect only when the Registrar issues a fresh certificate of incorporation.
- Shifting the registered office from one State to another needs Central Government approval, which is to be disposed of within sixty days.
- If money raised through prospectus is unutilised, a change of objects needs a special resolution, newspaper publication and an exit opportunity for dissenting shareholders.
- The Registrar registers an alteration of objects and certifies it within thirty days of filing the special resolution; no alteration has effect until registered.
- Articles are altered by special resolution, subject to the Act and the memorandum conditions.
- Converting a public company into a private company is not valid without Central Government approval.
- Alteration of articles must be filed with the Registrar within fifteen days with a printed copy of the altered articles.
- Entrenchment: on formation, or by amendment agreed by all members in a private company and by special resolution in a public company; notice goes to the Registrar.
- Section 15 penalty: ₹1,000 for every copy issued without the alteration noted; share capital alteration notice under section 64 is due within thirty days.
Common mistakes
- Saying the memorandum must state the full address of the registered office. Fix: Section 4(1)(b) requires only the State to be stated. Write 'the State in which the registered office is to be situated'.
- Stating that every company must have the word 'Limited' or 'Private Limited' in its name. Fix: Add that the requirement does not apply to a company registered under Section 8.
- Saying members can ratify an ultra vires act by a special resolution. Fix: Remember that ultra vires the memorandum means no capacity, so the act is void. Only an alteration of the objects, done properly beforehand, can change the position going forward.
- Treating constructive notice and indoor management as the same thing. Fix: Constructive notice binds the outsider to public documents. Indoor management lets the outsider ignore internal irregularities. They work in opposite directions.
- Saying the Central Government must approve every alteration of the memorandum. Fix: Approval is needed for a name change and for shifting the registered office between States. Other changes need a special resolution and filing, with extra steps only in the cases section 13 names.
- Treating a change of name as effective on passing the resolution. Fix: Under section 13(3) the change is complete only when the Registrar issues a fresh certificate of incorporation with the new name.
- Saying articles are optional and a company can function without them. Fix: Every company has articles, either its own or the model regulations that apply under Section 5(8) when its registered articles do not exclude them.
- Saying the articles override the Act. Fix: Section 10(1) begins with 'Subject to the provisions of this Act'. Articles cannot contradict the Act.
- Saying an ordinary resolution is enough to alter the articles. Fix: Remember that Section 14(1) requires a special resolution.
- Writing that the Tribunal approves conversion of a public company into a private company. Fix: Under the present text of the second proviso, the order of the Central Government is needed. Without it the alteration is not valid.
Exam tips
- Learn the clause list as Name, State, Objects, Liability, Capital, plus OPC. Examiners often ask you to 'state the contents of the memorandum' in two or three marks.
- Always cite Section 4(1) and, where you are sure, the sub-clause letter. Marks go to the provision first.
- For name problems, test the name against Section 4(2) and 4(3) in turn, then give a clear yes or no conclusion.
- Write the differences for each company type. Section 8, guarantee and OPC variations are favourite short-note points.
- If a question mentions a prospectus advertisement, bring in Section 30.
- Start every answer with the rule in one line, then apply it to the facts, then conclude. This is the ICSI answer style.
- In a case question, first decide whether the act is beyond the memorandum or only beyond the articles or authority. Marks depend on this split.
- Always list the exceptions to indoor management. Examiners usually reward each exception you name and apply.