CS Executive · Setting Up of Business, Industrial and Labour Laws
Conversion of Business Entities: formula sheet
Key formulas
- Conversion of companies already registered
- Section 18(1): a company of any class may convert to a company of another class by altering its memorandum and articles
- Applies only to companies already registered under the Act. The Registrar closes the former registration and issues a certificate of incorporation as in first registration (s 18(2)).
- Effect on past liabilities
- Section 18(3): conversion does not affect debts, liabilities, obligations or contracts incurred before conversion
- They remain enforceable as if no conversion had taken place.
- Private company to LLP
- LLP Act, 2008, section 56 read with the Third Schedule
- Available to a private company.
- Unlisted public company to LLP
- LLP Act, 2008, section 57 read with the Fourth Schedule
- Available only to an unlisted public company, not a listed one.
- Obligations of an entity registering as a company (section 374)
- (a) secured creditors' consent or no objection; (b) newspaper notice, one English and one vernacular; (c) notarised affidavit from all members or partners on filing papers for dissolution of the earlier entity; (d) other prescribed conditions
- Proviso: on registration as a company, an LLP is deemed dissolved under the LLP Act without any further act or deed.
- Who can convert
- Company of any class registered under the Act → company of other class under the Act
- Section 18(1). Conversion is by alteration of memorandum and articles as per Chapter II.
- Registrar's role
- Application → Registrar satisfied → closes former registration → registers documents → issues certificate of incorporation as on first registration
- Section 18(2). The Registrar acts on an application made by the company.
- Effect on past obligations
- Debts, liabilities, obligations, contracts before conversion remain enforceable as if no conversion
- Section 18(3). Conversion does not wipe out or change what the company owed or agreed earlier.
- Alteration of memorandum
- Special resolution + procedure under Section 13
- Section 13(1). The resolution is filed with the Registrar under Section 13(6)(a).
- Name change on conversion
- No Central Government approval if only "Private" is added or deleted
- Proviso to Section 13(2). Any other name change needs written approval.
- Effectiveness of alteration
- No effect until registered
- Section 13(10). Conversion is complete only on registration and the fresh certificate.
- Alteration of articles (Section 14(1))
- Special resolution → alter articles → private ⇄ public
- Subject to the Act and any conditions in the memorandum.
- Deemed ceasing to be private (Proviso to Section 14(1))
- Private-company restrictions removed from articles ⇒ company ceases to be private from the date of alteration
- The conversion takes effect by operation of law on that date.
- Public to private approval (Second proviso to Section 14(1))
- Alteration is not valid unless approved by order of the Central Government
- Application is in the prescribed form and manner. Private to public needs no such approval under Section 14.
- Filing with Registrar (Section 14(2))
- Within 15 days: alteration + copy of Central Government order (if any) + printed copy of altered articles
- The Registrar registers it. Once registered, it is valid as if originally in the articles (Section 14(3)).
- Name change on conversion (Section 13(2))
- Only adding or deleting "Private" ⇒ no Central Government approval needed
- Any other name change needs written approval. The proviso dispenses only with the approval. Do not assert that Section 13(3) governs the conversion name change.
- Alteration of memorandum (Section 13(1), (6), (10))
- Special resolution → file with Registrar → effective only on registration
- Filing of the special resolution is under Section 13(6)(a). No alteration has effect until registered.
- Unlimited to limited, reserve capital (Section 65)
- Resolution for registration as limited: increase nominal share amount and/or make part of uncalled capital callable only on winding up
- Either or both. The increase or portion is callable only in the event and for the purposes of winding up.
- Conversion by alteration (Section 18(1))
- Conversion = alteration of memorandum + alteration of articles + Registrar's registration
- A company of any class registered under the Act may convert itself into a company of another class.
- Alteration of memorandum (Section 13(1))
- Special resolution + compliance with Section 13 procedure
- Subject to section 61. An alteration has no effect until it is registered (Section 13(10)).
- Alteration of articles (Section 14(1))
- Special resolution, subject to the Act and the memorandum
- This includes alterations that convert a private company into a public company or the reverse.
- Private to public by dropping restrictions
- Articles no longer contain private company restrictions → company ceases to be private from the date of alteration
- This is the first proviso to Section 14(1).
- Public to private
- Special resolution + Central Government order approving the alteration
- Without the order, the alteration is not valid (second proviso to Section 14(1)).
- Name change on conversion (Section 13(2))
- No Central Government approval if the only change is deletion or addition of the word "Private" consequent on conversion of one class of company to another
- Any other name change needs written approval. It takes effect only on the fresh certificate (Section 13(3)).
- Filing of altered articles (Section 14(2))
- Within 15 days: alteration, copy of the Central Government order (where there is one), printed altered articles
- The Registrar registers them. Once registered, they are valid as if originally in the articles (Section 14(3)). The 15 days apply to this filing.
- Filing for memorandum (Section 13(6))
- File the special resolution; also the Central Government approval if the name changes
- Saves section 64. The text of section 13(6) states no time period for this filing.
- Registrar's action on conversion (Section 18(2))
- On the company's application: close former registration → register documents → issue certificate of incorporation as on first registration
- This is separate from the registration of altered articles under Section 14(2). The Registrar acts once satisfied that the Chapter's provisions are complied with.
- Effect on past liabilities (Section 18(3))
- Debts, liabilities, obligations and contracts are unaffected
- They are enforced as if no conversion had occurred.
- Who can register under Section 366
- Partnership firm, LLP, cooperative society, society or other business entity with two or more members may register as unlimited, limited by shares or limited by guarantee company
- Section 366(2). Cannot be used by a company already registered under the Companies Acts of 1882, 1913 or 1956.
- Minimum members rule
- Company with less than seven members shall register as a private company
- Section 366(2)(vii).
- Majority for assent
- Majority of members present in person or by proxy at a general meeting summoned for the purpose
- Section 366(2)(iv). Proxy counts only where proxies are allowed.
- Majority for limited company
- At least three-fourths of members present, if members' liability was not limited by any law and it registers as a limited company
- Section 366(2)(v). Poll votes count by each member's entitlement under the regulations (Section 366(3)).
- Guarantee company condition
- Assent plus a resolution that each member undertakes to contribute a specified amount on winding up
- Section 366(2)(vi). Contribution applies while a member or within one year after ceasing.
- Obligations before registration
- Secured creditor consent or no objection; newspaper notice (English and vernacular); notarised affidavit from all members or partners; other prescribed conditions
- Section 374(a) to (d).
- Effect of registration
- Earlier instrument treated as memorandum and articles; Act applies as if formed under it
- Section 371(2) and (3). Table F applies only if adopted by special resolution.
Quick revision
- Section 18 lets a company of one class convert into another class by altering its memorandum and articles.
- Under Section 18, the Registrar closes the former registration and issues a certificate of incorporation as on first registration.
- Conversion under Section 18 does not affect earlier debts, liabilities, obligations or contracts, which remain enforceable.
- Section 14 allows a private-public conversion by special resolution altering the articles.
- A private company that drops the required restrictions from its articles ceases to be private from the date of alteration.
- Converting a public company into a private company is not valid unless approved by an order of the Central Government.
- Every alteration of articles, with a printed copy of the altered articles, must be filed with the Registrar within fifteen days. Where the alteration converts a public company into a private one, a copy of the Central Government order is filed too.
- Under Section 366, a firm, LLP, society or other business entity can register as a company, but one registered under earlier Companies Acts cannot use that route.
- A company with fewer than seven members must register under Section 366 as a private company.
- Section 374 requires secured creditors' consent or no-objection, a newspaper notice in English and a vernacular language, and a notarised affidavit from all members or partners.
- Only a private company or an unlisted public company can convert into an LLP (Sections 56 and 57 of the LLP Act).
- On LLP conversion, property and liabilities vest in the LLP without further act or deed, and the company is deemed dissolved.
Common mistakes
- Saying a listed public company can convert into an LLP. Fix: Write 'unlisted public company' every time you cite section 57 and the Fourth Schedule.
- Treating conversion under section 18 as the same as registering a partnership firm as a company. Fix: Section 18 is for companies already registered under the Act. A firm or LLP becoming a company falls under the registration provisions, including section 374.
- Saying conversion creates a new company and the old one ends with its liabilities. Fix: Remember Section 18(3): only the registration is closed. Past debts, liabilities and contracts remain enforceable as if no conversion had occurred.
- Claiming Central Government approval is always needed for the name change on conversion. Fix: State the rule and the proviso. No approval is needed where the only change is adding or deleting the word "Private".
- Saying private to public needs Central Government approval under Section 14. Fix: Remember the second proviso applies only to public into private. Private to public needs only the special resolution and filing.
- Writing that the Tribunal approves public to private conversion. Fix: Write Central Government, as the current text of Section 14 states.
- Saying conversion needs only a board resolution. Fix: Write that the board approves and recommends, but the alteration of the memorandum and articles needs a special resolution of members.
- Claiming Central Government approval is needed for every conversion. Fix: Say approval is mandatory for public to private under Section 14. For private to public, only the usual alterations and filings apply, subject to the name rules.
- Saying a sole proprietor can register under Section 366 like a firm. Fix: Section 366(2) needs two or more members. A proprietor forms a new company under Chapter II and transfers the business to it.
- Writing that a three-fourths majority is always needed, or that a simple majority is enough for every type of company. Fix: The base rule under proviso (iv) is a majority of members present. If the firm registers as a limited company (by shares or by guarantee), proviso (v) raises it to at least three-fourths of members present, because the partners' liability is not limited by any law. For an unlimited company, the proviso (iv) majority applies.
Exam tips
- Always name the section and the Act with the route. Marks are given for the provision first, then application.
- For a 'listed or unlisted' fact pattern, check the status of the public company before choosing section 57.
- In case-study answers, end with a one-line conclusion such as 'the conversion is permissible' or 'the company cannot convert'.
- Learn the three routes as a list. Short notes on 'types of conversion' are easiest to score with this structure.
- Do not copy long text of the Act. Paraphrase the conditions in short points.
- Write the answer in ICSI style: provision first (Section 18), then facts, then a one-line conclusion.
- Always quote sub-section (3) when the question mentions creditors, contracts or pending liabilities.
- Link Section 18 with Section 13 in your answer. Examiners like the special resolution and the name proviso mentioned together.