FRM Part I · FRM Exam Part I
Exchanges and OTC Markets: formula sheet
Key formulas
- Exchange-traded profile
- Standardized + public prices + clearing house + daily margin
- Higher liquidity and transparency, lower counterparty risk, less flexibility.
- OTC profile
- Customized + bilateral + dealer-based + credit exposure unless cleared or collateralized
- Higher flexibility and closer hedge, lower liquidity and transparency.
- Counterparty exposure on an OTC trade
- Exposure = max(V, 0), where V is the mark-to-market value to you
- You lose only if the contract has positive value to you when the counterparty defaults. Collateral reduces it.
- Net exposure with a netting agreement
- Net exposure = max(ΣVi, 0)
- Compare with the gross sum of Σ max(Vi, 0) without netting. Netting never increases exposure.
- Daily margin balance
- New balance = Old balance + (Settlement price today − Settlement price yesterday) × Contract size × Number of contracts (long position)
- For a short position, the sign of the price change is reversed. Add any deposits, subtract any withdrawals.
- Margin call trigger
- Margin call if balance < maintenance margin; deposit = initial margin − balance
- The deposit restores the account to initial margin, not to maintenance.
- Bid-ask spread
- Spread = Ask − Bid; Half-spread cost = Spread ÷ 2
- A round trip (buy then sell at the same quotes) costs the full spread.
- Order trigger rules
- Buy limit: price ≤ limit. Sell limit: price ≥ limit. Sell stop: triggers when price ≤ stop. Buy stop: triggers when price ≥ stop.
- A triggered stop becomes a market order, so the fill can differ from the stop price.
- Position gain or loss
- P&L = (Exit price − Entry price) × Contract size × Contracts (long); reverse for short
- Total P&L equals the sum of daily margin flows.
- Novation result
- A ↔ B becomes A ↔ CCP ↔ B
- The CCP is the buyer to every seller and the seller to every buyer. Its net position is zero.
- Variation margin
- VM = change in mark-to-market value of the position since the last settlement
- Paid or received daily. The side with a loss pays. It is not a deposit that is returned.
- Multilateral netting
- Net exposure to CCP = Σ gains and losses across all trades with the CCP
- Netting works across all of a member's cleared trades in the same netting set, so the CCP exposure is lower than the sum of bilateral gross exposures.
- Initial margin purpose
- IM ≈ potential loss over the margin period of risk at a high confidence level
- Usually calculated with a VaR-type or scenario-based model. It rises when volatility rises.
- Default waterfall order (typical)
- Defaulter IM → defaulter default fund → CCP own capital → survivors' default fund → other loss-allocation tools
- State this as typical, not universal. The defaulter's own resources are always used first.
- Net exposure with close-out netting
- Net exposure = max(Σ Vi, 0)
- Sum the values of all trades in the netting set from your viewpoint, then floor at zero. Without netting: Σ max(Vi, 0).
- Netting benefit
- Benefit = Σ max(Vi, 0) − max(Σ Vi, 0)
- Always ≥ 0. It is zero when all trades have positive value or all are negative or zero.
- Collateral call (CSA)
- Required collateral = max(Net exposure − Threshold, 0) + Independent amount
- Compare with collateral already held. Make a transfer only if the difference is at least the MTA. Conventions on independent amounts vary, so follow the stem.
- Uncollateralised exposure after a call
- Residual exposure ≈ Net exposure − Collateral held × (1 − haircut)
- Non-cash collateral is valued after haircut. Add exposure change over the margin period of risk.
- Mandatory clearing
- Standardized OTC derivatives → cleared through a CCP
- Applies to standardized, sufficiently liquid products. Exemptions exist for some end users and non-financial firms below thresholds.
- Trade reporting
- All OTC derivative trades → reported to trade repositories
- Applies to both cleared and non-cleared trades. Its aim is regulator transparency, not risk reduction through collateral.
- Trading platform rule
- Cleared and eligible standardized swaps → traded on exchange or SEF (US)
- Dodd-Frank uses SEFs. EMIR refers to regulated markets and similar venues.
- Non-cleared margin rule
- Non-cleared trade → VM (daily) + IM (covers potential future exposure)
- BCBS-IOSCO framework. IM is segregated and is not rehypothecated, and posted and received IM are not netted.
- BCBS-IOSCO IM calibration
- IM ≈ potential loss over a 10-day margin period of risk at 99% confidence
- IM is calibrated to a period of significant financial stress. Models may be a regulatory schedule or an approved internal model.
- Margin threshold
- Bilateral IM threshold up to €50 million (or equivalent)
- Applies to the IM exchange between covered entities. Check the specific minimum transfer amounts in your reading.
- Notional versus risk
- Gross market value (absolute sum of positive and negative fair values) < Notional amount
- Notional is a scale for payments, not the amount at risk. Gross market value is the better proxy for replacement cost.
- Gross market value
- Gross market value = Σ |fair value of each contract|
- Positive and negative values are summed as absolute amounts, with no offsetting between counterparties.
- Net exposure to a counterparty
- Net exposure = max(Σ fair values under an enforceable netting agreement, 0)
- Netting applies only when legally enforceable. Collateral then reduces the exposure further.
- Gross market value ratio
- Gross market value ÷ Notional = relative size of replacement cost
- A small ratio shows that notional greatly overstates economic exposure.
Quick revision
- Exchange-traded contracts are standardized and cleared centrally; OTC contracts are customized and traditionally bilateral.
- A CCP becomes the buyer to every seller and the seller to every buyer, removing bilateral counterparty exposure between members.
- Variation margin settles daily gains and losses; initial margin covers potential loss while a defaulter is closed out.
- A margin call arises when the account falls below the maintenance level, and the investor must restore it to the initial margin level.
- CCP resources are used in layers: the defaulter's margin first, then the default fund, with further loss sharing among members.
- Netting lets the non-defaulting party combine positive and negative values across a netting set, so it owes or claims only the net amount.
- A CSA sets the terms for collateral: thresholds, minimum transfer amounts, eligible collateral and haircuts.
- Haircuts reduce the credited value of collateral to allow for price changes.
- Central clearing concentrates risk in the CCP, which makes the CCP systemically important.
- Post-crisis reforms push standardized OTC derivatives toward central clearing and trade reporting, and set higher requirements for uncleared trades.
- Uncleared bilateral trades face margin requirements to reduce risk and make clearing relatively more attractive.
- Securitization can spread and hide credit risk when structures are complex and opaque.
Common mistakes
- Saying OTC trades always carry more counterparty risk than exchange trades. Fix: Say OTC trades carry bilateral credit risk unless they are centrally cleared or collateralized.
- Assuming all derivatives like swaps are OTC and all like futures are exchange-traded with no exceptions. Fix: Treat the lists as typical. Some standardized swaps are cleared, and some options trade both ways.
- Thinking a stop order guarantees the stop price. Fix: A stop becomes a market order once triggered, so the fill can be worse in fast markets. Only a stop-limit caps the price.
- Placing a buy stop below the market or a sell stop above it. Fix: A sell stop sits below the current price and a buy stop above it. A buy limit sits below and a sell limit above.
- Treating initial margin and variation margin as the same thing. Fix: IM is a buffer against future losses after a default. VM settles gains and losses that have already occurred, daily.
- Thinking novation means the CCP guarantees nothing is lost. Fix: Novation moves credit risk to the CCP. The CCP still depends on margin, its capital and member contributions. It can fail.
- Adding only positive trade values when netting applies Fix: With enforceable close-out netting, sum all values including negatives, then floor the total at zero.
- Applying the threshold before netting Fix: Collateral is computed on the net exposure of the whole netting set. Net first, then subtract the threshold.
- Saying all OTC derivatives must be centrally cleared. Fix: Say that standardized, sufficiently liquid contracts are subject to clearing. Bespoke trades stay bilateral but face margin rules.
- Confusing trade reporting with clearing. Fix: Reporting goes to trade repositories and gives regulators information. Clearing goes to a CCP and transfers counterparty risk.
Exam tips
- Read for words like customized, standardized, cleared, collateralized and netted. They decide the answer.
- Be wary of options with always or never about counterparty risk.
- For exposure questions, set negative values to zero first, then apply netting only if the question says it is enforceable.
- Link the topic to central clearing and margining: questions often ask how those features change OTC risk.
- Expect numerical margin-call questions. Build a small table: day, price change, balance, call.
- Watch the direction of the position. Questions often switch between long and short.
- Know the trigger side for each order type. A common trap is placing a stop on the wrong side of the market.
- Remember that the call restores initial margin, and that a market maker earns the spread but bears inventory risk.