Skip to content

Performance Management · Divisional performance and transfer pricing

Transfer Pricing Objectives and Methods for ACCA PM

Updated 11 October 2026 · Fact-checked

A transfer price is the price at which one division sells goods or services to another division in the same group. Its aims are goal congruence, fair divisional performance measurement, autonomy and sensible group profit. Main methods are market price, full cost, marginal cost plus and negotiated prices. Compare each method against those aims.

Understand Transfer Pricing Objectives and Methods

A transfer price is an internal price. The selling division records it as revenue. The buying division records it as cost. It cancels out for the group as a whole, but it changes the profit shown for each division.

That is why it matters. If the price is set badly, managers may make choices that suit their own division but harm the group. The aims of a good transfer price are:

  • Goal congruence: divisional managers acting in their own interest also act in the group's interest.
  • Performance measurement: each division's profit is a fair guide to how well it has done.
  • Autonomy: divisional managers keep real freedom to decide.
  • Group profit: the group makes the best use of its resources, and in some cases pays less tax or handles exchange risks well.

No single method meets all the aims. Market price works well when there is a competitive external market for the product. It is objective and keeps divisions fair. It can be hard to use if the product is special or no market exists. Savings such as lower selling and packing costs on internal sales are often deducted.

Cost-based methods are used when no market price exists. Full cost (or full cost plus) includes a share of fixed overheads. It may make the buying division reject work that is worthwhile for the group. Marginal cost (or marginal cost plus) uses variable cost. It supports good group decisions but gives the selling division little or no profit unless a mark-up is added. The selling division may then lack motivation.

Negotiated prices are agreed by the two divisions. They suit situations with imperfect markets and respect autonomy. They can take time, cause conflict and depend on bargaining skill. Head office may have to step in if they cannot agree.

Key rules to remember

Minimum transfer price (general rule)
Minimum price = marginal cost of the selling division + opportunity cost to the group of making the transfer
Opportunity cost is the contribution lost on other uses of the resources. With spare capacity it is usually zero, so the minimum is marginal cost.
Maximum transfer price
Maximum price = lower of (net marginal revenue to the buying division) and (cost of buying externally)
Net marginal revenue is the buyer's selling price less its own further costs of processing.
Market price based transfer
Transfer price = external market price (less any savings on internal sales)
Suitable if the market is competitive and the divisions are autonomous.
Cost-plus transfer price
Transfer price = cost (full or marginal) + mark-up
The cost basis and the mark-up must be stated clearly.
Acceptable range
Minimum price ≤ transfer price ≤ maximum price
If minimum exceeds maximum, the transfer is not in the group's interest.

How to solve Transfer Pricing Objectives and Methods questions

Use this approach for any transfer pricing question, whether it is calculation or discussion.

  1. 1Identify the selling and buying divisions and the product being transferred.
  2. 2Check whether an external market exists, and whether the selling division has spare capacity or is at full capacity.
  3. 3Calculate the minimum price: marginal cost plus any opportunity cost to the group.
  4. 4Calculate the maximum price: the lower of net marginal revenue and the external purchase price.
  5. 5Compare the two. If minimum is above maximum, the transfer should not happen. Otherwise any price between them benefits the group.
  6. 6Test the proposed method against the aims: goal congruence, fair performance measurement and autonomy.
  7. 7Check the effect on each division's profit and on the group's profit.
  8. 8Conclude with a clear recommendation and mention any limits, such as tax or negotiation problems.

Quickest way: Min-max range check

When to use it: Use this for objective test questions asking for an acceptable or optimal transfer price, or whether a transfer should proceed.

  1. Write the selling division's marginal cost per unit.
  2. Add lost contribution per unit if capacity is limited, otherwise add nothing.
  3. Write the buying division's maximum: net marginal revenue or external price, whichever is lower.
  4. If the minimum is above the maximum, the answer is that no transfer should take place.
  5. If not, pick the answer lying inside the range and check it is not outside either limit.

Common mistakes in Transfer Pricing Objectives and Methods

  • Using full cost as the minimum price for the group

    Students see full cost as the true cost of the product.

    Fix: Fixed costs are usually unchanged by the transfer. Use marginal cost plus opportunity cost for the group decision.

  • Ignoring spare capacity

    Students apply one rule whatever the capacity position.

    Fix: Ask if the selling division is at full capacity. If it is, add the lost contribution from external sales. If not, add nothing.

  • Forgetting the buying division's own further costs when finding the maximum

    Students use the final selling price as the maximum.

    Fix: Deduct the buyer's further processing costs from its selling price to get net marginal revenue.

  • Saying a method is simply good or bad

    Students memorise methods without linking them to aims.

    Fix: Judge each method against goal congruence, performance measurement and autonomy, and say when it works.

  • Treating a transfer price as a group profit item

    Students forget it is an internal price that cancels in the group.

    Fix: Group profit changes only through real decisions, such as buying externally or losing external sales. The price moves profit between divisions.

Worked examples

Example 1

Division A makes a component with a variable cost of ₹40 per unit. It has spare capacity. Division B wants to buy it for a product that sells for ₹120, and B's other variable cost is ₹50 per unit. B cannot buy the component from any external supplier. Find the range of acceptable transfer prices.

Show the solution
  1. Minimum price: A has spare capacity, so opportunity cost is nil. Minimum = ₹40.
  2. Maximum price: net marginal revenue to B = ₹120 − ₹50 = ₹70.
  3. B cannot buy externally, so there is no external purchase price to act as a cap. The maximum is the net marginal revenue of ₹70.
  4. Range is ₹40 to ₹70.

Answer: Any transfer price from ₹40 to ₹70 per unit is acceptable to the group.

Exam tips

  • In calculations, always show the minimum and the maximum prices separately. Marks are given for each.
  • For discussion parts, link every method to goal congruence, performance measurement and autonomy.
  • Read the capacity information first. It decides whether opportunity cost is zero or not.
  • In Section B cases, check the units transferred. A range is per unit, so do not multiply by volume unless asked.
  • For negotiated prices, mention conflict, time cost and the possible need for head office to arbitrate.

Practice questions from Divisional performance and transfer pricing

Transfer Pricing Objectives and Methods in other exams

The same ground in other exams, if you are preparing for more than one or want another angle on it.

Transfer Pricing Objectives and Methods: frequently asked questions

What is goal congruence in transfer pricing?

It means divisional managers, by pursuing their own division's results, take decisions that also benefit the whole group. A transfer price promotes goal congruence if it never leads a manager to reject a transfer that would increase group profit. It is the main aim of a good transfer pricing system.

What is the difference between market-based and cost-based transfer pricing?

Market-based pricing uses the external price for the same or similar product. It is objective and supports fair performance measurement. Cost-based pricing uses the producing division's cost, with or without a mark-up, and is used when no market exists. It is easier to calculate but may give weaker incentives.

Why is marginal cost often the minimum transfer price?

When the selling division has spare capacity, making the transfer costs the group only the extra variable cost. Fixed costs are incurred anyway. So marginal cost is the least the selling division should accept without harming the group.

Why not always use full cost plus?

Full cost includes fixed overheads that do not change with the transfer. It can push the transfer price above the buyer's maximum, so a worthwhile transfer is rejected. It can also hide the selling division's inefficiencies.