Skip to content

CS Executive · Capital Market and Securities Laws

Prohibition of Insider Trading for CS Executive Paper 5

Insider trading means dealing in listed securities while in possession of unpublished price sensitive information (UPSI), or passing that information on. Section 12A of the SEBI Act, 1992 bars it, and the SEBI (Prohibition of Insider Trading) Regulations, 2015 set the detailed rules. You solve problems by testing: insider, UPSI, then trade or communication.

What this chapter covers

This chapter sits in Paper 5, Part II (Securities Laws). It deals with one wrong: using price-sensitive information that the public does not have to trade in listed securities, or leaking it to others. The source of the ban is the SEBI Act, 1992. Section 12A(d) says no person shall directly or indirectly engage in insider trading. Section 12A(e) bars dealing in securities while in possession of material or non-public information, or communicating such information to another person, in contravention of the Act, rules or regulations. The working rules are in the SEBI (Prohibition of Insider Trading) Regulations, 2015.

The chapter builds in layers. First the meaning and the legal framework. Then the key definitions: insider, UPSI and connected person. Then the two core prohibitions: communicating UPSI and trading while in possession of it. After that come the compliance tools for listed companies: disclosures, the trading window, the Code of Fair Disclosure and the Code of Conduct. The last topic is penalties and the Companies Act, 2013 angle. Sections 194 and 195 of the Companies Act, which once dealt with forward dealings and insider trading, were omitted with effect from 9 February 2018. So the law on insider trading now lives in securities law, and the Companies Act matters only for related provisions.

This chapter connects to the rest of Paper 5 through SEBI's powers, the other fraud and manipulation rules under the SEBI Act, listing obligations, takeovers and the enforcement framework. If you know who SEBI is and how it enforces, insider trading becomes an application of that knowledge. It also links to Company Law: directors, key managerial personnel and their duty of disclosure.

Insider trading is a favourite for written papers because it suits the ICSI answer format: state the provision, apply it to the facts, and conclude. Case-style questions ask you to decide whether a person is an insider, whether the information is UPSI and whether a trade is prohibited. The definitions are short and you can learn them fully. The compliance topics (trading window, codes, disclosures) also give you short-note questions where a structured list earns marks. Students who learn the definitions word for word and practise facts-based answers do well here.

Prohibition of Insider Trading: topics in the order to study them

  1. 1Insider Trading: Meaning and Legal FrameworkStart here to learn what the wrong is, why it is banned, and where the law sits: Section 12A of the SEBI Act and the 2015 Regulations.
  2. 2Key Definitions: Insider, UPSI and Connected PersonEvery problem begins by deciding who is an insider and what is UPSI, so you need these definitions before anything else.
  3. 3Communication of UPSI and Trading When in PossessionThese are the core prohibitions that apply the definitions, along with their exceptions and defences.
  4. 4Disclosures and Trading Window RestrictionsAfter the prohibitions, you learn the reporting duties and the closure of trading that help prevent breaches.
  5. 5Code of Fair Disclosure and Code of ConductThese codes are the company's internal system, and they make sense only once you know the disclosure and window rules they contain.
  6. 6Penalties and Related Provisions under Companies Act, 2013Study the consequences last, once you know what is prohibited, and link them to the related Companies Act provisions.

How to prepare Prohibition of Insider Trading

Treat this as a definitions-plus-application chapter. The words of the definitions decide the answers, so learn them closely and then practise applying them.

  1. Read Section 12A of the SEBI Act, 1992 first. Note its clauses on manipulative devices, fraud, insider trading, dealing while in possession of information, and acquisition of control. Know that clauses (d) and (e) are the insider trading ones.
  2. Write out the definitions of insider, connected person and UPSI in your own notes, close to the official wording. Note the look-back period used for connected persons and the 'generally available information' test for UPSI.
  3. List the kinds of events usually treated as UPSI, such as financial results, dividends, changes in capital structure, mergers, demergers, acquisitions and key management changes. Check the list against the current Regulations.
  4. For communication and trading, build a three-step answer: is the person an insider, is the information UPSI, and was there a trade or communication. Then check the exceptions and defences.
  5. Make a one-page chart of compliance tools: who must disclose, when, the trading window, pre-clearance, the Code of Fair Disclosure and the Code of Conduct. Revise it until you can list it from memory.
  6. Learn the penalty position and the Companies Act link. Remember that sections 194 and 195 are omitted. Note the penalty on non-disclosure in the explanatory statement under Section 102 and the lesser penalty rule in Section 446B for certain small companies.
  7. Practise at least five fact-based questions, writing each answer in ICSI style: provision, application, conclusion. Time yourself, as you have three hours per paper.

Common mistakes in Prohibition of Insider Trading

  • Quoting the Companies Act, 2013 as the law that bans insider trading.

    Fix: State clearly that both sections were omitted with effect from 9 February 2018. Cite Section 12A of the SEBI Act and the 2015 Regulations as the operative law.

  • Calling any confidential information UPSI.

    Fix: Check both limbs: the information is not generally available, and it is likely to materially affect the price once published.

  • Treating only directors and employees as insiders.

    Fix: Remember that connected persons and anyone with access to UPSI can be insiders, including outside advisers and relatives in suitable facts. Apply the definition, not the common meaning.

  • Writing the answer as a general essay without the provision.

    Fix: Follow ICSI style: quote the provision, apply it to the facts, and end with a clear conclusion on whether there is a breach.

  • Mixing up the Code of Fair Disclosure and the Code of Conduct.

    Fix: Remember the split: the Code of Fair Disclosure is about how the company publishes UPSI fairly, and the Code of Conduct governs the dealings of designated persons and insiders.

  • Ignoring exceptions and defences when a trade looks prohibited.

    Fix: Always check the permitted cases and the available defences before you conclude. Then state your conclusion with the reason.

Last-day revision: Prohibition of Insider Trading

  • Section 12A(d) of the SEBI Act bars insider trading. Section 12A(e) bars dealing while in possession of material or non-public information, and communicating it.
  • The detailed rules are in the SEBI (Prohibition of Insider Trading) Regulations, 2015.
  • An insider is a connected person or anyone in possession of, or having access to, UPSI.
  • A connected person includes someone who had a connection with the company in the six months before the act in question.
  • UPSI is information that is not generally available and that, once published, is likely to materially affect the price of securities.
  • Prohibited acts are communicating UPSI and trading while in possession of it, subject to the permitted exceptions.
  • Listed companies must have a Code of Fair Disclosure and a Code of Conduct.
  • The trading window is closed for designated persons when UPSI exists, and trades are generally barred then.
  • Disclosures are required from promoters, directors and key managerial personnel, and continual disclosure applies above a set trade value.
  • Sections 194 and 195 of the Companies Act, 2013 were omitted with effect from 9 February 2018.
  • Section 102(5) penalty: ₹50,000 or five times the benefit, whichever is higher, for default in the explanatory statement.
  • Section 446B halves penalties for OPCs, small companies, start-ups and Producer Companies, capped at ₹2 lakh for the company and ₹1 lakh for an officer or other person.

Prohibition of Insider Trading practice questions

Prohibition of Insider Trading in other exams

The same ground in other exams, if you are preparing for more than one or want another angle on it.

Prohibition of Insider Trading: frequently asked questions

Which law governs insider trading for CS Executive?

Section 12A of the SEBI Act, 1992 prohibits it, and the SEBI (Prohibition of Insider Trading) Regulations, 2015 give the detailed rules. Study both together.

Does the Companies Act, 2013 still have an insider trading section?

No. Sections 194 and 195 were omitted with effect from 9 February 2018. The Companies Act is relevant only for related provisions such as disclosure duties and penalties.

What is the first thing to check in an insider trading case question?

Check whether the person is an insider and whether the information is UPSI. Then see whether there was a trade or a communication, and look at any exception. Finish with a clear conclusion.

Is this chapter in Paper 5 Part I or Part II?

It falls in Paper 5, Capital Market and Securities Laws, within the securities laws part. That part carries 60 of the 100 marks in the paper.

How should I write answers on this chapter?

Write the provision first, then apply it to the facts given, then conclude. Use the exact definitions and keep each point short so the examiner can find it quickly.