FRM Part I · FRM Exam Part I · Simulation and Bootstrapping
A analyst wants to bootstrap the distribution of a 99% VaR estimate using 1,000 historical daily losses. Which statement best describes a limitation of the bootstrap in this application?
The bootstrap cannot generate a loss worse than the worst one in the original sample, because it only resamples observed values. This means extreme tail outcomes beyond the historical record are understated, which matters for high-confidence VaR. It does not require normality and can be applied to quantiles.
- AResampling with replacement can never produce a loss larger than the worst loss in the original sample, so the extreme tail is understatedCorrect
- BBootstrapping requires the losses to follow a normal distribution
- CBootstrapping always produces biased estimates of the sample mean
- DBootstrapping cannot be used for quantiles, only for means
Explanation
Bootstrap resamples contain only values observed in the original data, so no resampled loss can exceed the historical maximum. Tail risk beyond the observed history is therefore not captured. The bootstrap is nonparametric and does not require normality, and it can be applied to quantiles.
Did you get it right without looking?
One question tells you little. A timed set on Simulation and Bootstrapping shows your real accuracy, how long you take and where you lose marks.
More Simulation and Bootstrapping questions
- A risk analyst uses Monte Carlo simulation to estimate the expected payoff of a derivative. With 10,000 independent simulated payoffs, the s…
- An analyst uses the standard (iid) bootstrap to estimate the sampling distribution of the mean daily return from 500 historical observations…
- In an antithetic variates scheme, a simulation uses each standard normal draw Z and its mirror -Z to produce two payoff estimates X1 and X2.…
- A analyst uses a control variate to price an Asian option. The simulated Asian option payoff X has variance 36 and the control variate Y (a …
- A risk manager simulates the 99% tail loss of a portfolio and finds that very few plain Monte Carlo draws fall in the extreme loss region. W…
- A bank uses a bootstrap with historical returns to estimate the standard error of a 99% VaR estimate. Which statement about the effect of th…