CS Professional · Drafting, Pleadings and Appearances · Art of Opinion Writing
A client's instructions to the opinion writer run to twelve pages with correspondence and emails. In drafting the opinion, the writer includes a short section titled 'Facts'. What is the best practice for this section?
The facts section should briefly summarise only the material facts relevant to the questions, in a logical or chronological order, and record any assumptions made. Copying everything buries the issues, while omitting facts leaves the opinion without foundation.
- AReproduce all twelve pages verbatim so nothing is omitted
- BOmit the facts since the client already knows them
- CSummarise only the facts material to the questions, in logical or chronological order, and note any assumptions madeCorrect
- DState the facts only after giving the conclusion
Explanation
The facts section should be a concise, accurate summary of the facts relevant to the questions, ordered logically, with assumptions stated expressly. Verbatim reproduction is wasteful and omitting facts leaves the opinion without context.
Did you get it right without looking?
One question tells you little. A timed set on Art of Opinion Writing shows your real accuracy, how long you take and where you lose marks.
More Art of Opinion Writing questions
- Arjun Steels Ltd receives an opinion from its professional that a proposed buyback complies with the law. The board later decides to proceed…
- Anand Textiles Ltd. asks its company secretary, Meera, for a written opinion on whether it can defer a dividend declared last month. Meera h…
- An opinion for Bharat Agro Ltd. frames the question as: 'Whether the company is in trouble?' The reviewing partner asks for it to be redraft…
- Anand Pharma Ltd, a public company, asks whether it can give a loan to a firm in which a director is a partner. The opinion must address a r…
- A company secretary is asked to opine on whether a clause in Orbit Pharma Ltd.'s agreement is enforceable. Which feature distinguishes this …
- Nirmal Pharma Ltd asks a professional for an opinion on a dispute. The professional notes that the opinion rests on documents supplied by th…