FRM Part I · FRM Exam Part I · Simulation and Bootstrapping
A firm plans to use Monte Carlo simulation to assess portfolio risk and generates scenarios from a model calibrated to a calm historical period. Which is the most important limitation of this approach?
Simulation results depend on the assumed model and calibrated inputs, so a misspecified model, such as one fitted to a calm period, yields precise-looking but wrong risk estimates. More draws reduce sampling error only, not model risk.
- AIncreasing the number of simulations will eliminate model risk
- BSimulation output is only as reliable as the assumed model and its inputs, so misspecification produces precise but wrong resultsCorrect
- CMonte Carlo simulation cannot be applied to nonlinear instruments
- DSimulated results are always identical across different random seeds
Explanation
Simulation error from sampling shrinks with more draws, but errors from a misspecified model or poorly calibrated parameters persist. A model calibrated to calm data may understate risk in stressed markets. Simulation handles nonlinear instruments well, and results vary with the seed.
Did you get it right without looking?
One question tells you little. A timed set on Simulation and Bootstrapping shows your real accuracy, how long you take and where you lose marks.
More Simulation and Bootstrapping questions
- A bootstrap of 1,000 resamples produces estimates of a portfolio's beta. The sorted estimates give the 25th smallest value as 0.82 and the 9…
- An analyst has a sample of 200 daily returns and wants to estimate the standard error of the sample median using the bootstrap. Which proced…
- A risk manager simulates the price of a call option using a control variate. The simulated payoff X has mean estimate 8.40 and the control Y…
- In a Monte Carlo simulation of a portfolio's one-day loss, which statement about antithetic variates is correct?
- A risk analyst uses Monte Carlo simulation to estimate the expected payoff of a derivative. With 10,000 independent simulated payoffs, the s…
- An analyst uses the standard (iid) bootstrap to estimate the sampling distribution of the mean daily return from 500 historical observations…