FRM Part I · FRM Exam Part I · Simulation and Bootstrapping
A Monte Carlo analyst compares a simulation using antithetic variates with one using the same number of independent draws. Which statement best describes why antithetic variates can reduce the standard error of the estimate?
Antithetic variates pair each draw z with -z, producing negatively correlated payoffs for monotonic payoff functions. The average of each pair then has lower variance than two independent draws, reducing the standard error of the Monte Carlo estimate.
- AEach pair of draws uses z and -z, giving negatively correlated payoffs whose average has lower variance when the payoff is monotonic in zCorrect
- BEach pair uses the same z twice, so the number of random numbers generated is halved without changing variance
- CThe method replaces random draws with a deterministic grid, eliminating sampling error entirely
- DThe method increases the sample standard deviation so that confidence intervals are wider and more conservative
Explanation
Antithetic variates pair z with -z. For a payoff monotonic in z, the two payoffs are negatively correlated, so the variance of their average is less than that of two independent draws. Reusing the same z gives perfect positive correlation and does not help; the method does not remove sampling error.
Did you get it right without looking?
One question tells you little. A timed set on Simulation and Bootstrapping shows your real accuracy, how long you take and where you lose marks.
More Simulation and Bootstrapping questions
- A firm uses Monte Carlo simulation to value a portfolio, drawing correlated asset returns from a multivariate normal model calibrated in a c…
- An analyst bootstraps the mean of a sample of 100 returns with sample standard deviation 4%. Using many resamples of size 100, the bootstrap…
- A firm simulates portfolio losses with a Monte Carlo model that draws asset returns from a multivariate normal distribution calibrated to ca…
- A risk manager bootstraps daily returns of an asset by drawing individual returns independently with replacement, but the returns show stron…
- A firm plans to use Monte Carlo simulation to assess portfolio risk and generates scenarios from a model calibrated to a calm historical per…
- Compared with a Monte Carlo simulation that assumes returns follow a normal distribution, what is the principal advantage of the bootstrap f…