ACCA Strategic Professional · Strategic Business Leader · Public sector governance
A state-owned water utility has a board appointed by the government. A review finds ministers regularly direct the board to delay tariff increases, even where the regulator says costs require them. Which governance concern does this most directly raise?
The main concern is political interference that undermines the board's independence and the utility's objectives. When ministers direct tariff decisions against regulatory advice, the board cannot act on cost evidence, weakening accountability and the organisation's financial sustainability.
- APolitical interference undermining board independence and the utility's objectivesCorrect
- BExcessive managerial autonomy
- COver-reliance on private equity funding
- DLack of a marketing strategy
Explanation
Ministers overriding board decisions against regulator advice compromises board independence and clear objectives, a recognised risk in state-owned enterprises. The case shows too much government control, not excessive management autonomy.
Did you get it right without looking?
One question tells you little. A timed set on Public sector governance shows your real accuracy, how long you take and where you lose marks.
More Public sector governance questions
- A regional education department is accountable upward to a minister through strict output targets (exam pass rates), but parents, teachers a…
- A regional health authority publishes its board minutes, annual performance targets, audited accounts and details of how it awards contracts…
- The Ministry of Transport in a country publishes a detailed annual report on how it spent its budget, the outcomes achieved and the decision…
- A government agency publishes a long annual report full of activity counts, such as the number of inspections carried out, but no informatio…
- The Ministry of Water in a national government publishes its annual budget, contract awards and performance targets on an open website so th…
- A national audit office reviews whether a government agency's spending achieved its objectives economically, efficiently and effectively, an…