FRM Part II · FRM Exam Part II · Credit Scoring and Rating
A validator compares a rating model's performance on the development sample with a later holdout sample and finds a much lower accuracy ratio on the holdout. Which issue is the most likely explanation?
Overfitting is the most likely explanation. When a model performs much worse on a holdout sample than on its development data, it has fitted noise specific to the development sample rather than stable relationships, so out-of-sample discriminatory power drops.
- AOverfitting to the development sampleCorrect
- BExcessive rating migration
- CLow default correlation
- DUse of a through-the-cycle philosophy
Explanation
A large deterioration from in-sample to out-of-sample performance is the classic sign of overfitting: the model captured noise specific to the development data. Migration, default correlation and rating philosophy affect stability or test interpretation but do not explain a gap between in-sample and holdout discrimination.
Did you get it right without looking?
One question tells you little. A timed set on Credit Scoring and Rating shows your real accuracy, how long you take and where you lose marks.
More Credit Scoring and Rating questions
- A bank's rating model validation team finds that, for grade 6, the average estimated PD was 1.5% each year over five years, while the realiz…
- A bank validates its corporate rating model by plotting the cumulative proportion of all borrowers (ranked from worst to best score) against…
- Which statement best describes the conflict-of-interest criticism of the issuer-pays model used by many rating agencies?
- A bank's credit portfolio manager observes that rating agency ratings of corporate issuers show strong rating persistence, with downgrades a…
- A structured finance arranger pays a rating agency a fee for rating each new tranche, and the arranger can choose among several agencies bef…
- A bank validates a new application scorecard on a holdout sample. At a given cutoff, the cumulative share of defaulters scoring below the cu…