ACCA Strategic Professional · Strategic Business Leader · Governance scope and approaches
After a collapse, an inquiry into Corvane Bank found that the board had approved a high-risk trading strategy because executive bonuses were tied solely to short-term trading profits, with no adjustment for risk taken. Which governance lesson does this most directly illustrate?
The case shows that pay should align executives with long-term interests and the organisation's risk appetite. Bonuses based only on short-term profit with no risk adjustment encourage excessive risk-taking, which is an agency problem that remuneration design should prevent.
- ARemuneration structures should align executives' incentives with long-term shareholder and stakeholder interests and risk appetiteCorrect
- BExecutive pay should be set by the executives themselves to ensure motivation
- CBonuses should be based entirely on share price in the current year
- DRisk management should be delegated wholly to the internal audit function
Explanation
Short-term profit-based bonuses without risk adjustment encourage excessive risk-taking, an agency problem. Remuneration should be linked to long-term performance and risk appetite, often through deferral and clawback. Basing pay on current-year share price repeats the short-term problem, and risk ownership cannot be handed wholly to internal audit.
Did you get it right without looking?
One question tells you little. A timed set on Governance scope and approaches shows your real accuracy, how long you take and where you lose marks.
More Governance scope and approaches questions
- Corvale Ltd's majority shareholder, who also chairs the board, has arranged for the company to buy services from another business he owns at…
- Delmora Bank is considering a policy of engaging more actively with its customers, employees and local communities, believing this will prot…
- Zenara Holdings is listed, and its shareholders appoint directors to run the business on their behalf. The directors, who hold almost no sha…
- Dravik Industries has a controlling family holding 55% of its shares through a holding company, and the remaining shares are held by many sm…
- A medical research charity is funded by donations and government grants. Its trustees are unpaid volunteers, and the donors want assurance t…
- Tamsin Corp is cross-listed in a market with a prescriptive, legislated governance regime that imposes fixed requirements on board compositi…