CMA Foundation · Fundamentals of Business Laws and Business Communication · Primary and Subordinate Legislation
An Act empowers a Board to make regulations on listing norms. The Board frames a regulation that is within its power, but the regulation was never published in the Official Gazette although the Act requires publication. Which statement is most accurate?
The regulation is open to challenge because the Board did not follow a mandatory procedural requirement of the parent Act. Delegated authority must be exercised both within its substantive limits and in the manner prescribed, such as publication in the Official Gazette.
- AThe regulation is valid because the Board acted within its subject-matter power
- BThe regulation is open to challenge for non-compliance with a mandatory procedural requirement of the parent ActCorrect
- CThe regulation is automatically converted into an Act by Parliament
- DThe regulation is valid only for listed companies
Explanation
Delegated power must be exercised within the substance and the procedure laid down by the enabling Act. If publication is mandatory, failure to publish is a procedural defect which makes the regulation open to challenge. Having subject-matter power alone does not cure it, and no automatic conversion into an Act occurs.
Did you get it right without looking?
One question tells you little. A timed set on Primary and Subordinate Legislation shows your real accuracy, how long you take and where you lose marks.
More Primary and Subordinate Legislation questions
- Which of the following is the usual reason why Parliament permits delegated legislation instead of enacting every detail itself?
- An Act authorises the Central Government to make rules 'for carrying out the purposes of the Act'. A rule framed under it is later notified …
- An Act authorises the Central Government to make rules 'for carrying out the purposes of this Act'. A rule framed under it conflicts with an…
- A High Court in State X decides a point of law. Later, a trial court in State Y faces the same point, and the Supreme Court has not decided …
- In the Indian legal system, law made directly by Parliament or a State Legislature through an Act is generally described as:
- Parliament passes an Act that lays down the policy for regulating a trade but leaves the detailed procedure to be filled in by the Central G…