Skip to content

CFA Level I · CFA Level I Exam · Company Analysis: Past, Present, and Future

An analyst compares two firms in the same industry. Firm X reports a sales growth of 6% and a stable gross margin, while Firm Y reports 6% sales growth but its gross margin has fallen for four years because of price discounting to hold market share. Which conclusion is most appropriate?

Firm Y's growth is likely lower quality and its competitive position deserves scrutiny. Falling gross margin from discounting to hold share signals weak pricing power, so equal sales growth does not justify identical forecasts for both firms.

  1. AFirm Y's growth is likely lower quality, and its competitive position deserves further scrutinyCorrect
  2. BFirm Y has the stronger pricing power because it holds share
  3. CBoth firms should receive the same growth assumptions because sales growth is equal

Explanation

Equal sales growth hides differences in quality. Firm Y is buying growth through discounts, which erodes margins and signals weaker pricing power or competitive pressure. Giving both the same assumptions ignores this evidence.

Did you get it right without looking?

One question tells you little. A timed set on Company Analysis: Past, Present, and Future shows your real accuracy, how long you take and where you lose marks.

Practise Company Analysis: Past, Present, and FutureFree diagnostic mock

More Company Analysis: Past, Present, and Future questions