Skip to content

IAI Actuarial Core Principles · Business Management · Strategy, competitive advantage, strategic decision process and PEST analysis

Bharat Mutual, an Indian asset manager, claims to be both the cheapest fund house and the most premium, with the most personalised advice, across all customer segments. Its costs are rising and its margins are below those of rivals that chose a single approach. According to Porter, which description best fits its position?

Bharat Mutual is stuck in the middle. It tries to be cheapest and most premium across all segments without committing to one generic strategy, so it lacks a sustainable advantage and earns below-average margins, as Porter predicted for such firms.

  1. AStuck in the middle, with no sustainable competitive advantageCorrect
  2. BPursuing a hybrid focus strategy that Porter recommends
  3. CAchieving cost leadership through scale
  4. DHolding a differentiation advantage through reputation
  5. Protected by high barriers to entry

Explanation

Porter argued that a firm failing to commit to cost leadership, differentiation or focus becomes stuck in the middle and earns below-average returns. Bharat Mutual's rising costs and weak margins fit this. A hybrid is not recommended in his original framework, and the facts show no cost or differentiation advantage.

Did you get it right without looking?

One question tells you little. A timed set on Strategy, competitive advantage, strategic decision process and PEST analysis shows your real accuracy, how long you take and where you lose marks.

Practise Strategy, competitive advantage, strategic decision process and PEST analysisFree diagnostic mock

More Strategy, competitive advantage, strategic decision process and PEST analysis questions