CS Professional · Corporate Restructuring, Valuation and Insolvency · Overview of Business Valuation
Bhima Pharma Ltd is valued for a proposed sale of its entire business to a strategic buyer, and separately for a minority shareholder's exit in a squeeze-out of a few shares. A consultant states that the same number must be used in both cases. Which response is most appropriate?
The consultant is incorrect. Value is purpose-specific: a controlling sale to a strategic buyer may include synergies and control, while a minority exit is valued on a different basis. So the same business can legitimately carry different values for different purposes.
- AIncorrect, because the purpose and the standard of value can differ, so the value may differ for each purposeCorrect
- BCorrect, because every business has one single intrinsic value for all purposes
- CCorrect, because the Companies Act prescribes one formula for all transactions
- DIncorrect, because valuation is not required for a sale of business
Explanation
Valuation depends on its purpose, the premise of value (going concern or otherwise), and the interest valued, such as control versus minority. A strategic buyer may pay for synergies and control, which a minority exit may not reflect. There is no single universal value or single prescribed formula.
Did you get it right without looking?
One question tells you little. A timed set on Overview of Business Valuation shows your real accuracy, how long you take and where you lose marks.
More Overview of Business Valuation questions
- A valuer is assessing Ravi Steel Ltd, whose industry is cyclical and currently at a peak of demand. The valuer plans to capitalise this year…
- Mahesh Engineering Ltd has gone into liquidation and its assets must be sold quickly. A valuer is asked for the realisable amount from an or…
- A valuer is asked to value Kaveri Foods Ltd as of 31 March. Management hands over projections that are far more optimistic than the company'…
- Mehra Engineering Pvt Ltd engages a registered valuer for a share swap. The valuer finds that his brother holds a significant stake in the t…
- Meera Foods Ltd has net assets of Rs 300 crore at book value. A valuer finds land carried at Rs 40 crore is worth Rs 130 crore, and inventor…
- Anita, a company secretary, is asked why a company's valuation is needed before a scheme of amalgamation. Which is the most direct purpose?