ACCA Strategic Professional · Advanced Performance Management · Performance and reward
Brightwell Logistics pays warehouse supervisors a bonus for achieving a target of 98% on-time dispatch. Supervisors have begun recording orders as dispatched when they are merely packed, and have stopped reporting delayed orders. This is an example of which problem with performance-related reward?
This is gaming, or manipulation of reported data, caused by linking a bonus to a single target. Supervisors misclassify packed orders as dispatched and hide delays to hit 98%. Remedies include independent data capture, verification of reported results and a balanced set of measures so one number cannot be exploited.
- AGaming or data manipulation caused by tying reward to a single reported targetCorrect
- BInflation of the target due to benchmarking
- CLack of controllability of the measure
- DOver-reliance on subjective appraisal
Explanation
Supervisors are misreporting data to reach a bonus threshold, which is gaming caused by pay depending on one reported metric. Controls such as independent data capture, audit of reported figures and balanced measures reduce it. The issue is not controllability or subjective appraisal, since the measure is objective but falsifiable.
Did you get it right without looking?
One question tells you little. A timed set on Performance and reward shows your real accuracy, how long you take and where you lose marks.
More Performance and reward questions
- Orchid Logistics operates a team bonus pool for a depot of 40 drivers, paid equally if the depot meets on-time delivery targets. Over time, …
- Harrow Components plc pays its production managers a bonus of 10% of salary if monthly output exceeds budget. Managers have started shipping…
- Halden Group introduces performance-related pay for call centre staff based on the number of calls handled per hour. Customer satisfaction s…
- Orlin Co operates a team-based bonus for its production cell of 10 operators. Output has risen, but the most productive operators complain t…
- Brindle plc's finance director is paid a bonus based solely on this year's reported earnings per share. She delays a major R&D project, whic…
- Norvale Group's remuneration committee is reviewing the executive scheme. Executives receive large share options exercisable after only 12 m…