CA Final · Advanced Auditing, Assurance and Professional Ethics · Due Diligence, Investigation & Forensic Accounting
CA Meera is asked by the board of Himalaya Foods Ltd to investigate alleged misappropriation of inventory. While collecting evidence, she obtains a copy of an email from the company server and plans to rely on it in later legal proceedings. Which action best preserves the evidential value of the electronic record?
She should make a forensic image or verified copy, document the chain of custody and hash values, and leave the original untouched. This maintains the integrity and authenticity of the electronic evidence, so it can be relied upon later in legal proceedings.
- APrint the email and discard the original to avoid duplication
- BForward the email to her personal account so that it is stored outside the company
- CCreate a forensic image or verified copy, document the chain of custody and hash values, and avoid altering the original dataCorrect
- DAsk the suspected employee to extract the email and hand it over, as he knows the system best
Explanation
Digital evidence must be preserved without alteration, with documented chain of custody and integrity checks such as hash values. Discarding the original or forwarding it weakens authenticity. Letting the suspect extract the data compromises independence and invites tampering.
Did you get it right without looking?
One question tells you little. A timed set on Due Diligence, Investigation & Forensic Accounting shows your real accuracy, how long you take and where you lose marks.
More Due Diligence, Investigation & Forensic Accounting questions
- CA Tanvi is the statutory auditor of Lotus Foods Ltd. Her firm is invited by the audit committee to conduct a forensic investigation into al…
- While auditing Bharat Forgings Ltd, the auditor suspects that the Chief Financial Officer has diverted funds through fictitious vendors. Und…
- During a forensic investigation of Ratnam Traders Pvt Ltd, the investigator finds that the purchase manager approved invoices of a vendor wh…
- While auditing Ganga Pharma Ltd., the statutory auditor, CA Rohan, finds indications that an officer of the company has committed a fraud in…
- A chartered accountant is appointed to conduct a forensic investigation into suspected misappropriation of cash at a branch of Bharat Textil…
- Meera, a CA in practice, is the statutory auditor of Orion Pharma Ltd. The company asks her firm to also perform a forensic investigation in…